New Delhi: Left for dead by the men who gangraped her, Bilkis Bano wanted to move on. She did not seek harsher punishment for the 11 men convicted of the crime, focusing instead on rebuilding her life, finding peace and leaving behind the years of violence and court battles. But the fight continues to find its way back to her, senior advocate Shobha Gupta, her lawyer for over 20 years, told ThePrint.
Gupta said Bano had never wanted to prolong the legal battle indefinitely. After the trial court and the Bombay High Court sentenced her rapists to life imprisonment rather than the death penalty, several senior lawyers suggested that she appeal against the verdict and seek capital punishment considering the extreme nature of the crime.
But Bano refused. She told Gupta that it was enough that the convicts had been punished, regardless of the nature of punishment, and that she now wanted to rebuild her life.
“She wanted to move on. She wanted peace. Even after that judgment, she was trying to attain peace and put everything behind her. Once the remission was cancelled and the convicts were directed to return to jail, there was no reason for us to keep following the court proceedings,” Gupta said.
Yet the legal battle continues to find its way back to Bano. The Supreme Court’s recent decision to suspend the sentences of two men convicted of gangraping her and grant them bail has revived the fear she had struggled to put behind her, Gupta said.
“Bano is somebody who craves peace and an opportunity to have a life of her own, away from all of this. Unfortunately, these developments are not letting her be. Things keep coming back to her, again and again, not allowing her to move on,” Gupta added.
The latest Supreme Court order was particularly difficult for Bano because it came as a shock, Gupta said.
“It is one thing to say that a wrong had happened when the remission was granted. But when something like this happens again, without even making you a party to the proceedings, it unfortunately shakes your faith,” Gupta said.
There is a big difference between making someone a party to the proceedings, informing them they are being heard, and then passing an order against them, versus an order simply coming as a shock, she added.
Gupta said the violence Bano endured had left a lasting impact, with persistent fear and anxiety forcing her to remain largely withdrawn and away from the limelight.
“This time, when I spoke to Bano over a video call after the latest development, she was crying. These are the few moments when she actually speaks and expresses what she feels. Unfortunately, this latest development has been extremely traumatic for her,” Gupta said.
Also Read: The relentless Bilkis Bano: All the times she turned to the courts to fight back
A life still shaped by fear
Even after the Supreme Court’s 2019 order directing that Bano be given a job, a house and Rs 50 lakh in compensation for her suffering, rebuilding her life remained difficult, Gupta said.
“She could not take up the job because she continued to suffer from fear psychosis. She was afraid of being around strangers, particularly men. She is still on antidepressants and does not have the courage to step out and work,” Gupta told ThePrint.
The compensation and the house, however, helped provide some stability. Land was allotted to Bano, on which she subsequently built a house. “For someone who had spent 17 years moving from place to place, having a home where she could finally stay was significant,” Gupta said.
However, when the Gujarat government granted early release of the 11 convicts, all that fear returned, she added. “They became frightened of staying there, immediately left the house and went into hiding. Even now, they are not sure what to do. After everything they have been through, they are once again faced with the question of where they can live safely,” said Gupta.
A 2024 Supreme Court judgment had taken note of Bano’s repeated relocations over the past two decades. She had lived in more than 20 locations and safe houses across Gujarat, Maharashtra and Delhi because of death threats. Now, with two of the convicts granted bail, Bano and her family have once again fled Gujarat.
Bano’s aversion to crowds has also shaped her relationship with the court proceedings that have occupied much of her life. Gupta said she generally avoids court appearances and dislikes being seen or having to face people.
However, during the hearings on the appeal against the early release of the 11 convicts, Bano expressed a desire to attend. She followed the proceedings through video-conferencing, despite not understanding English, Gupta recalled.
Initially, she kept her camera switched off. But after Gupta informed the Bench that Bano was present and following the proceedings online, she switched it on briefly on the final day of arguments, when the hearings were nearing their conclusion.
“It was her way of expressing gratitude to the judges for giving the matter their sincere attention and hearing it at such length,” Gupta said.
“She is a person of very few words. She keeps herself away from the limelight and the glitter. She does not have the capacity to face the world. She continues to suffer from that fear psychosis, which does not allow her to come amongst people. But she wanted to show her respect and gratitude to the court. So she switched on her camera and sat on the floor. She did not have to say anything. She simply sat there with her camera on and said thank you. This was the best she could do for the court. This was her way of saying thank you,” Gupta said.
Gupta also recalled a video call from Bano after the Supreme Court cancelled the remission and directed the convicts to return to jail.
Bano, who rarely expresses her emotions, had little to say during most conversations. But on that occasion, she smiled, thanked Gupta and asked to speak to her mother.
“I know she is a person who finds it difficult to express herself. So, when she smiled and said those words, it meant a lot. Sometimes, certain developments are so heartening that they make even someone who has almost stopped expressing herself open up,” Gupta said.
The latest development threatens to undo the limited progress Bano has made in rebuilding her life. But she remains unshakeable.
“We will be challenging the order as soon as possible. This is a cause for all of us. It is the pain of all of us. We are all standing together,” Gupta said.
(Edited by Chingkheinganbi Mayengbam)
Also Read: Bilkis Bano’s rapists are finally back in prison. Now, it’s time to address the root cause
