Monday, 4 July, 2022
HomeThePrint #OTCWHO chief scientist denies 'Covid-19 cover-up', says no reason to think China...

WHO chief scientist denies ‘Covid-19 cover-up’, says no reason to think China hiding data

At ThePrint’s third digital Off The Cuff, WHO chief scientist Soumya Swaminathan says China sharing its expertise with teams all over the world.

Text Size:

New Delhi: World Health Organisation (WHO) chief scientist Soumya Swaminathan has defended the UN agency’s response to the coronavirus pandemic, saying it had been giving timely warnings as and when it gained more information. 

In conversation with Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta at ThePrint’s Off the Cuff Saturday, she expressed hope that the discord in the WHO’s relationship with the US would prove “temporary”.

“We are open to an audit and an investigation into how the organisation responded to the pandemic,” said Swaminathan, when asked about allegations, including from US President Donald Trump, that the WHO played down the threat from coronavirus, which originated in China, in the initial days. 

Swaminathan, a member of the WHO leadership team, claimed the organisation had been “fair, transparent and as technically informed as possible” in its response.

Trump’s accusations and decision to cut WHO funding

On 15 April, Donald Trump halted US funding to the WHO pending a review, after accusing the agency of “mismanaging and covering up the spread of the coronavirus”. The US currently accounts for the highest number of coronavirus cases as well as deaths.  

Trump had alleged that WHO director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus had a close relationship with China and he had delayed declaring the outbreak a public health emergency. 

The US has been the largest contributor to the WHO, which is funded by voluntary donations and member states, accounting for 14.67 per cent of the total contribution.

Swaminathan, former director general of the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), the country’s apex medical research body, denied any cover-up by the WHO, adding that it had been briefing the media about every new development regarding the pandemic.


Also read: Coronavirus has brought India’s almighty Centre back, and Modi’s unlikely to give up control


Is China hiding data?

Asked whether the data coming out of China raised any suspicion that the country may be hiding something, Soumya Swaminathan said, “As of now I have not seen anything that makes me or any of my colleagues suspicious.”

The team of technical experts that had visited China in January included representatives of the US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and National Institutes of Health (NIH). They collected a huge amount of data, she added.  

“They visited Wuhan to see how the situation was being tackled and prepared a report,” Swaminathan said, adding that China had been sharing their expertise from time to time with teams all over the world, not just the WHO. 

“They have been extremely open to dialogues and discussions. We speak to them on a regular basis. They are a part of many of our committees. They are going to work with us on vaccine development – they already have two candidate vaccines in human trials,” she said.

Asked why Trump was unhappy with the WHO, Swaminathan said she could not answer that question. However, she pointed out that, at the level of scientists, “our collaborations have always been excellent. We work very closely with both the CDC and NIH”.

“The US is one of our valued partners, not just in terms of the resources, but also in terms of the technical collaborations we have had with their institutions,” she said. 

“We have developed a strong bond over the years. And I hope that it will continue, and that this is a temporary problem,” Swaminathan said. 

The WHO, she added, is very open and transparent to a review, but right now is not the time “because we are facing a wildfire”.


Also read: Not just US, its adversaries China and Russia are struggling under Covid-19 too


How the outbreak unfolded

The coronavirus pandemic was first detected in the Chinese town of Wuhan in December 2019. Discussing its emergence, Soumya Swaminathan said the WHO was first informed about an unusual cluster of pneumonia cases in Wuhan by Chinese officials on 31 December, following which an “incident management support team” was set up.

On 4 January, the WHO reported about the pneumonia cluster incident on social media and, the next day, it released a statement about the disease outbreak, the WHO chief scientist added.

By 11 January, China had already shared the first genome sequence of the virus publicly, which made it clear that the outbreak was caused by a novel coronavirus, Swaminathan said.

Around 23 January, the WHO’s technical committee decided against declaring the disease a ‘public health emergency of international concern’ (PHEIC) since there were very few cases outside China, or even Wuhan, at the time, said Swaminathan.

A week later, on 30 January, the WHO declared the outbreak a ‘PHEIC’. On the same day, India reported its first coronavirus case in Kerala. 

“There had been just 82 cases of coronavirus outside of China at that time,” said Swaminathan.Even so, by 10 January, she added, the WHO had already put together an ‘R&D blueprint’, a global strategy and preparedness plan, which allows the rapid activation of research and development activities during epidemics.


