New graves at the Mhow Naka burial ground in Covid-19 hotspot Indore | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti | ThePrint
(Representational Image) of a graveyard | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti | ThePrint
Text Size:

Indore: At the Mhow Naka burial ground, Indore’s largest, a group of about 10 men, with handkerchiefs tied around their faces, lugs a coffin out of a truck and makes its way to a grave dug just a few metres away.

It’s a sight that has become all too familiar at Mhow Naka and other graveyards in Madhya Pradesh’s commercial capital Indore, a Covid-19 hotspot city. Ever since the nationwide lockdown came into effect on the midnight of 24-25 March, Indore has seen a drastic increase in the number of deaths among Muslims.

Indore Municipal Corporation data shows that in the first two weeks of April, the city has witnessed a massive spike in burials, but there is no corresponding spike from Hindu cremation grounds.

ThePrint visited the city’s biggest burial grounds to find out why this spike had occurred, and was told by city officials and people in-charge of the graveyards that not many deaths were related to Covid-19, despite several containment zones in the city falling in areas with high Muslim populations.

Several people said a lot of these deaths had occurred because the people were denied treatment at hospitals. However, Indore Collector Manish Singh told ThePrint that the reason for the spike in Muslim deaths could be the strictness of the lockdown.

“From 25 March to 29 March, the atmosphere was a little liberal, but it became stricter after 29 March. Then, we closed all the clinics, which are a potential source of the spread of infection. The local doctors were made to sit outside and treat patients,” he said.

“It is possible that because of hypertension, sugar and heart ailments, such localised cases happened. But nothing happened on a large scale,” Singh said.

We are deeply grateful to our readers & viewers for their time, trust and subscriptions.

Quality journalism is expensive and needs readers to pay for it. Your support will define our work and ThePrint’s future.

SUBSCRIBE NOW


Also read: ‘Should we poison our kids?’ — Indore daily wagers complain of sparse, erratic food supply


‘JCB’ brought in to dig more graves

The number of bodies buried at Mhow Naka alone between 1 and 16 April was 75, compared to 10 in March, 29 in February and 48 in January.

“Earlier, we would get two or three bodies every day. In a month, 30-35 bodies were normal. But after the (Covid-19) infection, this number has increased by 25-30 bodies,” a weary-eyed Mubarik Hussain, in-charge of the cemetery, told ThePrint.

Hussain said the cause of the deaths were predominantly heart attacks, high blood pressure, diabetes and hypertension. Only 8-10 bodied were those of Covid-19 patients, and they too had tested positive after death, he said.

“In some cases, people did not get proper treatment — hospitals refuse to admit them. Some also died at the gates of the hospitals. They were just going around from hospital to hospital,” Hussain said.

Mhow Naka burial ground in-charge Mubarik Hussain | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti | ThePrint
Mhow Naka burial ground in-charge Mubarik Hussain | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti | ThePrint

ThePrint spotted a digger, commonly known by its brand name ‘JCB’, which had just finished digging a grave. Hussain said the machine had been brought in by the local authorities to help the overburdened staff. “There are only four people here to dig the graves. So, sometimes, families also end up digging graves,” he said.

Residents of the neighbouring Samajwad area described the frequent sight of bodies being brought to be buried. Subhash Chouhan, 36, who lives just about 100 feet away from the burial ground, said, “I’ve seen 8-10 bodies being brought in one day. Four people would bring it in a cart and bury it just two or three feet into the ground.”

Chouhan said he shot a video of a burial — he presumed it was that of a Covid-19 patient, since out of six people who buried the body, three were wrapped in personal protective equipment.

Another resident, Rahul Nangi, said: “They bring the bodies here at night or early morning. The colony is sealed, and people are very scared of the infection spreading. We had also sent an appeal to the Chhatripura police station.”


Also read: This Indore hospital ‘first in India’ to try TCZ in critical Covid cases, claims good results


Not limited to one graveyard

The upward trend of burials has been observed at three other burial grounds too. At the Banganga cemetery, 44 bodies were buried between 1 and 16 April, of which 29 were brought in just between the 10th and the 16th. The numbers for the three preceding months were 10 (March), 11 (February) and 9 (January).

At the Chandan Nagar cemetery, the 1-16 April figure was 56, compared to 30 in March, 12 in February and 7 in January.

But the jump at Luniyapura graveyard was even bigger — 96 bodies were brought there in the first 16 days of burial, compared to just 5 in March, 13 in February and 20 in January.

Luniyapura graveyard in-charge Rafique Shah | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti
Luniyapura graveyard in-charge Rafique Shah | Photo: Angana Chakrabarti

“More people die out of anxiety and of not getting treatment. No one wants to touch them in the hospitals,” said an exasperated-looking Luniyapura cemetery in-charge Rafique Shah.

“We are digging five to seven graves every day — twice the usual number. I’ve had to employ three people when usually it’s just me.”


Also read: 1 sample a day to over 350: How Indore’s 5-month-old virology lab raised its testing capacity


The state of Hindu cremation grounds 

Data shows that the number of bodies at Hindu cremation grounds hasn’t spiked as much as at the Muslim graveyards.

At Panchkuian cremation ground, the largest in Indore, 95 bodies were cremated between 1 and 16 April, compared to 128 in March, 161 in February and 243 in January.

Similarly, at Juni cremation ground, 39 bodies were brought in the first 16 days of April, while the numbers for the previous three months stood at 18 (March), 26 (February) and 48 (January).

Juni cremation ground stands just about a kilometre away from Luniyapura cemetery, and its in-charge, Sohanlal Jeevan, said there had been only a slight increase since the Covid-19 outbreak.

“Earlier, five bodies used to come in a day; now the number is about eight. There are also one or two patients of Covid-19,” he said.

Acknowleding the bigger spike in the figures at the nearby cemetery, Jeevan said: “There, the rise has been nearly three times. What was usually the case for the whole month is now being seen within eight days.”


Also read: 5-hr sleep, limited PPE, bath outside home: Life of officers called back to aid hotspot Indore


‘Left without treatment’

Social worker Anwar Dehalvi said several of the deaths occurred because the patients were denied treatment.

“The private hospitals have especially done a lot of injustice. In one day, we would have to go to eight places with one patient. But the hospitals refused to take them in, saying there are no beds,” he said.

Dehalvi, a resident of Bombay Bazar, a hotspot zone in Indore, claimed that at least 25 patients had died in the area because they were denied treatment.

Among them was Mohammed Javed’s 65-year-old father, a fruit seller. Javed told ThePrint that his father fell sick on 12 April, but had to be taken around for at least two hours before a hospital admitted him.

“He was running a temperature. We took him to four or five hospitals, but no one was willing to admit him. They told us that there weren’t any beds and we should go elsewhere. With a lot of difficulties, we admitted him to one hospital. He died the next day at 8.30 am,” he said.

“This is wrong; you can’t refuse a patient. It’s their duty to admit him,” Javed said.


Also read: At Indore’s Covid-19 Ground Zero, there’s fear, suspicion and hostility — but some hope too


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

News media is in a crisis & only you can fix it

You are reading this because you value good, intelligent and objective journalism. We thank you for your time and your trust.

You also know that the news media is facing an unprecedented crisis. It is likely that you are also hearing of the brutal layoffs and pay-cuts hitting the industry. There are many reasons why the media’s economics is broken. But a big one is that good people are not yet paying enough for good journalism.

We have a newsroom filled with talented young reporters. We also have the country’s most robust editing and fact-checking team, finest news photographers and video professionals. We are building India’s most ambitious and energetic news platform. And we aren’t even three yet.

At ThePrint, we invest in quality journalists. We pay them fairly and on time even in this difficult period. As you may have noticed, we do not flinch from spending whatever it takes to make sure our reporters reach where the story is. Our stellar coronavirus coverage is a good example. You can check some of it here.

This comes with a sizable cost. For us to continue bringing quality journalism, we need readers like you to pay for it. Because the advertising market is broken too.

If you think we deserve your support, do join us in this endeavour to strengthen fair, free, courageous, and questioning journalism, please click on the link below. Your support will define our journalism, and ThePrint’s future. It will take just a few seconds of your time.

Support Our Journalism

7 Comments Share Your Views

7 COMMENTS

  1. What a bullshit article. Muslims claim they have nothing to fear from corona and Koran se nikla hai corona ( corona is derived from corona ) and that corona is allahs wrath for CAb. They don’t observe social distancing, they want to pray five times in mosque. It is expected that they will get infected more. If anything they have spread it to others. Stop painting Muslims as victims.

  2. Even now you are not recognising the fact that Muslims don’t take social distancing seriously.

    I closely work with health department.
    There is no corono virus out break here. Only 10 cases so far
    Doctors see regular patient but are adviced not to come for simple things.

    Most people listen. However there seems to be a feeling of invincibility among Muslims. They continue to visit for the silliest of things

    May be the preaching by some priests or the magzines like you who fail to understand and propogate the correct thing are responsible

    In your game of one-upsamship and hate propogation, it will be the poor Musalman who suffer.

    Please wake up

  3. Absolute Propaganda, Muslims need to step out of this Persecuted complex and Victim Card tactics now. Nobody, globally is buying into their bullshit anymore.

    And the Print you are the same outlet that das speaking against communalising the deaths of Hindu Sadhus at Palgarh. Do you have 1 bit of shame or self realization left to counter your Hipocricy and propagandist bullshit?

  4. Did these ladies who call journalists, themselves even think of calling up the registrar office for verification of their claim that more Muslims are dying than before?

  5. If the deaths are not related to Covid and are due to comorbidities, then why hasn’t there been a similar spike in cremated bodies

  6. First, Population control is the best solution for all the problems. Second the government should develop the villages and rural areas to stop the migration. Third, the government should stop giving money to caste and religious schemes and invest that money on the construction of hospitals, medical colleges and health sector.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here