Saturday, 25 June, 2022
HomeJudiciary2 senior Punjab cops challenge DGP appointment on ‘malafide grounds’

2 senior Punjab cops challenge DGP appointment on ‘malafide grounds’

IPS officers Mohammad Mustafa and Siddharth Chattopadhyaya challenge UPSC’s recommendation of 3 junior officers over them in Supreme Court.

Text Size:

New Delhi: The Supreme Court’s bid to minimise political influence in the appointment of director generals of police (DGPs) in states through a panel shortlisted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) has hit another obstacle.

Now two senior IPS officers from Punjab have challenged the recent appointment of the state DGP Dinkar Gupta — by the UPSC on “malafide grounds” in the top court.

Mohammad Mustafa, a 1985-batch officer, and Siddharth Chattopadhyaya, a 1986-batch officer, have also challenged the UPSC’s recommendation of three junior officers over them. The matter is listed for hearing Monday.

Gupta, a 1987-batch officer was appointed as Punjab DGP by the state government after his name was empaneled by the UPSC for the post. Gupta superseded five senior officers, including Mustafa and Chattopadhyaya.

“We have challenged it on malafide grounds,” Mustafa told ThePrint.

“I am more eligible for the post of DGP according to all the three criteria set by the Supreme Court — number of years in service, very good record and range of experience,” Mustafa said.

“The UPSC was deliberately kept in the dark while it was recommending the officers for the post due to vested interests…so we decided to take the matter to court,” he said.

Also read: UPSC has a plan for new 10% quota in civil services, and it’s anything but smooth

‘Completely arbitrary’

The political career of Mustafa’s wife was flagged at the meeting conducted by the commission to discuss the appointment, at which chief secretary Karan Avtar Singh and former DGP Suresh Arora were also present, said sources.

His wife, Razia Sultana, is a minister in Captain Amarinder Singh’s state cabinet.

Earlier, Mustafa had told ThePrint that the commission came up with no grounds while ignoring the senior officers for the post.

“It was completely arbitrary… How can this be allowed?” he had said.

Both Mustafa and Chattopadhyay have two years of service left before retirement.

The UPSC is not appointing any officer who has less than two years of service left as DGP, thereby superseding senior officers in states like Bihar, Haryana and Punjab where DGPs have recently been appointed.

Also read: Why UPSC is shortlisting IPS officers to become state DGPs

Punjab police tussle

Last year, a full-blown war broke out within the Punjab police when Chattopadhyaya, then DGP (human resource development), told the Punjab and Haryana high court that he was probing the role of Gupta, along with his predecessor, Arora in a drug case, and was therefore being targeted by them.

A month later, he was transferred as DGP Punjab state power Corporation limited (PSPCL).

Some opposition parties have, therefore, questioned the UPSC about why it didn’t take cognisance of these serious allegations against Gupta before empaneling him for the top post.

The UPSC, which was asked by the Supreme Court in January, to empanel officers for the post of DGP in states, has been under the scanner ever since the order.

Earlier this month, former DGP of Uttar Pradesh, Prakash Singh, moved the court challenging UPSC’s implementation of the court orders.

According to Singh, the court’s directive that DGPs should have a fixed tenure of two years has led the UPSC to unfairly exclude senior IPS officers close to retirement from the promotion exercise.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism



    • i agree with the above comments fully. the workings off the punjab-police after the 1993/ 1994 period= middle 1990s has been very lack lustre considering its rich history-traditions. corruption and protection of anti social elements within its ranks has been its mainstay, where as earlier these very same tainted persons would have been identified and sacked after being named and shamed in the punjab police gazette. one remembers rather nostalgically from my travels in the punjab, police officers like mr s.s. bains, mr g.s. bhullar and his younger brother g.i.s. bhullar. r.p. joshi. mps-nps aulakh. k.l likhi. surjit singh. d.s. mangat. s.c .jain, mr bhatti. and aa siddiqui and many others some sadly no longer among us who worked honestly under punjab chief ministers like mr darbara singh and later mr barnala and mr beant singh.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular