Saturday, 22 January, 2022
HomeIndiaGovernanceManeka can order any inquiry she deems fit on tigress Avni death:...

Maneka can order any inquiry she deems fit on tigress Avni death: Maharashtra minister

Text Size:

Under fire, forest minister Sudhir Mungantiwar says Maneka Gandhi should’ve called him to verify facts, says team shot tigress in self-defence.

Mumbai: Following sharp criticism from Union Minister Maneka Gandhi and the public outcry over the killing of the ‘man-eating’ tigress Avni, Maharashtra Forest Minister Sudhir Mungantiwar Monday defended the shooting as an act of self-defence and said he would request Gandhi to constitute any inquiry “she deems fit” to clear her doubts.

“Maneka Gandhi is very passionate about animal rights and may have made some remarks out of ignorance. I am writing to her to request her to constitute an inquiry into the incident at any level, national or even global, that she deems fit to clear any doubts she has,” he said.

“My department will cooperate. It will not be right for the department itself to inquire into the incident because people will then cry conflict of interest.”

The BJP minister added that Gandhi should “have spent at least 50 paisa” in making a call to him regarding her doubts, instead of going public on social media armed with “ignorance and misinformation”.

He also said that the outcry had demoralised the state forest department.

“A number of people have raised doubts and concerns regarding the killing of tigress T1 (as Avni was referred to by the forest department) and made derogatory comments, which has dented the spirit of forest department employees who have been doing their best for tiger conservation,” Mungantiwar told the media. “Tigers are not enemies of the forest department.”

Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis too said there needs to be an inquiry to see if there were any lapses in procedure.

“What exactly happened needs to be examined and if there are any lapses in the procedure I will look into it,” Fadnavis said in an interaction with the media at his official residence, Varsha.

“Maneka Gandhi is very sensitive about animal rights issues and calls very often showing concern over animal issues. One needs to understand the sentiment behind what she said,” he added.

Tigress Avni was shot dead Saturday by the son of the controversial Hyderabad-based hunter Nawab Shafat Ali Khan, who was hired by the Maharashtra forest department to capture the tigress. Khan’s involvement in the operation had sparked massive protests from animal rights activists.

Amid the outcry, Gandhi specifically targeted Mungantiwar Sunday, saying he regularly gave orders for the killing of animals, including thrice for tigers, and accused him of always relying on Khan to shoot the animals.

Also read: Orphaned, tigress Avni’s 10-month-old cubs stare at death or captivity

‘Department made all efforts to capture Avni’

Responding to the charges, Mungantiwar Monday insisted that the forest department had made every effort to tranquillise and capture Avni instead of killing her.

On the day the tigress died, the minister said a team of forest department officials had gone in search of the tigress and the nawab’s son was part of the team.

“When they spotted the tigress they fired a dart to tranquilise her but she turned on them. In self-defence, they shot her,” Mungantiwar said.

Forest department officials added that a tiger does not get tranquilised within a few seconds by a single dart. “The tranquilisation too had to be done carefully as we did not want to kill the tigress with an over-dose either,” a senior official said.

Also read: ‘Trigger-happy’ hunter’s son kills tigress Avni, but no one’s saying how he got there

‘Followed NTCA norms’

Stating that the tigress had killed 13 people, including eight tribals, since 2016, Mungantiwar said the government had followed the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) guidelines in declaring her a man-eater.

Directions to either tranquilise and capture or as a last resort eliminate Avni were also given as per NTCA guidelines, Mungantiwar said. He added that he had no role in the process as NTCA norms mandate a committee to study the situation and submit a report to the principal chief conservator of forests who issues the directions.

The minister said the directions were initially challenged in the Bombay High Court and later the Supreme Court, both of which ruled in favour of the Maharashtra forest department.

Regarding allegations that he ordered the killing of three tigers, the minister provided statistics to show that such orders were given only twice in his tenure — once in 2017 and now with Avni.

The forest minister defended hiring Khan as the shooter, saying several states such as Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Telangana and Bihar have also turned to him in man-animal conflicts. He made it a point to emphasise, several times, that it was Khan who was hired to capture or kill a tiger in Pilbhit in 2009 when Gandhi was the local MP.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. At one level I am sad that the tigress Avani was killed. At a different level, I feel overjoyed that as a society we are debating life of a tiger. We have SOPs to capture a wildlife, tranquillise it and instead of putting it to sleep, rehabilitate it. Many animals have supporters that take their issue to Supreme Court. Attention being paid to plight of Avani may make many humans jealous, because attention is not to garner vote (Avani could not vote) but out of genuine sadness and concern. This is certainly a sign of regeneration of a kind and caring society. Whether Avani was killed deliberately, whether Avani had attacked wildlife officials will emerge if an enquiry is held. In exploding population of India, people need job, people need livelihood. So conflict between man and animal is becoming inevitable. More you displace man, more man becomes hostile to animal. If man encroaches on animal territory, animal attacks become more frequent. I think solution lies in controlling human population drastically. So far no political party is talking about it. Politicians have to win election. They have to listen to what their voters say. May be voters are asking wrongly, but they vote for the politician. If this politician does not act, someone else will be chosen who will act. Create imbalance in human population, everything else will fall in place. Finally, a noted wild life activist from Ranthambhore, Dickey Singh, has said tigers of the age 1.5 – 2 years may not die of starvation. They may face difficulty, but they will live.

  2. Everything public servants do in the line of duty should not become a controversy. There was a famous tigress called Machhli, I remember the farewell the forest department of Rajasthan gave her when she died a natural death. Fit for a Rajput princess, which she was. Or the recent case of a plastic ring that slipped onto a stork’s beak in Haryana, which prevented her from feeding, and how the forest officials rescued it. In Avni’s case, she had turned a man eater. Jim Corbett would have done the honours if he had been alive. Conservationists should not become ayatollahs.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular