Friday, 27 May, 2022
HomeOpinionIndian democracy’s big contradiction – Dalits cherish Constitution, privileged want a rethink

Indian democracy’s big contradiction – Dalits cherish Constitution, privileged want a rethink

Modi government decided to celebrate Constitution Day in 2015. But India’s SC/STs have been celebrating the day much before the official announcement.

Text Size:

On the 70th year of the making of the Indian Constitution, here is an important question. Why does the Dalit community celebrate the Constitution the most, when it has received the least in terms of dignity, resources and development?

In 2015, the Narendra Modi government decided to celebrate this day as the ‘Constitution Day’. But India’s Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe communities have been celebrating the day every year much before the official announcement. Across many Indian cities, they have been wearing new clothes, lighting up their homes, organising seminars and rallies, garlanding the statues of B.R. Ambedkar, the chairperson of the Constitution Drafting Committee, over several decades.

But in real terms, 70 years since the Indian Republic came into being, Dalits are still the most disadvantaged lot. They are at the lowest rung of education. Dalit women die early. They do not have adequate representation in any of the power structures, like senior judiciary, media, higher bureaucracy, corporate sector, academia and so on. They still do not have any say in the functioning of well-endowed Hindu temples. Caste-based discrimination is a reality in Indian universities and workplaces. Dalits die inside gutters and sewer lines.

According to a paper by PhD scholar Nitin Kumar Bharti – the paper was supervised by French economist Thomas Piketty – the share of wealth in the hands of Dalits is miniscule compared to non-Dalits. “The relative growth of lower castes is either stable or declining. Probably the most worrying aspect for any Indian policy-maker is poor educational outcomes for lower caste population. This means that in coming future, the condition will not improve either,” says Bharti.


Also read: NCRB adds ‘insult’ to crimes against Dalits. And yes, merit argument is an insult


When Ambedkar was proved wrong

So, why have Dalits been celebrating the Indian Constitution relentlessly all these years? Any social group in any other part of the world would have revolted in a similar situation. Or at least, articulated its alienation from the dominant narrative. The Dalit optimism despite the prevailing circumstances should be a subject of sociological scrutiny.

While delivering the concluding speech in the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949, B.R. Ambedkar warned the makers of the Constitution against social and economic inequality and how these can be detrimental for the health of the Indian Republic. In his famous speech, he said:

“On 26th January 1950, we are going to enter into a life of contradictions. In politics we will be recognising the principle of one man one vote and one vote one value. In our social and economic life, we shall, by reason of our social and economic structure, continue to deny the principle of one man one value. How long shall we continue to live this life of contradictions? How long shall we continue to deny equality in our social and economic life? If we continue to deny it for long, we will do so only by putting our political democracy in peril. We must remove this contradiction at the earliest possible moment or else those who suffer from inequality will blow up the structure of democracy which this Assembly has so laboriously built up.”

All studies, census data and surveys have proved beyond doubt that inequality is on the rise in India in social as well as economic life.

Despite being one of the finest scholars of his time, who studied sociology, economics, law and governance, Ambedkar was proved wrong on this count – that the disempowered would blow up the structure of democracy.

Perhaps, the reason for the community’s elation is the provision of reservation in political institutions, like Lok Sabha, state assemblies and panchayati raj, as well as in government jobs and education. This provision has saved the Indian state from the ire of the underclass and the lower castes.

Other acts of optical symbolism like having a Dalit President or a Dalit Chief Justice of the Supreme Court have also played a seminal role in creating a false sense that Dalits have a say in the affairs of the Republic.

Constitutionally guaranteed reservation in education and government jobs is the only way out for a small section of Dalits to enter the sphere of the middle class. The Dalit middle class mostly comprises salaried government employees who see this provision as the only escape route.

Scholars have argued that Indian democracy is surviving, while many other democracies failed, because of the faith and hope of the underclass. This section still sees it as an institution, which acts as its saviour.


Also read: India’s founders gave us our Constitution. We must prove to them that we can keep it


Indian democracy’s biggest contradiction

After the advent of liberalisation, government jobs have shrunk and the private sector is not acting benevolent towards Dalits and tribals and as well the OBCs.

