Monday, 27 June, 2022
HomeOpinionMoving towards darkest hour of coronavirus, India can take strength from WW2's...

Moving towards darkest hour of coronavirus, India can take strength from WW2’s Dunkirk moment

There are occasions when a govt's resources are not enough. With coronavirus, India is in the midst of a World War and this crisis needs our entire national capacity.

Text Size:

The coronavirus pandemic has thrust us in a crisis of global proportions, the like of which was never seen since the Second World War (WWII), as mentioned by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in his address to the nation Thursday. Like the terrible war, nations are staggering under an attack that is devastating countries and killing thousands. While the number of casualties is incomparable to WWII, the widespread fear and chaos is similar.

On that occasion too, a war begun in foreign lands seized India in its wake. The hubris of several European countries that they would be spared the Nazi onslaught, is uncannily similar to those who believed that the pandemic had been ‘contained’ in India or that we are somehow immune to the virus. Even as country after country was ravaged by Hitler’s war machine, others, including France, believed that their much-vaunted armies would stop the German advance. They couldn’t.

It is a matter of days before the pandemic enters the third stage in India spreading its deathly wave exponentially. Projected mortality rates expressed in fractions; understate the millions those percentages will be. Comparisons with flu or road accident casualties are misleading because those don’t wipe out an entire generation of old people or destroy national economies. India will be especially ravaged by the inequitable distribution of misery. The poor as always will bear brunt of the decimation. At a time when India is teetering towards the precipice, perhaps, we could gather strength from the darkest hour of the Second World War.

While WWII had several pivotal and poignant moments, none comes as close to the darkest hour for the Allies — as the complete rout of British troops at Dunkirk, when indeed it seemed that all was lost.

Also read: Wartime mood grips world leaders, and debt fears melt away

When Germany attacked Poland in September 1939, a British Expeditionary Force (BEF), was sent to help defend France. After a brief interlude of seven months, Germany began its blitzkrieg and invaded Belgium, Netherlands and France on the 10th of May. The defences based on the Maginot line proved useless and the German war machine tore through the French and Belgian armies breaking west towards the English Channel. The entire British Expeditionary Force was trapped along the northern coast of France. Fearing total annihilation, the BEF commander General Vort, decided to evacuate from the port of Dunkirk — which was the closest port that could enable evacuation of the 350,000 British soldiers caught within a tightening noose.

While the remnants of the French army tried to delay the onslaught of the advancing enemy, they were no match for the seven German divisions, of which three were formidable panzers, that crashed through them. The enclave of Dunkirk was shrinking by the hour while German Luftwaffe pummelled the helpless troops. These 350,000 troops were — as Churchill put it — the whole root, core and brain of the British army. Their capture which seemed a certainty, would leave Britain defenceless against the German invasion which would follow the conquest of France. Britan stood alone against Hitler. The US had not yet joined the war because of the neutrality pact they had signed.

The British war cabinet itself was split, with the former prime minister Chamberlain’s insisting on suing for peace to save what was literally the entire British army in the European theatre, while Churchill was firm on fighting to the very end. The troops stranded in Dunkirk were essential if Britain needed to continue the fight but their evacuation was impossible with the depleted British and French navy. There simply weren’t enough vessels and those that were, could not be berthed near the shallow beaches where the wounded and weary soldiers were being strafed and bombarded by the Luftwaffe unchallenged.

The British Armed Forces realised that they needed far more than their own resources to achieve this miracle and appealed to every boat owner of Britain to come to their nation’s aid. Hundreds of private vessels ranging from yachts to rickety fishing boats responded to this national call, manned by reserves and volunteers, and sailed from Britain to Dunkirk knowing fully well that they were likely to be blown to pieces by the Stuka bombers pounding the beach.

Between 26 May to 4 June 1940, about 850 private boats rescued more than 336,000 British, French and other Allied soldiers who would have most certainly been killed or captured. This operation, code-named Dynamo, went down in history as the most pivotal turnaround of the Second World War. Without those rescued troops, the last bastion of the Allies would have fallen, and the Axis would have seized Europe.

Five years later, using those very troops as the core of a much stronger and formidable army, the Allied went on to win the Second World War.

