Thursday, 30 June, 2022
HomeOpinionWhy does BJP say ‘Beti Bachao’ and then do ‘Balatkari Bachao’ –...

Why does BJP say ‘Beti Bachao’ and then do ‘Balatkari Bachao’ – over and over again?

Text Size:

Remember, this is UP, where CM Adityanath says criminals will be shot dead in fake encounters without a trial — but he decides that he and other BJP leaders can be declared innocent without a trial.

In cases of rape, it’s common to see media and politicians advise, “Don’t politicise.”

This phrase is misleading. What we should be saying is, “Don’t defend rape and those accused of rape on political or communal grounds.”

Accountability and justice for rape must, of course, be a political issue — we must hold political parties and governments accountable for rape and rape culture, as we held the Congress governments at the Centre and in Delhi responsible for their handling of the 2012 Nirbhaya gang rape and murder.

Protecting daughters, or protecting rapists?

The question we should be asking today is: Why does the BJP say ‘Beti Bachao’ and then do ‘Balatkari Bachao’, over and over again?

We saw it when BJP MP Subramanian Swamy defended Asaram, accused under the Prevention of Child Sexual Offences Act of aggravated sexual assault of a minor girl, and deliberately distorted facts in his tweets.

We saw it when BJP MP Babul Supriyo defended Haryana BJP chief Subhash Barala’s son Vikas Barala in the Chandigarh stalking case, and BJP spokesperson Shaina NC slut-shamed stalking survivor Varnika Kundu.

We saw it when the BJP government let rape-convict Ram Rahim’s supporters run amok, and the BJP’s Unnao MP Sakshi Maharaj said, “Crores of people are supporting Ram Rahim, and only one person is complaining against him. Is one person right or are crores of people right?”

And we’re seeing it now, when the BJP’s MLA Kuldeep Singh Sengar, accused with his brother and others of gang-raping a teenager, is not arrested — but the victim’s father is arrested in a false case and beaten to death by the MLA’s brother. The teenager is forced to attempt suicide outside the CM’s residence — but the CM continues to meet a smiling Sengar, who calls the teenager and her father ‘lowly people’ .

Remember, this is UP, where CM Adityanath says criminals will be shot dead in fake encounters without a trial — but he decides that he and other BJP leaders can be declared innocent without a trial. He has not only not had Sengar arrested and withdrawn the various criminal cases against himself, he has withdrawn a case of rape against former union minister ‘Swami’ Chinmayanand, who was accused of raping a woman in his ashram.

Little girl needs our anger

The most soul-searing case of them all is, of course, in Kathua, where a special police officer, a former revenue official and other men are accused of kidnapping, drugging, torturing, repeatedly gang-raping, strangulating and smashing the head of eight-year-old girl in a temple, accompanied with rituals. The police initially destroyed evidence — but the case was handed over to the crime branch. The crime branch says the motive of this crime was to spread terror in the nomadic Bakerwal community to which the 8-year old belonged, and claims to have DNA and other evidence as the basis for its arrests. The J&K high court is monitoring the investigation in the case.

But in Jammu, there is a concerted attempt to hide the horror of the rape in a communal fog, where people are being urged to stand with the victim or the accused, depending on their community and political affiliation. They do not want us, irrespective of our faith, to feel empathy for and anger on behalf of little girl.

The defence of the accused should be a matter for courts (yes, even those accused of the most heinous rapes and murders deserve to have competent lawyers and defend themselves in court; online comments on newspaper reports calling for summary execution of the accused in this or other cases are pointless, unjust, and simply not helpful for gender justice). But in Kathua and Jammu today, there is an attempt to turn the defence of the accused into a matter of community honour and even ‘national’ honour. How is this being done?

BJP ministers of J&K led ‘Hindu Ekta Manch’ rallies waving the Indian tricolour to defend the accused, insisting that the crime branch was biased and a tool of the Muslim chief minister. Women of the accused men’s families and community are rallying to demand a CBI enquiry, saying the police have only arrested “our people” (Hindus) and none of “their people” (Muslims) and “only the CBI will give us justice”.

The Kathua and Jammu bar association are also agitating in defence of the accused and even threatening the woman lawyer representing the victim.

Just pause and think about the meaning of such mobilisation.

When Jyoti Singh was raped and murdered in Delhi in 2012, the whole country rallied for her — without, at the time, knowing her name or caste or community. Modi, then the Gujarat CM, called her “Bharat ki beti” – India’s daughter.

Today, what stops Modi from speaking about her? In his eyes, is she not “Bharat Ki Beti”? And if so, why not?

