scorecardresearch

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomeOpinionRobert Pattinson, James Bond, and the economics of female fandom

Robert Pattinson, James Bond, and the economics of female fandom

The women who first made Robert Pattinson a global phenomenon have never really gone away. They have simply grown up, and are still here to celebrate him as he becomes the next James Bond.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

Robert Pattinson has officially been summoned to ‘Her Majesty’s Secret Service’. He will become the seventh actor to slip into the hide of the famous MI6 agent, who is decidedly the world’s most famous on-screen spy. For many women who grew up in the late 2000s and early 2010s, however, Pattinson will always be Edward Cullen, the brooding vampire from the Twilight universe. The news of Pattinson’s casting has been received with nothing short of the loudest cheers by the same demographic that put him on the map — the then-teenage girls who are now in their 20s and early 30s. 

Interestingly, women, especially those in their teens and early 20s, make up a demographic that has so much impact on art, cinema, and pop culture and by extension its evolution. Yet, we are prone to dismissing or belittling their interests, almost on principle. There is something about the way young women are taught to be embarrassed by their own enthusiasm.

I remember being in my teens, having read the Twilight books and watched the movies, and how it was not seen as cool or smart to be seen as liking it. So, I would cloak my interest in it as derision of the content. As I have grown up, this need to audition for the approval of the larger society in general and of men in particular has been extinguished, at least to a great extent. I can now come forth and quite easily admit how big of a thing the Twilight books and movies and the fanfiction based on them played in my life and how obsessed I was with Pattinson’s Cullen. I do not think I am singular in this experience. This, I believe, is the rite of passage for many women. There is a kind of social currency attached to being a woman who doesn’t like what other women like. 

At the root of this, I believe, is the fact that feminine consumption is largely seen as emotional rather than intellectual, even though neither can exist in a vacuum in the absence of the other. A man who follows football, is a huge fan of a particular athlete and knows everything about him, including but not limited to the football statistics, and spends money traveling to watch his team, or buy their merchandise is passionate. A teenage girl who follows every detail about her favourite popstar, follows his/her career, attends concerts, buys merch may be described as obsessive. Despite the fact that both of these are expressions of fandom, the language and lens employed to describe each of them can be remarkably different. This distinction, in many ways, deprives women of their intellectual agency.

The feminisation of an interest 

There is a contradiction between women’s enormous economic and cultural power as consumers of popular culture and the relatively little cultural legitimacy afforded to their tastes. Somehow, the feminisation of an interest makes it more prone to social ridicule. We see this across generations. The female consumers of pop culture are branded as hysterical, as in the case of The Beatles in their early years. Contemporary examples of this phenomenon can be witnessed with the fans of Taylor Swift, Justin Bieber, Olivia Rodrigo inter alia. 

Yet, female audiences are sophisticated, powerful consumers, and their consumption has shaped a lot of what the artistic and cultural scene looks like at any given time. Consider Fifty Shades of Grey, originally a work of fanfiction based on the Twilight universe. The entertainment industry is aware of how extraordinarily valuable young women are as a consumer demographic. The phenomenon of boybands like Backstreet Boys, NSYNC, and One Direction is a testament to this. The popularity of books such as It Ends With Us on BookTok and Bookstagram also demonstrates how cultural momentum driven largely by female audiences eventually translates into successful film adaptations.

So, the industry recognises the purchasing power of young women, not just owing to their participation but also because of their role in the creation of cultural demand. What I can only call cosmic, capitalist humour, women’s money is welcome without their tastes being considered intellectually legitimate. Take the Kardashians, for instance. I will probably be amongst the first to critique the Kardashian family’s contribution to consumerism, unrealistic beauty standards, celebrity culture and the commodification of personal life. That being said, it is interesting how their cultural influence is often discussed with a degree of intellectual disdain, even though they have transformed and, in many ways, made more public the aspects of celebrity and beauty entrepreneurship and social media marketing. Criticism of their influence is entirely valid. However, dismissing their influence and their target audience, which is largely female, as unworthy of serious consideration is another matter altogether.


Also read: James Bond’s Omega legacy faces a challenge from Pattinson’s Jaeger-LeCoultre deal


Influential yet unacknowledged

Perhaps the most interesting thing about Pattinson as the new Bond is the contrast between the reception of his earlier and later career. The actor who was previously dismissed in certain quarters for playing a sparkling vampire has since established himself through films such as Good Time (2017), The Lighthouse (2019), Tenet (2020), and The Batman (2022). And he is now going to play one of cinema’s most iconic masculine icons. And the women who first made him a global phenomenon have never really gone away. They have simply grown up, and are still here to celebrate him.

Popular culture has time and again demonstrated that young women are among its most influential consumers and participants. They champion, interpret, and popularise the people, their stories and ideas, making them the architects of many cultural phenomena. Despite that, their enthusiasm is seen as frivolous and their cultural influence is acknowledged only when it comes to commercial profits. Perhaps it is time we started actively trying to question a culture that is happy to profit from young women’s enthusiasm but reluctant to respect their intelligence, and change it for the better.

Shabnoor Rahman is a Civil Servant (Assistant Commissioner of State Tax), Government of Assam. Views are personal. 

(Edited by Aamaan Alam Khan)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular