Purchasing car insurance is mandatory by law in India under the Motor Vehicle Act. While Third-party car insurance is compulsory for all car owners, Comprehensive car insurance provides more extensive coverage. So which one should you choose – Third-party or Comprehensive car insurance? This guide will assist you in understanding the key differences and making an informed decision.
What is Third Party Car Insurance?
As per the Motor Vehicles Act, third party insurance is mandatory for all vehicle owners in India. This basic plan protects you from legal and financial liabilities if your car damages a third-party vehicle/property or injures someone. Here’s a quick look at what third-party car insurance covers:
- Bodily injury to a third party – Covers death, permanent disability, medical expenses, etc.
- Property damage – Covers repair or replacement costs of a third-party vehicle or property.
What is Comprehensive Car Insurance?
A comprehensive car insurance policy is a great choice to safeguard your prized vehicle. Now, legally, you only need a basic third-party cover to drive in India.
But comprehensive insurance goes beyond that in protecting your car from bumper to bumper. What essentially happens is that it bundles mandatory third-party protection along with extensive coverage for damage to your car from accidents, theft, natural disasters, etc.
So, while the premiums are a bit higher, comprehensive insurance provides peace of mind with its extensive coverage. Another pro tip in this regard is that you can upgrade to a comprehensive plan if you already have a third-party plan during the car insurance renewal process.
Third-Party vs Comprehensive Insurance: Key Differences
| Basis of Comparison | Comprehensive Car Insurance | Third-Party Car Insurance
|
| Meaning | Bundles third-party cover with Own Damage cover | Only covers third-party liability |
| Add-on Availability | Yes | No |
| Legal Compulsion | Not mandatory | Mandatory |
| Coverage Offered | Third-party liability + Own Damage cover | Only third-party liability |
| Is it Enough? | Offers complete protection | Basic coverage may not suffice |
| Premium | Higher | Lower |
| Premium Rates | Varies based on Insured Declared Value (IDV), location etc. | Fixed by IRDAI slabs |
| Discounts | Yes, multi-year policies, NCB benefits etc. | Limited compared to comprehensive |
How to Buy the Best Car Insurance Policy?
Here are some tips to secure the ideal car insurance policy for your vehicle:
- Evaluate Add-Ons – Based on your car’s age and usage needs, assess relevant add-ons like zero depreciation, engine protectors, etc. It allows customised enhancement.
- Check Claim Settlement Record – The insurer should have a quick and hassle-free claim settlement process supported by positive customer reviews.
- Understand Exclusions – Clarify applicable exclusions and waiting periods to avoid future claim disputes. Also, check if any major exclusion can be covered through add-ons.
What are the Major Exclusions in Car Insurance Policies?
While car insurance policies promise extensive coverage, there are specific conditions and instances where your claim can get rejected. Here are some major exclusions to be aware of in third-party and comprehensive car insurance:
In Third-Party Car Insurance
- Any damage to your vehicle
- Personal accident cover for passengers
In Comprehensive Car Insurance
- Consequential losses – Costs not directly related to an insured event
- Losses arising when the policy is not active
- Damage due to a manufacturer’s defect
- Loss/damage outside the specified geographical area
- Depreciation or wear/tear of car
- Mechanical or electrical breakdown
Conclusion
Evaluating third-party vs comprehensive insurance in light of your budget, car value, usage needs, claim likelihood, etc., is vital for informed decision-making. Comprehensive insurance makes absolute sense for new and frequently used cars.
However, if you own an old car with limited usage, third-party cover may suffice and help minimise premium outflow. Add-ons allow you to handpick relevant extensions at marginal costs. So, evaluate associated risks insurance needs and make the optimal choice.
ThePrint ValueAd Initiative content is a paid-for, sponsored article. Journalists of ThePrint are not involved in reporting or writing it.