So, resentment against institutions is on the rise. Violence during the Bharat Bandh on 2 April last year against the alleged dilution of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act and during the celebration to mark the Battle of Bhima Koregaon, or the Bharat Bandh against the 13-point reservation roster for faculty recruitment in colleges should be a wake-up call for the Indian state.

After similar acts of resentment among Blacks during turbulent 1960s, the US federal government instituted the Kerner Commission to investigate the reasons for the racial riots. The idea of affirmative action and adoption of the diversity principle by the US state, corporations and the media are a result of an awakening post the racial riots in the US.

Diversity in workforce in the US and European companies has done no harm to their top line and bottom line. Rather it has benefitted them by expanding the talent pool. Indian diaspora in the US and Canada are also flourishing due to the diversity programmes of these corporations.

Is it time for the Indian state, the corporates and the media to also take note of the brewing resentment among the underclass?

On the other side, the Indian ruling class may act not so benevolent. It may adopt coercion as a means to quell the disenchantment of Dalits and tribals and other sections of the underclass. The UPA government had tried this in the tribal areas of Chhattisgarh, with Salwa Judum and Operation Green Hunt. The clampdown on Bhima Koregaon protests and the subsequent arrests and surveillance of Dalit activists under the Modi government are a sign that the Indian state is going to learn the wrong lesson from the disquiet on the ground.

Ironically, the socially privileged Indian middle class, which has largely benefitted from the Indian democracy in the last 70 years, has shown its dissatisfaction with the Constitution. It wishes to overturn many of the foundational principles of the Constitution like religious freedom, personal laws, state patronage to minority institutions and reservation. This class pours scorn on the Constitution and believes it contains ‘imported’ ideas from the West, and is not Indic enough.

The privileged want a rethink, even as they make a big deal of the official commemoration of the Constitution Day. The Dalits cherish it. This is one of the biggest contradictions of Indian democracy.


Also read: A Dalit laid first brick for Ram Mandir. Now, Modi must appoint a Dalit woman as its priest


The author is an adjunct professor, Dept of Mass Communications at Makhanlal Chaturvedi National University of Journalism and Communication (MCNUJC), Bhopal. He is the former managing editor of India Today Hindi Magazine, and has authored books on media and sociology. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

6 COMMENTS

  1. This professor has nothing to do with knowledge, he is most toxic casteist personality in current era. I condemn this personality and want to ask government to ban him as soon as possible.

  2. Casta is foreign concept and has nothing to do with how Portuguese and Spanish practice racist Christianity. Europe had slavery and serfdom, in Russia till 1850s. Till we examine the real situation, Islam and Christianity pushing Hindus to the edge of genocide, we cannot understand how imported nonsense like casta has been used to oppress Hindus. Hindu India certainly had classes and heriditary classes as well. Still, compared the slave states of Arabia or Genocidal Jesus States of West, India never had the evils of slavery and serfdom, till Islam and later Christians came. In the 1700s the English and the Moslems made and an agreement that slavery should be allowed to continue but no Muslims or Christians could be kept as slaves. This forced slaves to convert, I guess they didn’t use a sword.

  3. Author puts himself in a bind in trying to justify himself through ‘constitutionalism’, his argument is this –

    Dalits celebrate Constitution because it is the document which gives them hope at the same time he acknowledges that it has not worked since inequality increased dis-proportionally & thus dalits celebrate constitutional contradiction because they don’t really want to try anything else & even things which may actually change their material conditions and are happy with only with the illusionary emancipatory promises of constitution.

    Privileged or others want rethink because they are religious chauvianists & privileged bigots.

  4. The USA constitution has been revised thirty odd times in 200 Plus years. How many revision of the Indian constitution? Few thousands????

  5. Thank you dear author for saying the obvious, that never-the-less needs to be said. Annihilation of caste is the revolution India needs but never managed to have in spite of two thousand years of sporadic effort. till this becomes a reality (along with equal rights for women), we can not truly progress and no other permanent evolution or revolution is possible towards a better future.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular

×