Monday, June 5, 2023
Support Our Journalism
HomeIndiaWe are shrinking India by highlighting our differences & young India isn't...

We are shrinking India by highlighting our differences & young India isn’t happy: Harsha Bhogle

Cricket commentator and writer Harsha Bhogle said people in power needed to focus on creating opportunities so the next generation isn't burdened with talk of war & cultural differences.

Text Size:

I think young India is speaking to us. It is telling us what it wants to be; and that it doesn’t want to be what we are telling it to be.

For many years now, I have been bullish on India. There is a reason. My generation grew up in an India that was still feeling the after effects of being plundered by colonial England. My parents’ generation weren’t just short on resources, they also had their confidence sucked away by a terrible, repressive environment. We were luckier but we still didn’t know what we were capable of

I was in my early 30s when two quiet gentlemen brought about a revolution. Maybe Narasimha Rao was forced into opening up India by the calamity that would have befallen us otherwise. Maybe Manmohan Singh had no choice but to deliver the budgets he did. But they saw the writing on the wall and they acted

The effects of liberalisation on my generation were beyond what we could have dreamt of. If at 32, I was asked to imagine an India of opportunity, I wouldn’t have imagined half of what I was privileged to see. As India opened up we were allowed to believe we could be as good as anyone else in the world. And to our great joy, we discovered that we were indeed as good. We had never thought of ourselves that way. We became the blessed generation and our children benefited from it, they dreamt higher than we knew.

India under 30 now is brimming with possibility. Their minds have been opened, they are proud Indians but they are citizens of the world. And India under 40 is showing that it has the ability to take on the world by getting into leadership positions. This India is more confident, better informed, more aware and far more ambitious than we could ever have been. It is a beautiful India and it has been nurtured by people who are liberal and secular at heart. Those are beautiful words.

So what should we, the generation that reaped the benefits of liberalisation and openness, be doing for the next? Quite simply, putting an arm round their shoulder, patting them on the back and getting out of their way for we can at best be the banks to their rivers.

This is a great time to be a benevolent government; to think of education, of infrastructure, of technology; to remove barriers, to embrace openness, to free this beautiful generation to take India beyond where we think it can be.

So why are we creating fear? Why are we driving wedges into society? Instead of giving this generation wings to fly, why are we putting a weight on their backs? Why are we obsessed about our neighbours when, as an economic entity, they aren’t even in the same book, let alone on the same page as us?. We are shrinking our country by highlighting our differences and young India is telling us it isn’t happy.

So, other than writing lengthy emotional posts, something that is easy to do, what should my generation do? Forget changing the world, we can encourage five people, maybe ten and that will be enough. I have seen that happen in front of my eyes. At a low point in my career, I got to work with young people. Their energy was an eye-opener. All I had to do was pat them on the back sometimes, provide a window to a new world. No more. In the last three years, these young people have made CricBuzz an extraordinary success. It is just a small example in a small sector but it tells us what is possible.

Winning elections isn’t a good enough reason for highlighting differences between us. My naive view of the world tells me that creating opportunities through liberalisation and openness and togetherness could win more elections.

So my appeal to people in power, to those my age and older is simply this. We have played a very nice innings, we have been lucky to have been Indians for the last twenty five years. Let us not burden the next generation with talk of war and cultural differences. They are going to be better than we were. Let them be. In a happy, open, secular, liberal world, they can become the best in the world.

Pardon me if this post appears self-indulgent. These are just my thoughts and that is why they appear on a personal platform.

(The article was originally published on Harsha Bhogle’s Facebook page)

Also read: This is why Modi will win the war protesters have waged against him on CAA


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Can’t there be a view that is different from that of the ‘Bhakts?’
    Can’t there be a way of looking at life differently from one singular way of the ‘Bhakts?’
    There can be if we accept each individual is different and so will have and is entitled to his own ways of looking at things and arriving at his/her own conclusions.
    That is FREEDOM.
    That is DEMOCRACY.

  2. Exactly the words me or at least some persons from my generation would like to speak.
    When we have enough good things to do why we are focusing on the wrong things
    which in no way leads to prosperity to the nation and its inhabitants.Now we are
    fighting among ourselves when other nations overtake us in every aspect and we
    are happy to go backward fighting for religion and division.

  3. Looks like Harsha is giving cricket commentary for a football match! It appears that he has not understood the issues of CAA and NRC in the right context and has generally cobbled together his ideas on good, sensitive, sympathetic government with a tone which is conciliatory but with a deeper message. He is of course entitled to his views but one does expect some balance and sound logic in his judgment. CAA is passed by both houses of parliament. If there is any dissent about it, it ought to be in SC or peacefully on streets. Students are expected to protest peacefully and not allow themselves to be hijacked by anti social elements. Police have not entered their campus before the mob turned violent! So one cant start complaining Police turned violent and put cart before the horse!

    There are many critical questions around NRC which need to be sorted out and they are much beyond support for or opposition to Hindutva. One expected Harsha to analyze them as critically and clinically as he does when he is doing commentary on cricket!

  4. Chalo subkuch baat lete hai, Desh mera yanha aye woh bhi mere ; hum bhi tere , This country log aye gaye sub milkar, nation Ban gaya.

  5. Harsha Bhogle is being lionised / applauded for expressing a perfectly innocuous opinion. Stands out like an albino in a herd of conformity.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular