File image of Union Railway Minister Piyush Goyal at BJP HQ in New Delhi | PTI
File image of Union Railways Minister Piyush Goyal at BJP HQ in New Delhi | PTI
Text Size:

If a train bound for Gorakhpur reaches Raurkela in Odisha and another one going to Patna reaches Purulia, there must be something very ‘special’ about these Shramik Specials. And if jobless labourers are reaching their hometowns on wheels, instead of walking hundreds of kilometers, is being considered something special in 21st century India, then indeed, railway minister Piyush Goyal must be felicitated for this grand feat.

Piyush Goyal has justified these ‘stray’ trains stating “route rationalisation” to avoid congestion on select routes, since most of these trains are bound for Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. But let’s be honest. What’s happening with the Shramik Specials could easily be called a hot mess. It is also a PR nightmare for the Narendra Modi government.

It is not for the first time that the Railways and a railway minister are facing flak for their poor management of the national transporter. But what’s different this time is the response from those who are responsible.

Railway ministers in the past used to be the accountable ones. Some even resigned or offered to vacate the post in light of accidents, taking moral responsibility. Now, you have this cantankerous minister who spars on Twitter but can’t say a sympathetic word for those who are dying on the train.

The one cliche about Emergency was that the trains ran on time. But in this lockdown, the trains are getting lost, people are arriving dead and bodies are lying unclaimed on platforms.

Also read: From Shah to Goyal, ministers laud ‘Covid-19 hero Modi’ in media blitz on NDA anniversary

Junking a good idea

Goyal is partially responsible for this hot mess. The railway minister had junked some of the policy initiatives introduced by his predecessor Suresh Prabhu that could have helped the national transporter overcome the distress it is going through now.

By scrapping Prabhu’s proposal of giving a brand new IT infrastructure to the Railways, Goyal denied the national carrier a chance to streamline the operations related to management of goods, passengers, assets and management functions that would have come under one digital dashboard.

Prabhu had increased the IT budget of Railways by 50 per cent. But Goyal’s assumption that the Railways could function well on existing IT infrastructure has come back to haunt him. His abysmal handling of the transportation of jobless workers has led to utter chaos and the Railways is being rightly criticised for its shoddiness.

Also read: ‘Tears’ to tweets — why Piyush Goyal’s throwing everything he’s got to fight Shramik PR mess

Ordinary response to extraordinary demand

And what’s the Railways’ defence? The national transporter has blamed the mess on extraordinary circumstances. Alright. But how does it plan to justify the deaths on trains and platforms due to dehydration and hunger? How hard was it for Piyush Goyal and the Railways to ensure food and water on these ‘special trains’? What has he got to tell those waiting outside railway stations for hours at a stretch in sweltering heat? In fact, the reasoning for route congestion too is hard to understand as the Railways is currently not running at its full operational capacity.

Railways can’t shift the blame of these deaths on old-age and existing illnesses. By that logic, every natural calamity can be blamed on God and all infrastructure failure on public misuse. The reason governments exists is to ensure that during dire straits, the citizens remain protected.

Also read: Retired Army man, grandmas, students — everyone on the special trains has a lockdown story

Not realising the role of railway

Where Piyush Goyal has failed the most is in his late realisation of the role railways had to play in mitigating the migrant workers’ crisis.

He is sending out tweets to tell migrants not to travel if they are above 65 or below 10 years of age, or if they have any serious ailments. He says that people should travel “only when necessary”. With the sick having nowhere to go since hospitals are already running on reserve and the migrants’ rents not being footed by the government, the railway minister should know that people are travelling because they have no choice. Those with pre-existing ailments can’t lie on the road, and those who are out of work can’t beg in streets.

Before tweeting out such advisories from the comfort of his home or office, he should ask his government how these people will be taken care of. And with over two months of lockdown, how can any citizen be told to stay away from their homes when they lack basic amenities like food, water and shelter in the cities they work in?

