Once upon a time, I could call my friends, ask them what they were reading, and get five different book titles as suggestions. Not anymore. Today, almost everyone reads the same book. I call it hashtag reading.
Bestsellers were once determined on merit. Now, they are based on algorithms, celebrity endorsements, and controversy. Take, for example, the ‘It Book’ of the month, Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging.
It’s arguably a well-written book, though that is not why it is already setting sales records. It has merit, yes, but it also has lore, controversy, and best of all, gossip. The inner workings of politics, entertainment, and one of India’s most famous families.
Even those who haven’t picked up a book since eighth-grade library class are now devouring Mrs Gandhi’s tell-all memoir from cover to cover. Social media is abuzz, and Indian Bookstagram can barely control itself.
So does Belonging’s early success, like others that sweep social media, signal that reading is social or conformist?
Reading in a new age
Belonging is the latest example in a long line of books that take the internet by storm. Earlier this year, many cinephiles and ‘Nolaniacs’ were suddenly classical history scholars, debating the merits of Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey. Translations, adaptations, nay, even inferences were discussed, dissected, and disseminated online. For a brief moment, classic history scholars had their moment in the sun.
But like Icarus, they, too, soon fell from their glorious heights. BookTok and Bookstagram soon moved over to Caro Claire Burke’s Yesteryear and Suzanne Collins’ Sunrise on the Reaping (2025)—which has now been turned into a feature film—or whichever new adaptation Netflix and Prime Video were promoting in between.
As beings constantly on our phones, our habits, vices, and choices are vastly determined by what we consume. So when the fashion Bible, Vogue, declares that literary chic is the latest fashion, of course, reading picks up. It helped that Dior, Coach, and other designer houses also had book-themed bags and accessories, making reading haute couture officially.
In such a world, it makes sense that reading, and the books that make it to the top of the TBR list, are then determined by the hot topic of the day rather than what is the best written.
Sure, there are always underdogs such as Salt: A World History written by Mark Kurlansky (originally published in 2001) or Siddhartha Mukherjee’s 2010 book The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer (which even received a shoutout by Oprah Winfrey) that saw a brief renaissance. But those are rare and brief, a filler before the next book shakes things up.
Also read: Robert Pattinson, James Bond, and the economics of female fandom
The verdict
Bookstores may be picking up momentum across the US and other parts of the world. But most of us still want to be in the know. While the joy of browsing for books remains, it is no longer setting the gold standard; your algorithm is. Or, in Belonging’s case, the Gandhi family’s dirty laundry.
Gandhi’s book is the best example of how the internet, trends, and pop culture shape what we read, consume, and talk about. It has taken the mantle; it sits upon every coffee table, and in many cases, even has a spot on the grid, making the memoir’s place in popular culture Instagram–official.
Social media is making reading both conformist and social. It is limiting the not-so-keen reader to the flavour of the season, but hey, at least they can talk about it with others, and they are, even still, reading.
Views are personal.
(Edited by Prasanna Bachchhav)