Also read: Anti-globalisation lobby sees world as ‘us vs them’. Coronavirus doesn’t make distinction

There are rare occasions in the history of a nation, when its government’s resources are simply not enough. We are in the midst of a World War and this crisis needs our entire national capacity. This is not the time to bicker about differences — of which we have aplenty. There will be time enough for that. Right now, we need all “hands on deck” disciplined approach and realisation that viruses don’t differentiate between any economic class, caste or religion. We need to remember that the world is one family and every citizen needs to take care of those less privileged than them if we have to survive as a nation.

The story of Dunkirk has a postscript from which we may get a sense of fortitude and destiny.

After the troops were rescued against all odds — on 4 June 1940 — Winston Churchill gave the most famous speech of the Second World War, which is commonly known by a line within it: “We shall fight on the beaches…” This speech extolled the fighting spirit and determination of a nation, during its darkest hour.

In the last paragraph of his peroration, Churchill goes on to say that “…if the island of Britan were to be subjugated… then the Empire beyond the seas would carry on the struggle until in God’s good time, the New World, with all its power and might, steps forth to the rescue and the liberation of the old”.

The ‘old world’ is reeling. It is for us to step forth and battle this common enemy.

The author is former CEO NATGRID and president, Risk & Security Reliance Industries. Views are personal.

This article was first published on Medium.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. This is not a war. Do you declare a war against excess rain, drought (well, many people wrongly do) ? No. Simply because you cannot stop it from happening – we cannot stop/eradicate coronavirus out of existence, we cannot make it go away or surrender. We can only shield ourselves from it and stay unharmed. In other words, we don’t defeat it – we make it irrelevant.
    Also, there is a difference in a leader pulling together all the nation’s resources versus people rushing for rescue out of their own anxiety – Churchill was humble enough to let go of his ego, relay the reality to the people. Our Supreme leader did not do that.

    War (and the metaphors) might be the gush of fresh air for the army aficionados and for haughty leaders to justify hardship & leader worship, but it is tedious for the rest of us.

    P.S. I don’t think Churchill was ever complacent either, rather he was the paranoid one.

    P.P.S. Here as well the US is mired in its self-interest, staying out of all the action.

  2. Have come across a few times the writings and videos of this author. The basis of every piece turns out to be needless military hyperbole and trash-emotional calls focused on the so called greatness of the military and its people.

    Grow-up Mr Author!

  3. The writer want to highlight the coopration by public can bring the positive change in the end result

  4. Dunkirk saw evacuation of British forces. It was not a victory.
    When victory happened 5 years later, it was as a result of British, French, Canadian, American, Russian, Polish, Indian etc. etc. troops fighting in multiple theaters across the globe.

    It’s fine to choose analogies to make a point but with more robust examples please. The 2008 sub prime crisis triggered in the US but having cascading impact on global economy requiring individual nations to act in concert comes to mind. This requires more of technocratic expertise and less of whipping up of nationalistic fervor.

  5. I think, the author’s likening the Covid crisis to Britain’s Dunkirk moment, where by national resolve and unity, the BEF was rescued, is only to point out that we too may be able to fight the crisis by national resolve and unity.
    My only two bit on this, is that, the present Govt has to do much more than the firefighting that they are doing at present. They have to take Parliament and the people with them like Churchill did

  6. What a shambles of a piece where a veteran tries to force fit a localized WW2 action into a modern global crisis. Needless hyperbole about how Britain would have been lost if it only lost a part of its army when its powerful Navy and Air Force were intact. Has the writer heard of the Battle of Britain?

    Who’s playing the role of the Germans here? The Corona virus?
    So the British Expeditionary Forces are who exactly? The Indian population? The World population? Where are they being evacuated to?
    Who is Churchill here? Modi? Or Trump? or Trudeau? All of them together?
    Which “people’s navy”” does the writer want to mobilize like at Dunkirk – when in fact people are being asked to demobilize?
    How does he know Govts resources are not enough? Is he asking for donations – money or blood, or other kinds?

    There are some excellent WW2 movies that the writer could have been watching or suggested that the rest of us watch rather than pen this meaningless piece.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular