Saturday, 22 January, 2022
HomeIndia'Deeply hurtful' — why Ramakrishna Mission is not happy with Modi's CAA...

‘Deeply hurtful’ — why Ramakrishna Mission is not happy with Modi’s CAA comments in Belur

Members of Ramakrishna Mission & Ramakrishna Math and have expressed displeasure over PM Modi's speech on CAA at Belur Math in West Bengal Sunday.

Text Size:

New Delhi: A day after Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressed people on the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) at Belur Math, the headquarters of the Ramakrishna Mission and the Ramakrishna Math, members of the two organisations Monday expressed displeasure over his “political speech” from an “apolitical platform”.

“The Citizenship Act was not brought overnight. We have only brought an amendment to the Citizenship Act and have made it easier for those who have suffered persecution in Pakistan, after Partition, to get Indian citizenship,” Modi had said while addressing the youth at Belur Math, in West Bengal’s Howrah district.

The PM had spent the night at the Math and addressed students Sunday morning, marking the birth anniversary of Swami Vivekananda, which is also observed as the National Youth Day.

Modi’s “political” address, however, didn’t go down well with members of the organisation. Gautam Roy, a member of RKM, was quoted as saying it was “deeply hurtful to see controversial political messages being disseminated from the platform of RKM (Ramakrishna Mission), which is an apolitical body”.

Swami Suvirananda, the Ramakrishna Math and Mission’s general secretary, also said, “We are an inclusive organisation, which has monks from Hindu, Islam and Christian communities. We live like brothers of the same parents. To us, Narendra Modi is the leader of India and Mamata Banerjee the leader of West Bengal.”

He also said members of the organisations come there “to answer eternal calls” and they do not “respond to ephemeral calls”.

Quoting several senior monks, a report in The Telegraph said the general understanding was that PM Modi, who says he is a follower of Swami Vivekananda, would “stick to speaking about the great leader and his vision”.

They said they did not expect Modi to talk about politics.

“This was not what we had anticipated. But we could not have whispered into the Prime Minister’s ears to stop midway. It is not proper,” the report quoted a senior monk as saying.

Also read: Narendra Modi is losing his political mojo

‘Non-political & non-sectarian spiritual organisations’

The Ramakrishna Math and Ramakrishna Mission identify themselves as “worldwide, non-political and non-sectarian spiritual organisations”. Actively involved in relief work, youth development and rural services, the organisations own several hospitals and educational institutions which aim to provide care to all, irrespective of one’s caste, creed or gender.

Both organisations were brought into existence by Sri Ramakrishna Paramahansa’s chief disciple Swami Vivekananda after Paramahansa’s demise. Sri Ramakrishna was a the 19th-century saint from Bengal.

The twin organisations claim to have set in motion a “non-sectarian, universal spiritual movement which has been silently working for more than a hundred years to catalyse the spiritual regeneration of humanity”.

The organisations have over 208 centres across the world, including 157 in India, 15 in Bangladesh and 14 in the US.

Modi wanted to join Ramakrishna Mission as a teenager

The camaraderie and mutual respect between the PM and the Ramkrishna Mission go back to the mid-sixties when as a teenager Modi, inspired by the teachings of Swami Vivekananda, had arrived at the Mission’s Rajkot branch in Gujarat and expressed his desire to join the order.

Swami Atmasthananda, who then headed the Rajkot branch in 1966 and later went on to become the 15th president of the Ramakrishna Math and the Ramakrishna Mission, advised Modi against taking sanyas. He was asked to work among people and not in seclusion.

Not surprisingly then, that in 2017, the PM had called Atmasthananda’s death a “personal loss”.

Modi’s unequivocal support for the CAA, during his Belur Math address, also seemed in contrast to what Vivekananda had said in his famous 1893 speech in Chicago when he said India “always offered refuge to the persecuted from all nations and faiths”.

Also read: TMC and CPM activists begin anti-CAA and NRC protests ahead of PM Modi’s visit to West Bengal

Disassociating from the ‘political’

The Ramakrishna Math and the Ramakrishna Mission have always been apolitical. Hundreds of monks here do not vote even though most of them have a voter ID. This is because voting would mean taking sides of a political party “which would take them beyond the spiritual path”.

