BJP national general secretary P Muralidhar Rao said the party expects the Congress-JD(S) coalition to lose the trust vote in the Karnataka Assembly on Thursday.
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik accused the BJP-run Central government of conspiring to sell the Chilika lake as part of its plan to build a water aerodrome.
Farm crisis in poll-bound states of Karnataka, MP and Rajasthan, had made BJP jittery, especially after it suffered reverses in rural Gujarat in 2017 polls.
Whether it is due to the alleged unofficial ban on The Bengal Files or allegations by Gopal Mukherjee’s family against Agnihotri, everyone in the state wants to know more about Mukherjee.
As devastated farmers begin to come to terms with the fallout, 4 lakh hectares of land under paddy cultivation across state is flooded. Punjab is among the biggest contributors to PDS.
New Delhi: Army chief General Upendra Dwivedi has strongly backed the idea of theaterisation, saying it is inevitable and the need of the hour.
Speaking...
In its toughest time in decades because of floods, Punjab would’ve expected PM Modi to visit. If he has the time for a Bihar tour, why not a short visit to next-door Punjab?
There so many comments that are just idiotic. The article states that 50% people did not respond in the survey. Hence the numbers do not add up to 100%. People should do the basic job of reading the article before ranting.
It is clear that the journalist has a clear political view. I can evaluate the analysis in that light. But people are accusing the journalist of bad data analysis without giving credible alternative perspectives on the same data set.
Dear writer, Idk what’s your name and address. But i would like to point out something for you. As per your statistics data, the best solution for Kashmir is to give independence. Do you know that Most of the north Indian State River water comes through Kasmhir, idk exactly accurate data but around 6-7 states are depending on it.
Not only me, each and every one can assure you that If Kashmir gets independence it’ll merge with Pakistan. As you guys are funding on Pakistan’s money, you might have no idea what they will do. But I can confidently say that they will stop the water n there are many more factors.
Good to See Now the Anti India Narratives Stand on No Grounds.
When Topic is DATA BASED then the language ” ruled by BJP for the longest time, Hindi belt states ” .. ruled by BJP for the longest time, Hindi belt states … ” should have mentioned the Exact Hind Belt State Names and The Number of Years to project the “Longest Rule”.
The Heading Itself Collapsed on the Article and Killed it plus Spilled loads of Mud n Garbage on the Author
So far thanks to Art 370 Indian Tax payers’ money was poured in Tons down the drain w/ o any accountability to so called “win hearts o K-ppl” and that is why the development level is higher compared to other poorer states but not to the level commensurate with among of money poured into Kashmir.With Art 370 gone the development money will be spent with full accountability and will benefit common kashmiri ppl.Now K is more like elitist n feudal ruled Pakistan with large disparity compared to those in rest of India.b
In the first table, which is mentioned as shared from CSDS lokniti, the numbers do not add up. This place a an deliberate attempt to mislead people with some ulterior motive in mind. Pre drawn conclusions have been matched with twisted datasets.
There is no cherry picking here, the author says that its the BJP that removed ART370 stating development as a core reason but they have only not been able to bring about the said development in the states they governed for a long time with no pre existing laws or barriers like ART370.
after reading this article I only hope that data analysis is not your primary source of livelihood.
everything else is fine in it though.
Obfuscating data and writing with an agenda can easily be done both ways. Pray how can J&K have low employment when there is 0 investment?? Does this not sound illogical. How can they earn so much by just selling apples and carpets? On the other hand UP though produces so much the per capita income n development index will get dragged down so much due to the large denominator! Look at the area of J&K to population ratio. 1.3 crores for a third of UP’s area.
You have shown the data where maximum people support independence of Kashmir. However, the total of those percentages add up to less than 50%. What were the other 50% people in that survey thinking? Perhaps ‘Kashmir is a part of India’? Such idiotic data mining sitting in Chennai, having no touch with reality. With systematic wiping out of Hindu population in the 1990s, how can anyone sane suggest a plebiscite will reflect true sentiment of the original residents (including Kashmiri Hindus) and not just the imported Jihadis?
Another propaganda by CONgress ecosystem. First, they gave half Kashmir to Pakistan, half Ladakh to China. then implemented 370 forcefully going against Indians, then kicked out pandits and given space for jihadi terrorists, and now started crying against the brave step to rectify blunder committed by Nehru. People of Jammu and ladakh celebrating this move. As jihadis kicked out real Kashmiris from Kashmir, we need to wait how real Kashmiris take this step(Kashmiri pandits celebrating this step) for few years. After 6 decades of looting people of Jammu and Ladakh & feed those family and jihadis of kahsmir, time is correct to give justice to all. 90% Indians celebrating. stop propaganda. enough is enough.
Dear Rukmini, great attempt to throw negative light on the centre’s bold move. BJP doesn’t really need to justify and talk much, since even some senior Congress leaders have voiced support to the J&K decision. Like someone else has indicated in the comments section, thousands of data are available and most usually don’t match. Depends on what data you take and what you do with it. Lastly, for a state like J&K, using data to gauge development and progress could be the most amateurish thing to do… It’s a clear exception considering the bloodshed and disputes with our noisy neighbour. So let’s keep data away and look at reality.
I can produce another set of data. This Chennai based journalist have not idea of reality in Kashmir. The problem is not just what the Kashmiris want. Obviously they do not want any interference from central, as once privilege is given, knowngingly or unkowingly, you cannot alter early just by taking option. For certain decision, democracy doesn’t work. The problem of Kashmir is insurgency by Pakistan that need to be curbed.
I liked your first line. Why don’t you produce another set of data?
What absolute garbage in the name of data based journalism . The question to b asked is about the investment per person relative to productive output and the delta for gain in human development. This is a clear case of starting with a conclusion in mind and then finding simplistic statistics to make that argument. As for the decision to get rid of 370, it is clear that this government has chosen a policy with an end goal of integrating kashmir and then gone about finding a legislative route towards that goal. One can disagree with the route or even the goal but this article is pointless both in its target and its substance.
P.S : In retrospect i may have been a bit too harsh on Ms.Rukmini but deliberate misuse of data as conduit to precooked arguments is a pet peeve of mine, so i will leave the comment as is. Hope it is taken in the right spirit and i don’t mean any disrespect..
This was a good read with analysis of valuable data. I wish this much analysis and planning took place before taking massive national decisions. Could you also link to the source for the data? Like link to MPI and Indian official statistics. So, anyone lazy enough to doubt can be pointed to those links.
I think it is wrong to view the opinion of few people. Kashmir is part of India hence majority views of Indians matter and not just few people and disgruntled media men. Now Kashmir will progress when it has cosmopolitan structure and all Indians live in brotherhood atmosphere. Abrogation shall spontaneously wipe out terrorists when they find few supporters. More Central fund shall get utilizes for development programs rather than security issues. I strongly condemn those who oppose the abrogation of article 370 and 35A.
Abrogation would be OK if the goals stated are met. Terror and Art 370’s existence have no connection at all. It is Pakistan’s fomenting of terror that is the cause of insurgency and they will continue with it whether 370 exists or not. NDA is manufacturing causes to explain an effect. There could be other good effects from removing 370, but these are very minimal, since even earlier, almost all of the Indian Constitution applied to J&K. This was achieved by successive Govts passing a series of 46 Presidential orders watering down the original clauses of Art 370.
There so many comments that are just idiotic. The article states that 50% people did not respond in the survey. Hence the numbers do not add up to 100%. People should do the basic job of reading the article before ranting.
It is clear that the journalist has a clear political view. I can evaluate the analysis in that light. But people are accusing the journalist of bad data analysis without giving credible alternative perspectives on the same data set.
Dear writer, Idk what’s your name and address. But i would like to point out something for you. As per your statistics data, the best solution for Kashmir is to give independence. Do you know that Most of the north Indian State River water comes through Kasmhir, idk exactly accurate data but around 6-7 states are depending on it.
Not only me, each and every one can assure you that If Kashmir gets independence it’ll merge with Pakistan. As you guys are funding on Pakistan’s money, you might have no idea what they will do. But I can confidently say that they will stop the water n there are many more factors.
Good to See Now the Anti India Narratives Stand on No Grounds.
When Topic is DATA BASED then the language ” ruled by BJP for the longest time, Hindi belt states ” .. ruled by BJP for the longest time, Hindi belt states … ” should have mentioned the Exact Hind Belt State Names and The Number of Years to project the “Longest Rule”.
The Heading Itself Collapsed on the Article and Killed it plus Spilled loads of Mud n Garbage on the Author
JAIHIND.U
So far thanks to Art 370 Indian Tax payers’ money was poured in Tons down the drain w/ o any accountability to so called “win hearts o K-ppl” and that is why the development level is higher compared to other poorer states but not to the level commensurate with among of money poured into Kashmir.With Art 370 gone the development money will be spent with full accountability and will benefit common kashmiri ppl.Now K is more like elitist n feudal ruled Pakistan with large disparity compared to those in rest of India.b
In the first table, which is mentioned as shared from CSDS lokniti, the numbers do not add up. This place a an deliberate attempt to mislead people with some ulterior motive in mind. Pre drawn conclusions have been matched with twisted datasets.
i agree with you. when something doesnot add up to 100% then it is not math, its something else
Geniuses should read the article. It mentions that 50% people did not respond to the survey. Hence the numbers do not add up to 100%.
cherry picking of data. Why do you compare JK with hindhi belt states ? why not compare with southern states ? The author seems to be biased
There is no cherry picking here, the author says that its the BJP that removed ART370 stating development as a core reason but they have only not been able to bring about the said development in the states they governed for a long time with no pre existing laws or barriers like ART370.
after reading this article I only hope that data analysis is not your primary source of livelihood.
everything else is fine in it though.
