New Delhi: Devilal Gond was arrested for murder in 2012 under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code but was acquitted in 2018; however, he remained in prison for over seven years after that due to a miscommunication between the prison and the courts.
The Supreme Court awarded Gond compensation of Rs 30 lakh, holding that compensation for wrongful incarceration must provide meaningful constitutional redress rather than merely a symbolic payment.
A Bench of Justices Augustine George Masih and Sanjeev Sachdeva on Monday enhanced the Rs 2 lakh compensation awarded earlier by the Chhattisgarh High Court.
The Bench said compensation must enable one to rebuild his life, calling it “not an act of charity or benevolence…but the bare minimum required to meaningfully redress the wrong inflicted upon him.”
The ruling goes beyond the quantum of compensation, reaffirming the principles of public-law compensation, strict State liability for violations of fundamental rights and the power of constitutional courts to provide effective remedies for unlawful deprivation of liberty.
Acquitted in 2018, released in 2025
After Gond’s arrest in 2012, a Sessions Court convicted him in 2013 and sentenced him to life imprisonment. In 2018, the Chhattisgarh High Court set aside his conviction and acquitted him. The State did not challenge the acquittal, which consequently attained finality.
Yet Gond remained in prison until May 2025. The High Court had apparently proceeded on the mistaken impression that he was already on bail and therefore directed that his surety and personal bonds remain operative for six months. The acquittal was never implemented, resulting in his incarceration for another seven years and three months.
The error surfaced only during a prison-record verification exercise in May 2025. The State explained that the Jail Superintendent had twice written to the concerned legal-aid panel lawyer in 2018 seeking the status of Gond’s appeal, but the outcome never reached the jail because of a breakdown in communication and coordination.
A subsequent inquiry found the lapse bona fide rather than with an oblique motive.
Gond approached the Chhattisgarh High Court seeking Rs 50 lakh compensation. The High Court declared his detention “wholly illegal, arbitrary, and violative” of Article 21 and found a “grave and inexcusable failure of the State machinery”. It stressed that “Administrative inefficiency or systemic lapses can never be pleaded as a defence in cases involving infringement of fundamental rights.” Nevertheless, it awarded Rs 2 lakh in 2026, prompting Gond’s appeal to the Supreme Court.
Why Rs 2 lakh was not enough
The Supreme Court then turned to the consequences of Gond’s incarceration. He was about 28 when acquitted and approximately 35 when released, losing what the Court called the “hey days of his youth”. The injury extended beyond loss of liberty to the physical and mental harshness of incarceration, loss of consortium and livelihood, and lost opportunities for education, skill development and future earnings.
The Court held that compensation “ought not to be confined to providing merely symbolic or nominal monetary relief”.
It must provide a meaningful remedial measure capable of helping the victim rebuild his life and regain financial independence.
Rehabilitation thus became an element of constitutional redress. Ensuring that Gond could regain self-sufficiency, the Court said, “It is not an act of charity or benevolence on the part of the State; it is the bare minimum required to meaningfully redress the wrong inflicted upon him.” It therefore enhanced compensation to Rs 30 lakh covering both pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses.
Also Read: As SC looks at worth of life that could’ve been, how other countries deal with wrongful convictions
Illegal detention and public law compensation
For the Supreme Court, the starting point was Article 21: no person may be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. Once Gond’s acquittal became final, there was no legal authority for his continued incarceration.
Drawing principally from Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa (1993), the Court explained that compensation under Articles 32 and 226 for an established violation of fundamental rights is “a remedy available in public law, based on strict liability for contravention of fundamental rights”. “Sovereign immunity cannot be pleaded against such constitutional liability”, it added.
The doctrine has its roots in the case of Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar (1983) involving continued imprisonment despite acquittal. The Supreme Court there said that restricting its power merely to releasing a person from illegal detention would do “mere lip-service” to the fundamental right to liberty and would denude Article 21 of its substantive content. It concluded, “Therefore, the State must repair the damage done by its officers to the petitioner’s rights.”
The present judgment also drew on D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997), where it consolidated the principle that monetary compensation may be an appropriate, effective and, in some circumstances, the only adequate remedy for an established infringement of Article 21.
While the State must compensate the victim, it can proceed against the official responsible for the violation.
The Court further emphasised that constitutional courts are “not helpless” in the face of violations of life and personal liberty and must be prepared “to forge new tools and devise new remedies” to vindicate fundamental rights. Article 32 imposes a constitutional obligation on the Supreme Court to provide effective relief, while Article 142 enables complete justice in an appropriate case.
Otherwise, the Court said, constitutional guarantees risk becoming a “mirage”.
The legislative gap
The judgment also exposes a continuing statutory gap. The Supreme Court expressly noted that “there is at present no legislative mechanism in place to determine the compensation to be awarded to such victims.”
The problem was highlighted by the Delhi High Court in the case of Babloo Chauhan vs State (NCT of Delhi)(2017), which called for “a legal (preferably legislative) framework” for the relief and rehabilitation of persons wrongfully prosecuted and incarcerated. The resulting Law Commission Report No. 277 recommended both pecuniary compensation and rehabilitative assistance, including counselling, mental-health support and vocational or employment services.
From compensation to prevention
The Supreme Court also referred to Sohan Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2025), where Rs 25 lakh was awarded for over four years of unlawful detention, following which the Madhya Pradesh High Court introduced safeguards for timely communication of court orders and prison-level compliance. It also established an Online Criminal Justice Ecosystem linking courts, prisons and other criminal-justice institutions, and the Supreme Court has asked all High Courts to consider similar measures.
The judgment therefore addresses both redress and prevention. Continued imprisonment after the authority of law has ended is not merely an administrative lapse but an infringement of personal liberty under Article 21. And where the years already lost cannot be returned, constitutional compensation ensures that recognition of the wrong is accompanied by a meaningful remedy.
(Edited by Anupama Yadav)
Also Read: Jailed for years: Why India needs a right to compensation for wrongful arrests & detention
