Saturday, December 10, 2022
HomeIndiaNGO group VANI calls FCRA amendments 'death blow', wants them referred to...

NGO group VANI calls FCRA amendments ‘death blow’, wants them referred to Parliament panel

VANI says India needs international collaborations for Covid battle, but FCRA Bill, now passed by Lok Sabha, will stifle the NGO sector.

Text Size:

New Delhi: The Voluntary Action Network India (VANI), an association of development organisations, released a statement Monday saying that the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2020, should be referred to a select committee of Parliament.

The FCRA Bill, VANI’s statement said, would be a “death blow to the development relief, scientific research and community support work of the NGO community” as it prohibits collaboration with other Indian organisations.

VANI also said at a time when India is battling a deadly disease like Covid-19, there is much at stake and international collaborations need to be encouraged. So, the enactment of the Bill would be a “model of control over and above the rules, regulations and certification processes, that stifles this important sector”.

The FCRA (Amendment) Bill 2020 was passed by the Lok Sabha Monday evening, with Opposition leaders objecting to it and terming it a means to “crush dissent”.

Congress leader Gaurav Gogoi said the government should not be in a hurry to pass the Bill. “Political dissent will be stopped with this Bill. Do not be in a hurry, send the Bill to the standing committee. Call the NGOs and have a dialogue to find solutions,” he said.

“Due to the 20 per cent cap on administrative expenditure, many NGOs will shut and many people will become jobless,” he said.

Also read: Modi govt tables FCRA amendments, opposition & NGOs call it fatal blow to civil society work

‘Bill will make impossible for NGOs to function’

VANI’s statement said the FCRA amendments assume that all NGOs receiving foreign grants are guilty, unless proven otherwise. It said the amendments would make it impossible for NGOs to function and lead to possible harassment of these groups.

“This makes NGOs open to possible harassment via queries which can be raised on almost any activity. This would impede collaborations and any other constructive activity they do,” the statement read.

“This restriction, when added to the existing restrictions prohibiting Indian organisations that win foreign research grants from sub-contracting a foreign institution, runs against the core mission of the government’s desire to strengthen India’s science/research performance.”

The statement also said that once the amendments are enforced, collaborations, even with national NGOs that are compliant with FCRA regulations, will be curtailed, as the Bill talks of no sub-granting.

“These amendments are therefore killing the overall spirit of collaboration,” it said.

Taking about reducing the administrative expenses to 20 per cent from 50 per cent, the statement said that it will act as a “major blow”.

“The term administrative expenses in FCRA rules is defined to include all salaries (except for school teachers, doctors, and field researchers, trainers). This means all the salaries of outreach workers, field staff who support villagers and rural communities are also counted as administrative expenses,” the statement said.

“This amendment will be a major blow to organisations in terms of payment of salaries, professional fees, utility bills, travel and other such expenditure,” it added.

Also read: FCRA Bill not against NGOs, meant to stop misuse of foreign funds, says minister Nityanand Rai

‘Govt should not ignore work done by NGOs’

VANI further said by bringing in this amendment, the government of India was not recognising the diversity of NGOs, which include world-class science organisations.

These amendments, it said, will crush their competitiveness and creativity.

The statement added that these new rules may be intended to control the vast number of NGOs which engage in dubious charitable activities, and that VANI stands with the government of India in its efforts to put down such activities, but it should not ignore the good work done by some organisations.

Another provision in the Bill, asking 20,000 charities to move their FCRA accounts to State Bank of India in Delhi, will be “hugely disruptive”, the network said.

“Many will not be able to operate these accounts properly as the home branch will be in Delhi,” the statement said.

VANI added with limited domestic philanthropy, guidelines that criminalise activities of even those certified as FCRA compliant will lead to the shutting down of thousands of small NGOs that enable good work and are dependent on legal funds obtained internationally. “This will be also endangering the livelihoods of those dependent on them for a vocation,” it stated.

Also read: UPA made Indira’s draconian FCRA tougher, Modi govt’s amendments will now make it worse


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Why is it that those who shout & squeal the loudest are always those whose insidious agendas are at the greatest risk of being exposed?

  2. NGOs means “service to society”, right? An unsolicited advice advice in late 1990s- “Just open an NGO. You only have to maintain a register. Money will come; no questions asked”
    Does that mean that the finance to these organizations is not / should not be regulated? Should not the NGOs play by a rule? Just asking.
    Appreciate all REAL social service, definitely.

  3. Who is giving you money? Why? If they want to give money, they should give elected government through proper channels. Who gave you rights to tale forgein money? What is your business if indians who know you and see you in real life know what you really are and don’t give a penny. All NGO people use iPhone and expensive gadgets, is this what money is given for. To say nothing of expensive SUVs. We are not kids here. The money is used for anti government causes and used to buy votes for congress and left.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular