SC has rightly remarked that a conscientious objector cannot be penalised for not singing Vande Mataram. Its 1986 judgment that quashed rustication of school students for refusing to sing the national anthem remains a binding law. Ciminalising non-rendition is disproportionate, undermines constitutional tolerance, and religious freedom. Nationalism can’t be coerced.
In 2017, Shekhar Gupta started ThePrint with a simple belief: Indian readers want journalism that asks why and what next, not just what. And that enough of them would be willing to pay for good journalism.
Nine years on, that belief has held.
And, in these nine years, we’ve stayed true to our mission. We’ve been asking the follow-up questions, going beyond the headlines and explaining what’s actually happening. We’ve travelled across the country to bring you in-depth, visually-compelling stories from the ground.
It’s been nine years of readers choosing to make this possible. If you’d like to be one of them:
That’s the point. Nationalism cannot be coerced.
And most Indian Muslims don’t have any issues in singing either Jana Gana Mana or Vande Mataram.
It’s just the Pakistan inspired fundamentalist Muslims who have objections to singing these venerable songs. Of course, nationalism cannot be expected from them.
Our Constitution, quite unfortunately, gives such elements leeway to get away with worse.
That’s the point. Nationalism cannot be coerced.
And most Indian Muslims don’t have any issues in singing either Jana Gana Mana or Vande Mataram.
It’s just the Pakistan inspired fundamentalist Muslims who have objections to singing these venerable songs. Of course, nationalism cannot be expected from them.
Our Constitution, quite unfortunately, gives such elements leeway to get away with worse.
That’s the point. Nationalism cannot be coerced.
And most Indian Muslims don’t have any issues in singing either Jana Gana Mana or Vande Mataram.
It’s just the Pakistan inspired fundamentalist Muslims who have objections to singing these venerable songs. Of course, nationalism cannot be expected from them.
Our Constitution, quite unfortunately, gives such elements leeway to get away with worse.
Pseudo nationalism. To be filed with pseudo secularism.