Also read: Covid-19 has given developing countries a great chance to care for their migrant workers


WHO doesn’t have the power to inspect

Earlier this month, US President Donald Trump had lashed out at the WHO chief for praising China when he visited the country in January, not declaring Covid-19 a global emergency until later, and what he described as Ghebreyesus’ inability to make China share data about the pandemic.

Responding to these charges, Soumya Swaminathan said, “The World Health Organisation does not take sides, we are a neutral organisation, we praise countries whenever it is due.”

She said Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus had praised India’s Ayushman Bharat – which offers medical insurance cover for poor households – several times as he believed in the cause of universal health coverage. 

“One must understand what the WHO can and cannot do. The WHO is a member-state organisation and the member-states have the authority to make rules and regulations,” Swaminathan said. 

In 2005, WHO member-states passed the International Health Regulations (IHR) – a law that provides a public health response to the international spread of disease – after the spread of SARS.

While most member-states agreed to share data and have been doing so, the WHO does not have the authority to make the countries do so, said Swaminathan.

The WHO can work through cooperation, building consensus and giving advice, she added. “It does not have the power of an inspector to march into countries and do inspections,” she said, adding that the WHO director general depended on technical experts of various countries to declare an outbreak an emergency and the committee had initially advised against it.

On the WHO’s criticism of the travel ban imposed by the US on Chinese travellers in January, she said, as a policy, the body does not recommend travel restrictions and bans under the IHR even during emergencies as they can have “unintended consequences”. Travel restrictions have to be temporary and measured and based on the latest evidence, she said.

On WHO chief 

In defence of Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, who has come under fire from several quarters in the last couple of months, Soumya Swaminathan said the whole team had been working round the clock since January, adding that the WHO chief was the last person to leave the building.  

“His heart is in the right place,” Swaminathan said. She pointed out that Ghebreyesus’ brother had died of malaria, and the Ethiopian national came from a background that allowed him to understand poverty and disease. 

She said there could be mistakes and failings due to human errors of judgement, but the WHO was open to an audit of its response to the pandemic.  

The emergency programme had improved and performed better than the Ebola outbreak of 2014-15, she said. “Everyone did their best, starting with Dr Tedros.”


Also read: China’s Covid cases could’ve been four times more than official tally, says study in Lancet


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

11 COMMENTS

  1. Dr. Soumya Swaminathan is a moron and should not be in charge of The WHO. I’m her latest statement she claims the “young and healthy” should not be given the vaccine until 2022. Apparently, she doesn’t realize that everyone is at risk, and if they want to, should be vaccinated in order to stop transmission. But it is irresponsible to say that this should go on for another year before everyone is vaccinated. This woman is a fool.

  2. Why do we have to give so much importance to utterances of a man who is thinking more about his re election then health of his people.

  3. ” Wuhan Health Organization “, please tell that ” to the Marines “, as the adage goes.

  4. Please don’t lie so much Dr Soumya you are insulting the memory of those doctors in China who were persecuted for trying to bring out the truth

  5. Madam, WHo lost its relevance when it was talling the lines of CCP. This organization has done damage to itself than helping people.

  6. Super interview. Hugely informative & lots of behind the scene insight into the C-19 fight-from such a respected person. The full interview on youtube is a must watch. She should be facing cameras in WHO briefings .

  7. Brilliant interview. Hugely informative and lots of behind the scene insight into what’s happening with C-19 – from such a respected person. The full interview on youtube is a must watch.we need to listen to people like her – a scientist instead of social media/politicians. .She should be facing cameras in WHO briefings .

  8. I am afraid, that the doubts about China on whatever it does, including all that surrounds the origin and spread of the covid-19, will always remain until China open itself to International Media….

    Any assurance from any body, especially WHO, will remain suspect. Very unfortunate but true

  9. Thank you for sharing your views on the Covid-19 and China’s responses to the pandemic. Very insightful. Let’s trust in science, not rumors and conspiracy theories.

  10. The Print has sold out to the Chinese. Stop the whitewashing. Whom are you trying to fool?
    “His heart is in the right place…. his brother died of malaria”….. boo hoo hoo. – all meant to generate sympathy towards Ghebreyesus.

    Don’t lose sight of the main issue – Ghebreyesus is compromised by the Chinese.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular

×