Last week, Karnataka Chief Minister H.D. Kumaraswamy was on a private visit to the United States. In his absence, rebel MLAs from his Janata Dal (Secular) and coalition partner Congress mounted a political coup. But Kumaraswamy is not the only chief minister to have faced a rebellion while abroad. In 1984, then Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N.T. Rama Rao was undergoing a heart surgery in the US. In his absence, one of his cabinet ministers, N. Bhaskara Rao, got his government dismissed. More recently, in 2012, one of Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik’s trusted advisers, late Pyarimohan Mohapatra, had tried to wrest control while the CM was on an official visit to London. While Rao was able to return to power after a month, Patnaik did not lose control of his party MLAs.
JD(S)’ Kumaraswamy, however, may not be able to achieve a similar result. His coalition government does not seem to have the numbers to survive a no-confidence motion, which is likely to be moved on the first day of the monsoon session of the 225-member Karnataka assembly on 12 July. Against the majority mark of 113, the Congress-JD(S) coalition had a combined strength of 120 MLAs – Congress’ 80, JD(S)’ 37, Bahujan Samaj Party’s one and two Independents.
Latest media reports say that as many as 16 MLAs have submitted their resignation to the Speaker. If accepted, it will reduce the House strength to 209 and bring down the majority mark to 105. The Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) has 105 MLAs in the House.
Damage control is in full swing in Bengaluru. The entire cabinet has resigned to make way for other MLAs to become ministers in the government. Former Congress Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has threatened disqualification proceedings against the rebel Congress MLAs. The office of the Speaker has indicated that the resignation letters of some of the MLAs are not in order and may not be accepted. But the rebel legislators have stood their ground on resignation, and are currently holed up in Mumbai.
A remedy that achieved little
The events in Karnataka are not new. Individual and group of legislators have been able to destabilise governments regularly over the years. The usual method of opposition parties has been to lure away ruling party/coalition legislators. This floor-crossing in states reached epic proportion in the 1960s and 1970s. MLAs in some states changed their political allegiances multiple times during the day.
We are deeply grateful to our readers & viewers for their time, trust and subscriptions.
Quality journalism is expensive and needs readers to pay for it. Your support will define our work and ThePrint’s future.
Parliament amended the Constitution in 1985 in an attempt to stop this menace, with the deterrent being the MLA’s loss of House membership. However, the deterrence has had little effect. Political parties and MLAs have over the years continued to bypass and exploit this constitutional amendment, referred to as the anti-defection law.
The only thing this law has been good at is in defining the rules that need to be met or bypassed for creating political uncertainty. Political parties now hide behind this law to cajole and convince MLAs to serve their purpose. The events in Karnataka (as well as in Goa) are among the many wake-up calls about the uselessness of the anti-defection law.
Law and its fundamental flaw
The anti-defection law has been in place for over three decades now. But the penalty of loss of membership of the legislature has never deterred MLAs from switching political parties. In the current situation in Karnataka, MLAs have preempted the punishment under the law by resigning themselves. The problem with the anti-defection law is not that the penalty for changing political party is not stringent enough; the fundamental flaw is that the entire idea of anti-defection tries to solve a political issue through a legal solution.
Anti-defection is the only law in the country that has consistently failed every time it has been invoked to secure political stability. In addition to being ineffective and redundant, the anti-defection law has destroyed the deliberative nature of our democracy. The threat of expulsion is used to ward off any intra-party dialogue or debate in the assembly. Since the law gives the Speakers the power to expel MLAs, their office’s neutrality too has been systematically destroyed, so much so that Speakers have delayed acting on expulsion for years.
If we want our lawmaking institutions to function as per their constitutional mandate, it is high time that the anti-defection law is repealed in its entirety.
The author is the Head of legislative and civic engagement, PRS Legislative Research. Views are personal.
News media is in a crisis & only you can fix it
You are reading this because you value good, intelligent and objective journalism. We thank you for your time and your trust.
You also know that the news media is facing an unprecedented crisis. It is likely that you are also hearing of the brutal layoffs and pay-cuts hitting the industry. There are many reasons why the media’s economics is broken. But a big one is that good people are not yet paying enough for good journalism.
We have a newsroom filled with talented young reporters. We also have the country’s most robust editing and fact-checking team, finest news photographers and video professionals. We are building India’s most ambitious and energetic news platform. And we aren’t even three yet.
At ThePrint, we invest in quality journalists. We pay them fairly and on time even in this difficult period. As you may have noticed, we do not flinch from spending whatever it takes to make sure our reporters reach where the story is. Our stellar coronavirus coverage is a good example. You can check some of it here.
This comes with a sizable cost. For us to continue bringing quality journalism, we need readers like you to pay for it. Because the advertising market is broken too.
If you think we deserve your support, do join us in this endeavour to strengthen fair, free, courageous, and questioning journalism, please click on the link below. Your support will define our journalism, and ThePrint’s future. It will take just a few seconds of your time.