The clarity on who is paying for the migrant workers’ train fare also makes clear Piyush Goyal and the Modi government’s seriousness towards the crisis. BJP spokesperson Sambit Patra had said that 85 per cent of the train fare was being borne by the Railways while 15 per cent was coming from states. It has now come to light that it is the state governments who are paying for these journeys.

Also read: Stray trains: Poor planning by Indian Railways or overwhelming load on some routes?

But politics is on track

Politics over the migrant workers’ crisis has made the entire exercise appear sordid and inhuman. Goyal indulged in a Twitter war with Maharashtra and has accused some of the non-BJP ruled states like Rajasthan, Jharkhand, West Bengal and Chhattisgarh of not co-operating with the Centre.

In an FB Live with Sambit Patra, Goyal vehemently criticised the non-BJP states for non-cooperation with the Railways. Perhaps, the railway minister forgot to see the Centre’s fresh directive allowing the Railways to run Shramik Specials without seeking permission from the states.

Ashok Gehlot and Hemant Soren were quick to rebut Goyal’s claim and confirm that they had given all NOCs for the trains to bring migrant workers home.

It looks like election season is still on. Mamata Banerjee has to be proved mercurial because she is refusing to accept trains into Bengal (even if it is due to cyclone Amphan). And also because elections are due in the state? Or Uddhav Thackeray has to be accused of being too slow in his planning because while Goyal was ready with over 145 trains from Maharashtra, Thackeray only managed to fill 27. But no one’s blind to the fact that BJP’s trying a little too hard to destabilise the Maharashtra government.

It’s time for some serious introspection for the Modi government. Some of their cabinet ministers are failing to do their job. Face-saving is not that job.

The author is a political observer and writer. Views are personal.

ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

10 Comments Share Your Views


  1. Chronic patients were stuck for months in South indian medical centres like vellore and TMH Mumbai…they returned after shramik specials started….total 90 lakh people returned …80 deaths reported….2 trains had major diversions….railways war working with 33 percent staff strength….evacuation of a train at a station was taking 2 to 2.5 hours at a station as compared to 20 minutes….instead of appreciation the cheap politics far away from facts…anyways that is what is expected print

  2. Dear writer. You had just given the data of 2 trains , what about the other trains whose numbers are in hundreds reached the destination with all help and cooperation for migrants. Debate must be for and against not just against. My suggestion to you is join communist party and write directy under them.

  3. It is not as big mess as it is being made out. Definitely the railways (and flights) should not have been stopped during the first two weeks of lockdown. And after that only reserved compartments must have been allowed with strict social distancing of 5 passengers in a coupe. So we can say that extraordinary circumstances created the mess.

  4. Ranting as usual. No article on how Bengal and Maharastra are mismanaging the crisis . Deaths are acceptable as long as it is caused by a ‘ secular government’. The only agenda of this columnist is anti BJP and anti Hindu arricles.

  5. Railways and Mr Piyush Girl have done the very nice job of running Shramik trains with short notice. Kudos to the team Railways.

  6. ZAINAB’s head is in a mess. Better she stops wasting ThePrint media space and readers time. She is a full time anti-BJP headless creature.

  7. I appreciate your single minded focus in showing up all the wrong doings of the NDA government in particular and Hindutva in general. But it would help in your professional career or at least give it the veneer of being true to your profession if you turned the spotlight, however so ever fleetingly, on how the non NDA states are managing COVID. You may wish to start with Maharashtra or West Bengal, both being ruled by parties with impeccable secular credentials.

  8. Nowhere in the world, these many people, have ever been transported without a few mix-ups. Yes care needs to be taken that these lapses don’t repeat. It is a very complicated job made more complicated by defiance of a few states to shift the blame on the central government. The number of lapses are just too few compared to the objective & task fulfilled. Mistakes shouldn’t
    be repeated.

  9. Stop being negative. We have had enough of it. Do not exaggerate. In these times of crisis we all must understand each other’s problems. Not bring in religion or politics.

  10. Zainab here you go again having NO experience in any life but since your paycheck comes from Congress party you will pick on BJP and try to stick your theories.Being a Muslim does not help either.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here