What if Barkha Dutt had joked about Konark Temple’s erotica instead of Abhijit Iyer Mitra?

Updated: 16 November, 2018 6:56 pm IST
Text Size:
  • 632
    Shares

The absurd arrest of Abhijeet Iyer Mitra for joking about Odisha’s Konark Temple has exposed the weakness of India’s Free Speech Laws. But in this episode of #NewsKaJuice, Barkha Dutt—while calling for the immediate release of Iyer—argues that it also exposes his hypocrisy and that of his right-wing supporters.

Read the full script here:

Many of you may know the name: Abhijit Iyer-Mitra

A defence analyst and a writer, he has now been in jail for several weeks.

The charge against him is absolutely ridiculous.

In September, he posted a video of himself outside Odisha’s famed Konark Sun Temple.

In an obviously tongue-in-cheek take on the erotic sculptures at the temple, he punned that it should be called a Humple…

Later, he had a similarly satirical comment about the state’s Jagannath Temple.

An unsparing Naveen Patnaik government went after him for sullying regional pride.

A House panel of politicians from across the parties demanded — and got an apology — from a man who is otherwise an online motor-mouth…

And the Supreme Court denied him bail because he had inflamed religious sentiments.

Abhijeet must be freed. His incarceration is a farce.

But if the episode exposes how abused free speech is in India, it also tells you much more about… Abhijit Iyer-Mitra’s own hypocrisy

And the humbug and double standards of his friends in the right wing eco-system…

————————————————

Human Rights groups have been a constant punching bag for Abhijit.

In July this year, he referred to them as Baboons who may multiply.

In September, he attacked Meenakshi Ganguly, the South Asia head of Human Rights Watch… For her critique of an operation in Kashmir…

He called her a highly-paid bimbo…

And in 2015, he sneered at Amnesty and accused it of being after money and publicity!

Well, guess what my friend.

While so many of your right-wing supporters fell absolutely silent…

Who do you think spoke up for you?

The same activists and journalists you spent your life slandering and vilifying.

This week Amnesty described your arrest as unjustified and called for respecting your freedom.

The same Amnesty you showed zero respect for… or even minimum politeness…

————————————————

Abhijit Iyer-Mitra should NOT be in jail

But as odious as his arrest is, he is certainly not a victim.

After all, what has happened to him?

Isn’t this what he always demanded should happen to everyone else…

————————————————

Today his friends say Abhijit is the victim of a blinkered mob mentality on religion…

But when Gauri Lankesh was assassinated, Abhijit Iyer-Mitra helpfully explained that “lynch mobs are spurred on by the same fake news that criminal Gauri spread.”

————————————————

In September, when 28-year-old Sophia Lois was arrested for shouting anti-Modi slogans on board a plane, Abhijit said it violated DGCA rules.

In fact, he wanted the young woman to be in jail for up to a year…

Because “at the very least it would have corrected the deficient upbringing her family gave her on how to behave in public.”

So what about when your behaviour offends people then Abhijeet?

————————————————

You have called for throwing Lefty scum in jail… or using a machine gun on them.

Ok, hyperbole yes… But no satire or humour here…

————————————————

You have called for clowns of the human rights watch to be imprisoned as well…

And in 2017, when the Karnataka assembly called two editors to be put in prison for what they claimed was defamation you said…

“I totally support throwing editors in jail! It’s a healthy habit — must be encouraged — especially the ones who instigate stone pelters.”

Karma comes back to haunt all of us, doesn’t it?

Like they say, be careful about what you wish for, because you might just get it.

————————————————

Abhijieet Iyer-Mitra

That you are behind bars and that bail has been denied to you is atrocious.

But what if instead of you, it was me in front of the Konark temple?

Making a joke about temple erotica.

Would the Hindu right-wing have spared me?

Or would they have called me a Muslim lover… A burkha instead of Barkha.

Or worse, a whore… Who is sullying Hindu tradition…

After all, this is language you have used routinely for women.

Phrases such as vacuous vamp appear on your timeline.

And when The Telegraph did a story on you that you didn’t like, you called them Presstitutes spreading their legs for Naveen’s money.

————————————————

Your other great hero appears to be Vivek Agnihotri; the filmmaker who gave us this curious phrase Urban Naxals.

Basically gobbledygook for those all of you disagree with.

The man who calls all of us anti-national…

Well we don’t see Vivek Agnihotri quite leading the crusade for your release. Do we?

Instead it’s the liberals you and your friends call scum… Like historian Ram Guha who has spoken up for you…

On your Twitter Page, you snarkily insinuated his loyalties lay with Pakistan.

On his Twitter page, he reweeted Amnesty’s call for your release…

So when you do get bail… And I hope it’s very soon

Will you finally admit

That in the end, it was Indian Liberals… the ones you like to mock and humiliate

Who spoke up for you…

You Abhijit Mitra should never have been arrested

Yet, this is victimhood. It’s actually Irony.

See you next week


Also read: Are Hindus really the victims in India? Of what, asks Barkha Dutt


Separate fact from fiction, the real from the fake going viral on social media, on HoaXposed .


  • 632
    Shares
10 Comments Share Your Views

10 COMMENTS

  1. One hopes, like a particularly virulent strain of flu, this discourse of the trolls will soon be history. It is coarsening the national discourse, tragically the hurtful words sometimes translating into physical violence. Except within the circle of the believers, it is not winning any new converts.

  2. If barkha dutt had joked about Konark Temple’s erotica then the police would have arrested her. Liberals would have unleashed hell. Court would have given the case a midnight hearing. Left parties would have made some deals. Media would have cried democracy in danger, emergency etc. Barkha dutt would have been let off.

  3. Well, this seems to be the problem with most journalists and commentators. They think that going against the grain would highlight their comments and bring them to notice. But on the contrary,the risk it entails is also exemplary. As human beings we must stand up to the values we have learned to uphold from our childhood and to do that even if that panders to mass sentiments, we must approve of it. Afterall, we as human beings must take a stand and show that values are universal and they don’t change under different circumstances.

  4. Barkha, Why so much spatting about?? If Iyer Mitra is right reactionary, he would himself vanis one day as great French film Maestro Jean Renoir predicted. PRADIP BISWAS film critic, The Indian Express.

  5. Barkha, Why so much spatting about?? If Iyer Mitra is right reactionary, he would himself vanish one day as great French film Maestro Jean Renoir predicted. PRADIP BISWAS film critic, The Indian Express.

    Reply

  6. Barkha is using the occasion to score points. Will the Amnesty be the Amnesty it is by choosing silence. Ram Guha is no leftist but centrist overlooked for Director, Nehru Memorial for his views on Congress and Dynasty. Abhijit Mitra’s arrest rather underlines the silence of our ‘Liberals’. Barkha’s outpouring here shows she is not above pillorying an incarcerated man for his views. She didn’t had similar analysis for Gauri Lankesh’s, convicted for defamation.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here