New Delhi: The family of the victim in the Muzaffarnagar gangrape case has now accused the Uttar Pradesh police of physical torture and abuse, three months after the 21-year-old allegedly committed suicide.
The case surfaced in October last year, when the woman killed herself and named four of her relatives for traumatising her sexually and mentally. No arrests have been made so far. This came four years after she was raped by three boys of her Badhiwala village in August 2015 — all out on bail.
Now, the victim’s family has accused the UP police of beating them up inside the Chhapar police station, located 10 km from the village, Thursday.
“In the police station they abused us like anything. They have been bribed by the accused family (his relatives). So while abusing us they said we allow our girls to get raped in lieu of money. They also used several cuss words that I can’t even mention to you,” the victim’s father told ThePrint.
The family showed pictures of the victim’s sister with swollen cheeks.
The father said the police had called on his family on 28 December to visit the police station to make a statement.
“My son was severely ill after he met an accident. I informed them by phone that we were in hospital and would come to the police station after reaching home. I reached home on 8 January and called them the next morning to enquire about the timings. After about an hour and a half, another call came from the police station and I was asked to bring my wife and daughter too,” he explained.
“On the same day, between 1.30 pm and 3.30 pm, we were severely thrashed inside the police station. My daughter was beaten by the CO (circle officer) and another female constable. We were abused too,” said the father.
He added that in between all this, the station house officer (SHO) left the police station due to some accident. “But we were forced to sit (and wait) in separate rooms for about five hours.”
However, Pawan Kumar Sharma, SHO, Chhapar police station, denied these allegations.
“Yesterday, they had come on their own. No such alleged beating of the family by us ever took place. In fact, it was (the victim’s father) who threatened us and showed tantrums,” Sharma told ThePrint Friday.
“This family had written a similar complaint letter against the previous SHO too with a ploy to extort money from him. Now they are playing the same trick with me. On that day I had gone out to investigate an accident case,” he added.
The latest allegation is the second such by the family. Earlier in October, the father had told ThePrint that his family was tortured by then SHO H.N. Singh around Diwali. Singh had also denied the charges by raising doubts over the family’s motives.
Also read: Unnao rape survivor’s case shows rural India needs a MeToo
The case
On 5 October last year, the 21-year-old woman allegedly committed suicide in Badhiwala village of Uttar Pradesh’s Muzaffarnagar, but not before disclosing the names of four of her relatives — her maternal uncle, maternal aunt, father’s uncle and the uncle’s daughter-in-law.
Her ordeal came four years after she was raped by three boys from the same village. A case was registered against the three under the stringent Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, but the accused are out on bail.
Speaking to ThePrint, the victim’s father said he could not properly fight the 2015 case due to lack of resources. On several occasions he failed to appear in court and as a result, the victim’s case was weakened.
Months after the gangrape, the victim’s maternal uncle also allegedly raped her, taking advantage of her distressed state.
After she reportedly killed herself, the Chhapar police registered a case against the four relatives under Section 306 (abetment to suicide) of the Indian Penal Code.
‘Injustice to dead daughter’
SHO Pawan Kumar Sharma said none of the accused in the second case has been arrested yet.
“Earlier the case was with SSI (special sub-inspector) Suresh Pal Singh. I was recently transferred here and then the case was given to me. I have started investigating the case from the very beginning.
“I have sent the victim’s suicide note to be matched with her original handwriting to Agra,” he said.
Sharma said he found the case suspicious as he could not believe the version presented by the victim’s family — that her maternal aunt was in getting her raped by her maternal uncle. According to Sharma, the victim’s father tried to extort money from the accused and settle the matter.
However, the victim’s father has a different story to tell. He said the whole village was against his family.
“The accused families tried to put pressure on us to sign an agreement and withdraw the case… It would an injustice to my dead daughter. That is why I have written to DIG (deputy inspector general) Saharanpur that I will commit suicide if my daughter doesn’t get justice,” he said.
However, Muzaffarnagar police insisted that the father is trying to blackmail the force, and his past record is doubtful.
Also read: Gangrape, sexual abuse by uncle, taunts — what UP girl went through before killing herself
The U.P. police is demonstrating everything similar to that of Nazi’s who fearlessly acted in the most horrific way. The law itself has become lawless and currently a women fears for her safety in U.P. The Girls father may have faced the hardship even after loosing his daughter raped and abused, this contradicts the Govt.’s policy of zero tolerance for manhandling a girl/women anywhere in India. Even during the NRC agitation and till date Muslim Arabic Madrassas are being target, Students beaten brutally and huge ruckus is being created so that this community resides in fear. Is this the democratic value and principle of our country where all are taken as equals. The open mouths of the Sevak of the rightist war declaring to burn the houses and kill the muslim if they rebel against the ruling elite. What can be said about the courts who are waiting for the culprits to evade all acts of violence as none could gather courage to file a complaint. The State of U.P. has seen the highest ratio of crimes against womens and the YOGI Govt. is little to prosecute their own cadre to serve justice. If this becomes a trend then raping a women will become a passion of the criminals as a red carpet is shown by the authorities to commit such heinous crimes and evade the justice.
So, hooliganism and burning of public property should not be stopped. UP police is doing its job, the problem criminal patronage given for last 2 decades in the rule of casteist parties like SP and BSP which will take it’s time to subside.
Difficult to conceive of any part of the country which is further from Ram Rajya. One temple more will not change that.