A senior monk has been quoted as saying: “…we never vote as we do not take part in politics or express our political opinion in public…Swamiji gave us instructions that we should focus on spiritual activities and do humanitarian activities for the upliftment of society.”

Swami Chetanananda, another senior monk at the mission, similarly said, “We are not even allowed to vote. Otherwise, by now you would have seen some political party trying to seek affinity, this hasn’t happened because of Swamiji’s rare acumen.”

So when it came to Modi’s political comments on the CAA, senior member Roy explained: “Let me make two things clear. One, RKM has an elaborate and official process of consecration. Mr Modi has not been officially consecrated and two, he is not allowed to come and make statements which are political in nature.”

Also read: Mamata Banerjee first meets PM Modi at Raj Bhavan & then shouts anti-CAA slogans


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. When will these stupid Hindu organizations learn to be Hindus with a spine??

  2. WHY doesn’t @ The print & other leftists shift to Pakistan & be at peace with their Muslim brotherhood??
    They will also have good company like Taliban & Mohammad’s kin!!

  3. By implementing CAA, Modi is trying to prevent terrorism getting imported from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Buy opposing it, Bengal and Kerala are giving fertile land for Al-Qaida to grow. The situation in India in 1893 was different

  4. If swami Vivekananda was their they were feeling sad they told all are equal but modi is separating us. Down down modi and Amit shah. We will not leave to bring CAA in our country. In Delhi election bjp will loose. This loss is the gift for bjp.

  5. Correction : We did not ‘distance’ ourselves from NaMo, as some allege. We chose not to comment in public and said that politics is not our job. We pointed out that PM is our Nation’s leader and that CM is a State’s leader. We had very warm time with NaMo and our students had very enthusiastic interaction on the Youth Day with NaMo. Thanks PM Narendra Modi ! God bless you.

  6. Swamiji would have been proud that India finally has a leader who thinks only about the country and not about his family and relations
    Modiji decisions have only benefited the country be it Swacch Bharat Make in India smart cities Ayushaman Bharat Mudra Schemes Jan dhan Yojana
    Compared to Modiji the rest of the political parties have only Pappu

  7. Modi only pretends to be a follower of Swami Vivekananda. There is nothing common between him and the great Swami. The Swami’s message was one of hope, aspiration and strength both spiritual and on the material plane. Modi’s philosophy is exactly the opposite, one of whining, grievances and weakness.

    • @Vish: Ha!! Ha!! Your puppu has qualities of asuras as his mother, the Italian fascist!!

  8. Another milestone in the downward slide of Shah/Modi as imporant as the gesture of Deepika Padukone last week. Deep respect for RKM.

  9. kuch bhi likha hai print ne…apne mar marzi se 2-3 logon ka quote likh do…during the speech the loud roar only explained how much people supported what modi said..

  10. “Modi’s unequivocal support for the CAA, during his Belur Math address, also seemed in contrast to what Vivekananda had said in his famous 1893 speech in Chicago when he said India “always offered refuge to the persecuted from all nations and faiths”.”

    No dichotomy. The emphasis here is on ‘persecuted’ and Modi considers that people of one faith do not qualify as persecuted. The rest are all persecuted.

    • A faith which has:

      . persecuted & killed other faiths and especially Hindus for centuries
      . which made slaves of poor Dalit Hindus in Kashmir
      . regards women as slaves
      . continues to kill Sikhs/Hindus in India, & in theocratic states like Pakistan/Bangladesh

      That is a “faith” which needs a complete ban and should be compelled to discard it’s values of pigs & dirty animals!!

  11. That is it!That is it! This fellow (has no respect for this man anymore) is spreading venom everywhere to divide our society! Racist, fascist minded, autocratic and what not to be said about this man !! Have tarnished the image of RKM and Sri.Vivekananda !!!Think twice next time whether to entertain this fellow in RKM!!!

    • @santosh banerjee: PM Modi is a trillion times better than the rotten, spineless & brainless communist & Jihadi pig existence that you seem yo follow!! And if you are not a rice bag convert or someone shamelessly keeping a Hindu name, then shame on you!!

Comments are closed.

Most Popular