The three-judge bench hearing the ‘administrative powers of CJI’ case is headed by Dipak Misra himself. Its ruling will be binding on him and all future CJIs.
Judicial decision making is an idealised form of public reasoning that must elevate & educate public discourse. The SC/ST Act order failed meet these standards.
They have argued that ‘master of roster’ could not be an ‘unguided and unbridled discretionary power, exercised arbitrarily by the CJI by hand-picking benches of select judges.’
Even if he survives this crisis by default, Misra's perceived inaction on every crucial issue will leave the judiciary with a lot to defend itself against.
On 18 February 1956, 'Rajkumari' Amrit Kaur, India's first health minister, moved the Bill in Lok Sabha for the establishment of AIIMS in Delhi. She wanted it to have the powers and functions of a university because it will 'probably make revolutionary changes in curriculum as well as in modes of teaching'.
Move to bring down differences in commodity prices with neighbouring states, says government. Oppn, dealers blame it on welfare, Congress's guarantees.
Occasional lovers’ tiffs have marked history of RSS-BJP relations. To think that Nagpur will bring about any change in leadership is a misreading of both its intent and its power.
More I see behavior of congress party, more appalled I get. First this party put India under emergency. Then, they got Sikhs killed in a pogrom. Then they tried to put Modi behind bars. Now after all else failed, they want to employ scare tactics on a Supreme Court chief Justice. All this actions spread over many decades indicate dictatorial tendency of the party. Do not mess with us, or else! Ironic that congress spokees sermon use this nation about value of democracy and independence of judiciary!
Dipak Mishra should be impeached because from last few months the judgement of few cases was really looked biased towards the government . Sahi ko sahi v nhi kehta h SC. Judiciary is under the command of government while it should not be. And what happened to Prasad Educational Trust case!!!
Congress Very well knows that they do not have enough numbers to impeach CJI. Idea is to create problems for the ruling party and to CJI. Now when impeachment motion gets rejected in the house, they will shout that look the party in power is supporting CJI as he is their man. It’s a plan to win in both the situations. Congress has forgotten that the same game can be played in future if Congress comes to power.
The CONgress party is nent ipon creating a civil war situation. Wonder where the Hell have the intellectuals are hiding hiving tje nation a rooten leader ala Rajol Gamdie.
What Ranjan Gogoi did is unpardonable. The other three judges were not due to be chief justice of SC, but Gogoi was and is. He could have initiated all the reforms in the SC judiciary that they talked about in the press release. It takes decades for the common man to get court rulings. This SC judge could tot wait for a few months for his turn to be Cj and initiate whatever reforms they were talking about? His actions sound political and in poor faith.
A very unfortunate development. CJI Dipak Misra is the best judge of his conduct. Just yesterday, his judgment reiterated certain verities : A judge cannot lie; what he says is the gospel truth; to question a judge is to commit contempt of court. He might wish to introspect if he has lived up to that high standard. If his conscience is clear, he should soldier on, as he did even while four brother judges were expressing their anguish to the world. Else, he should step down, save India the agony of impeachment, recommend that Justice Ranjan Gogoi succeed him.
More I see behavior of congress party, more appalled I get. First this party put India under emergency. Then, they got Sikhs killed in a pogrom. Then they tried to put Modi behind bars. Now after all else failed, they want to employ scare tactics on a Supreme Court chief Justice. All this actions spread over many decades indicate dictatorial tendency of the party. Do not mess with us, or else! Ironic that congress spokees sermon use this nation about value of democracy and independence of judiciary!
Dipak Mishra should be impeached because from last few months the judgement of few cases was really looked biased towards the government . Sahi ko sahi v nhi kehta h SC. Judiciary is under the command of government while it should not be. And what happened to Prasad Educational Trust case!!!
Congress Very well knows that they do not have enough numbers to impeach CJI. Idea is to create problems for the ruling party and to CJI. Now when impeachment motion gets rejected in the house, they will shout that look the party in power is supporting CJI as he is their man. It’s a plan to win in both the situations. Congress has forgotten that the same game can be played in future if Congress comes to power.
Impeachment is a political drama. Opposition has no number. It is only to threat other judges .
Vanakkam, Do unto others as you would wish to be done by others! The Law-maker should not be a Law-breaker?
Let them decide if it will happen than he will be the first and worst CJI
DIPAK Misra worst CJI ever, must be impeached immediately.
Where are the numbers ?
The CONgress party is nent ipon creating a civil war situation. Wonder where the Hell have the intellectuals are hiding hiving tje nation a rooten leader ala Rajol Gamdie.
Why a chief justice can’t lie…why his judgement is above question.. isn’t he a human after all
O.K.
Ridiculous allegations on CJI for impeachment.
What Ranjan Gogoi did is unpardonable. The other three judges were not due to be chief justice of SC, but Gogoi was and is. He could have initiated all the reforms in the SC judiciary that they talked about in the press release. It takes decades for the common man to get court rulings. This SC judge could tot wait for a few months for his turn to be Cj and initiate whatever reforms they were talking about? His actions sound political and in poor faith.
A very unfortunate development. CJI Dipak Misra is the best judge of his conduct. Just yesterday, his judgment reiterated certain verities : A judge cannot lie; what he says is the gospel truth; to question a judge is to commit contempt of court. He might wish to introspect if he has lived up to that high standard. If his conscience is clear, he should soldier on, as he did even while four brother judges were expressing their anguish to the world. Else, he should step down, save India the agony of impeachment, recommend that Justice Ranjan Gogoi succeed him.