Btw, you should also read this India Today report,since data is your ‘thing’. It states that J&K has one of the worst unemployment rates currently and equally bleak other development & economic parameters:
https://www.indiatoday.in/mail-today/story/j-k-among-top-5-states-with-high-monthly-average-unemployment-rate-1577640-2019-08-06
Obfuscating data and writing with an agenda can easily be done both ways. Pray how can J&K have low employment when there is 0 investment?? Does this not sound illogical. How can they earn so much by just selling apples and carpets? On the other hand UP though produces so much the per capita income n development index will get dragged down so much due to the large denominator! Look at the area of J&K to population ratio. 1.3 crores for a third of UP’s area.
You have shown the data where maximum people support independence of Kashmir. However, the total of those percentages add up to less than 50%. What were the other 50% people in that survey thinking? Perhaps ‘Kashmir is a part of India’? Such idiotic data mining sitting in Chennai, having no touch with reality. With systematic wiping out of Hindu population in the 1990s, how can anyone sane suggest a plebiscite will reflect true sentiment of the original residents (including Kashmiri Hindus) and not just the imported Jihadis?
My advice take on more data from hindi belt . saperest/ Terrorsist from Hindi belt or From J&K . I think thats why we are loosing our soldiers.
Another propaganda by CONgress ecosystem. First, they gave half Kashmir to Pakistan, half Ladakh to China. then implemented 370 forcefully going against Indians, then kicked out pandits and given space for jihadi terrorists, and now started crying against the brave step to rectify blunder committed by Nehru. People of Jammu and ladakh celebrating this move. As jihadis kicked out real Kashmiris from Kashmir, we need to wait how real Kashmiris take this step(Kashmiri pandits celebrating this step) for few years. After 6 decades of looting people of Jammu and Ladakh & feed those family and jihadis of kahsmir, time is correct to give justice to all. 90% Indians celebrating. stop propaganda. enough is enough.
Dear Rukmini, great attempt to throw negative light on the centre’s bold move. BJP doesn’t really need to justify and talk much, since even some senior Congress leaders have voiced support to the J&K decision. Like someone else has indicated in the comments section, thousands of data are available and most usually don’t match. Depends on what data you take and what you do with it. Lastly, for a state like J&K, using data to gauge development and progress could be the most amateurish thing to do… It’s a clear exception considering the bloodshed and disputes with our noisy neighbour. So let’s keep data away and look at reality.
Yes This happens when you have no IQ and you start writing reviews…Poor data analysis..Get admission in good college and try to learn.All d best.
I can produce another set of data. This Chennai based journalist have not idea of reality in Kashmir. The problem is not just what the Kashmiris want. Obviously they do not want any interference from central, as once privilege is given, knowngingly or unkowingly, you cannot alter early just by taking option. For certain decision, democracy doesn’t work. The problem of Kashmir is insurgency by Pakistan that need to be curbed.
I liked your first line. Why don’t you produce another set of data?
What absolute garbage in the name of data based journalism . The question to b asked is about the investment per person relative to productive output and the delta for gain in human development. This is a clear case of starting with a conclusion in mind and then finding simplistic statistics to make that argument. As for the decision to get rid of 370, it is clear that this government has chosen a policy with an end goal of integrating kashmir and then gone about finding a legislative route towards that goal. One can disagree with the route or even the goal but this article is pointless both in its target and its substance.
P.S : In retrospect i may have been a bit too harsh on Ms.Rukmini but deliberate misuse of data as conduit to precooked arguments is a pet peeve of mine, so i will leave the comment as is. Hope it is taken in the right spirit and i don’t mean any disrespect..
This was a good read with analysis of valuable data. I wish this much analysis and planning took place before taking massive national decisions. Could you also link to the source for the data? Like link to MPI and Indian official statistics. So, anyone lazy enough to doubt can be pointed to those links.
I think it is wrong to view the opinion of few people. Kashmir is part of India hence majority views of Indians matter and not just few people and disgruntled media men. Now Kashmir will progress when it has cosmopolitan structure and all Indians live in brotherhood atmosphere. Abrogation shall spontaneously wipe out terrorists when they find few supporters. More Central fund shall get utilizes for development programs rather than security issues. I strongly condemn those who oppose the abrogation of article 370 and 35A.
Abrogation would be OK if the goals stated are met. Terror and Art 370’s existence have no connection at all. It is Pakistan’s fomenting of terror that is the cause of insurgency and they will continue with it whether 370 exists or not. NDA is manufacturing causes to explain an effect. There could be other good effects from removing 370, but these are very minimal, since even earlier, almost all of the Indian Constitution applied to J&K. This was achieved by successive Govts passing a series of 46 Presidential orders watering down the original clauses of Art 370.