When the ‘Hindu Ekta Manch’ rallies for those accused of the rape and murder of the 8-year old, they are saying that ‘Hindu unity’ must mean unity even with cruel rapists and murderers, and that such unity is more important than unity across communities against rape. They want Hindus of Jammu and Hindus of India to see her, not as a victim needing our solidarity, our anger, and our thirst for justice, but as a Muslim, as someone of “their” community; and they want the accused of this heinous crime to be seen as those of “our” community, who must be defended only because they are Hindu. Every Hindu needs to ask themselves: Is this what being Hindu means to you — defending even rapist murderous scum just because they’re Hindu and their victim, Muslim? Should we be dividing child victims of rape, torture, and murder into “us” and “them”? Should we divide rapists into “ours” and “theirs”?

When anyone tries to defend those accused of such a crime, based not on any credible evidence or arguments but “Jammu sentiments”, “Hindu sentiments/Hindu unity”, or “national sentiments” (using the national flag), it means they are trying to make people accused of rape and murder the poster boys of Jammu, of the Hindu faith, of the nation. Is that really OK? The identity of the rape accused should not be used to malign any community or country but if they are defended as community or country heroes, that does, in fact, tarnish the community’s and country’s image.

If anyone feels the wrong people have been arrested for the crime, they can collect evidence and help the accused build a case for their defence in court. But the Kathua and Jammu bar associations, instead of using legal means to present evidence in defence of the accused in the high court, are calling bandhs, blocking chargesheets, and even threatening Deepika Rajawat, the woman lawyer representing the victim’s parents.

Modi spoke on the Jyoti Singh rape and murder because, then, it was politically convenient to use the rape to target the Congress; he is silent on the 8-year old because it is politically inconvenient to risk offending the ‘Hindu Ekta Manch’, which is so closely associated with his own party; he is silent on Unnao because his own party’s MLA is accused. We didn’t tolerate silence from the Prime Minister in December 2012 — why should we tolerate silence from the Prime Minister now?

Kavita Krishnan is secretary of the All India Progressive Women’s Association

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Never have I been so ashamed to be a Hindu. These bastards do not represent me or my values – not now, not ever. Asifa and all victims of such heinous crimes should never go unpunished. Mr. Modi/Ms. Irani/Ms. Seetharaman — Do you have any conscience left? Will we, Indians, ever see a rule of law???

    I voted for BJP in last elections tired of the corruption of the Congress. Little did we know that we were exchanging one set of crooks with a set of rapists. Long Live our democracy!!!

  2. Who is this author with no GK!
    I don’t understand why Hindu Muslim came here
    Rape is a heroneous act against a human, don’t communalize it.
    And author for your FYI , Asharam Bapu’s charges are not yet being proved. He has been trapped.

    • This is strange. A powerful man like Asaram trapped? What about all the witnesses that were murdered ? Surely you need to open your eyes and see through this dhongi baba.

  3. Subramaniam swamy gave correct facts for Sant Shri Asaramji Bapuji. He is completely innocent.

    Some facts of the on Saint Shri Asharamji Bapuji fake allegation:

    1. Bapuji is 82 years old with proven history of social service, helping society for 50+ years.

    2. This girl alleged that she was attacked for 1.5 hours when her mother was sitting outside the room. The mother did not hear anything.

    3. The girl further alleged that this 75 year old saint had put one hand on her mouth and attacked her with one hand for 1.5 hours when there were a lot of people outside the room.

    4. Medical reports denies any attack.

    This should be very obvious that this is a conspiracy against Hindu saints!

    5. There is a well-planned media attack constantly for many hours per day for the last 3 months against Bapuji – when not even showing news of other people who are already convicted. The media is controlled by the Congress party.

    6. The girl stayed in the same place of the attack for 5 days with her family. People that she interacted her described her to be her normal self and being joyful, files report after 10 days.

    7. The girl claims the incident happened in Jodhpur, the girl is from Shahajahanput but files FIR in Delhi at 2:30 AM, 10 days after the “alleged” incident. Locals say they have seen lots of politicians coming to the girl’s home before the FIR was filed. The FIR was filed in Delhi hoping that it will get approved there quickly.

    convinced this is a fake case for character assassination?

  4. Given the surcharged atmosphere in Jammu, it may be in the interests of justice to move the trial to another state and require the High Court to entrust it to a judge of high integrity and competence.

  5. Sant asaram bapu was framed in a wrong case .. medical report gave cleanchit … nothing found on girls body… even no Rape charge in FIR .. only media projected this case rape case and still showing same… it will be good if u gyus get more knowledge on this case as well … not a single media house showed original FIR to viewers …

  6. Seems the writer has lack of general awareness!

    Since 5 yrs, there is no proof found against Asaram Bapu and even Police / Medical report found the Rape allegations are bogus

      • As per you sir, If the motive to purchase the witness then it could be done at very early stage.
        Not a single evidence available which state that he is guilty and the reason to not getting bail because of POCSO act. Saint Shree Asaram Bapuji told that i have full faith in judiciary and that’s what he is in jail about 5 years.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular