Wednesday, May 31, 2023
Support Our Journalism
HomeIndia18 months, 5 reminders — CBI yet to get Speaker nod to...

18 months, 5 reminders — CBI yet to get Speaker nod to prosecute Trinamool MPs in Narada scam

CBI took over case in 2017 and sought permission in April 2019 from Lok Sabha Speaker to prosecute three MPs — Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar, Sougata Roy and Prasun Banerjee — and former MP Subhendu Adhikari.

Text Size:

Kolkata: At least 18 months and five reminders later, the CBI is yet to receive approval from the Lok Sabha Speaker to prosecute three Trinamool Congress (TMC) MPs and a former party parliamentarian accused in the Narada sting operation and bribery scam.

The sting operation, conducted by Narada News, purportedly showed Trinamool Congress leaders, MPs and cabinet ministers accepting bribes. It hit the headlines before the 2016 assembly elections in Bengal.

The CBI had taken over the case in 2017 and had sought permission from the Lok Sabha Speaker to prosecute three MPs — Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar, Sougata Roy and Prasun Banerjee — and former MP Subhendu Adhikari in April 2019.

The agency is yet to receive the Speaker’s assent.

“We had requested for prosecution approval from the Lok Sabha speaker for four MPs in April 2019. In the past 18 months, we have sent at least four to five reminders to the Lok Sabha requesting the necessary approval,” a senior CBI official told The Print.

“We have informed the Calcutta High Court about the delay. We will not be able to file the charge sheet without LS approval,” he said. “The approval for the accused IPS officer (S.M.H. Mirza) is also pending with the central government.”

ThePrint reached the Lok Sabha Speaker’s office Friday and Monday through calls and texts seeking a response. ThePrint also contacted the office of the secretary general of the Lok Sabha on Friday and Monday through calls and emails for a comment. But no response was received till the time of publishing this report.

ThePrint reached the CBI spokesperson in Delhi through calls and mail on Monday and Tuesday but is yet to receive a response.

Meanwhile, the ethics committee formed under the chairmanship of L.K. Advani to probe the alleged involvement of the accused MPs did not even meet once in the last four years.

The CBI and the Enforcement Directorate (ED), both central government agencies, are ready with their probe reports and charge sheets, ThePrint has learnt.

Also read: BJP, Congress, Trinamool, Left, Governor — in Bengal, everyone’s ‘being snooped on’

Narada scam and the investigation

The scam broke in 2016, before the assembly elections, when a website called Narada News purportedly showed Trinamool Congress leaders, MPs and cabinet ministers accepting bribes. S.M.H. Mirza, a serving IPS officer of the West Bengal cadre, is also an accused in the case .

A year later, the Calcutta High Court in March 2017 directed the CBI to investigate the case. The CBI registered an FIR in the case and named 13 accused, of whom nine are top Trinamool leaders apart from a senior IPS officer.

A senior ED official said the agency also probed and prepared a detailed report on the money trail of some senior Trinamool leaders.

“We have traced the money trail of some senior Trinamool leaders. But we cannot file a charge sheet until the Lok Sabha gives permission to the CBI,” the official said.

According to the Prevention of Corruption Act, 2018, investigating agencies require the Lok Sabha Speaker’s approval for prosecuting sitting and former MPs.

Delay due to politics of poaching: Congress

Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha and the West Bengal Congress president, said the BJP is “deliberately” delaying the corruption case.

“This is an unholy nexus. The probe agencies are ready with evidence but they are not getting permission from the government despite the PM and HM speaking several times on the Narada scam,” Chowdhury said.

Two of the accused — former union minister Mukul Roy and former state minister Sovan Chatterjee — have since joined the BJP from the TMC.

The state BJP, however, insists that action will be taken.

“We raised this issue in Parliament. We will again appeal to the central government about this,” said Dilip Ghosh, the BJP’s state president.

Kailash Vijayvargiya, BJP’s national general secretary and West Bengal incharge, said, “I will ask our MPs to meet the Lok Sabha speaker and discuss the reasons behind this delay.”

Also read: Covid deaths & cases rising, tests down — Bengal stares at grim scenario ahead of Durga Puja


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Saradha scam was handed over to CBI in 2013 and Narada scam in 2016. Both these scam are being investigated by CBI at the order of Top court and Calcutta High court. Modi and Amit Shah have made it an election issue and an issue with which to get these TMC MPs and MLAs into their camp. This happens in India where CBI is under the Prime Minister and ED as well and their service conditions and promotion systems are such that they cannot function independent of their Political Master just like CID and Police cannot function independent of their Political masters be it in Bengal or in UP. Naturally these issues are no more a corruption issue but an issue to exploit politically to the advantage of the Political party in power. This was used in 2014 Lok Sabha election by BJP, and Narada was used along with Saradha in Assembly elections in 2016 and now it is being used in elections that iscoming up in 2021. Narendra Modi / Amit Shah Zindabbad. What Shubhendu is now calling TMC as Tolabaz sarkar to which he belonged and was Minister in Mamata Govt. and certainly if mamata is leading a Tolabaz Govt. then no one should doubt that Shubhendu being one of the beneficiary as well but his Father Shishir Adhikary another TMC MP of Shubvbhendu is still at large with Mamata. Now Shishir Adhikary must condemn Shubhendu switching to BJP or he should also join the Bandwagon else Mamata Must expel this man as well and sooner the better.

  2. System of Law and Parliament is totally support criminals and corrupts. From Advani to present generation of all parliamentarians are associated with criminals. They make laws for criminality. Supreme Court also works as an onlookers. People are fed up with the criminals.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular