New Delhi: In a video circulated heavily on social media this week, first-year MBBS students can be purportedly seen in white aprons, walking slowly in a single file past a row of parked two-wheelers at King George’s Medical University (KGMU) in Lucknow, with their heads bowed and hands clasped behind their backs. As senior students pass, they are heard raising their voices in unison to greet them with “Pranam mahoday ji (Greetings, sir)”, or “Pranam madam ji (Greetings, madam)”.
The clip quickly triggered allegations of ragging on the campus, but the institution defended the practice as a traditional gesture of respect.
Now, the incident has drawn the attention of the National Medical Commission (NMC), following a complaint by United Doctors Front (UDF), a registered organisation representing medical students and resident doctors, which approached the commission’s Anti-Ragging Cell seeking an independent inquiry.
NMC has questioned both the alleged conduct on campus, and the university spokesperson’s public dismissal of ragging allegations. On Wednesday, taking serious cognisance, it sought a detailed, point-by-point response and a preliminary action taken report (ATR) from KGMU’s Vice-Chancellor and Dean within 24 hours.
“Initiate an independent, impartial and time-bound inquiry into the incident and preserve all relevant CCTV footage, video recordings and other evidence,” the NMC’s Anti-Ragging Cell told the university.
UDF’s complaint comes amid a series of ragging allegations at medical colleges across the country. Between 16 October and 11 November, the regulator issued 18 notices or communications to 15 medical colleges. The complaints during this period were largely linked to colleges in Rajasthan, with one from Karnataka. The allegations involved physical and verbal abuse, sexual humiliation, coercive activities, restrictions on juniors’ movement, and threats of academic retaliation.
The complaints from Rajasthan included allegations of particularly disturbing forms of ragging. For instance, at Government Medical College in Banswara, first-year students were allegedly forced to perform degrading postures, imitate sexual acts, dance to item songs, and change clothes in front of seniors. At Government Medical College, Barmer, disciplinary action was initiated against around 80 students over alleged harassment of juniors, while 19 students were suspended at Dr S.N. Medical College in Jodhpur following a ragging inquiry.
Also on Wednesday, the NMC sought an explanation from the principal of Government Medical College, Kota over repeated allegations of harassment of its first-year MBBS students. This would be the third ragging-related matter that the NMC has addressed just this month.
Referring to complaints from the Kota college, dated 10 October, 29 October and 17 November, the regulator said the alleged practices had continued despite earlier intervention, and sought a response within 24 hours.
Students there have alleged they are forced to walk with bowed heads and hands behind their backs, address seniors as “respected boss”, and seek permission even to disclose their names. The complaints also cite a “compulsory” dress code, verbal abuse and harassment of students living in private accommodation outside the campus.
The NMC has ordered an independent inquiry, preservation of CCTV footage and WhatsApp messages, and surprise inspections.
Also Read: NMC refuses to disclose information on action against private colleges over unpaid PG stipends
Questions over university’s defence
After the students’ video went viral, KGMU spokesperson Dr K.K. Singh rejected the ragging claims, describing the supposed greetings as a “traditional gesture of respect”, rather than harassment. He said that no formal complaint had been received, adding that the university would investigate if one was submitted.
UDF, however, argued that the absence of a formal complaint did not establish that the conduct was voluntary or acceptable.
“We respectfully submit that this response does not meet the requirements of the Regulations. A greeting given out of respect does not require freshers to stand in rows with heads bowed and call out in unison each time a senior passes,” the organisation wrote in its letter to NMC Tuesday.
Regulation 3 of the National Medical Commission (Prevention and Prohibition of Ragging in Medical Colleges and Institutions) Regulations, 2021, defines ragging to include asking a student to perform an act they would not ordinarily do, where it causes shame, torment or embarrassment and adversely affects their physical or psychological well-being.
Regulation 4(c) specifically covers asking a student to perform such acts, while Regulation 4(k) includes conduct that affects a fresher’s mental health and self-confidence, whether or not there is an intention to derive sadistic pleasure or demonstrate power or superiority.
“Whether this conduct falls within these provisions should be decided by an inquiry, not settled by a press statement,” UDF told NMC.
Dr Lakshya Mittal, UDF’s chairperson, told ThePrint, “Freshers who fear consequences are less likely to complain. When the institution publicly calls the conduct respectful before any inquiry, it makes it even harder for them to come forward. Besides, KGMU has treated similar conduct as ragging before.”
Mittal was referring to a previous controversy at KGMU. In 2018, the university had fined an entire batch of around 350 second-year students after a video showed freshers bowing to greet seniors with a ‘salaam’. In a separate ragging complaint that same month, six students had been suspended for forcing juniors to cut their hair short and bow their heads. Four were later suspended for three months after an internal inquiry substantiated the charges.
The NMC has raised concerns over the university spokesperson’s reported public statement that the incident was an ordinary greeting of respect. It has asked the university to explain the regulatory basis on which it concluded that the conduct did not amount to ragging without a proper inquiry.
It emphasised that seniority does not give students the authority to humiliate, intimidate or compel juniors to perform acts against their wishes. “Any such conduct cannot be justified in the name of tradition, customary respect or campus culture,” it further said.
NMC seeks details of who instructed students
In its communication to KGMU, the NMC also said that the reported conduct, if established, would require examination under Regulations 3 and 4(c) of the 2021 anti-ragging regulations.
It has asked the university to establish if the students seen in the video were from KGMU, and if the incident recorded in the video took place near the Kalam Centre on campus on 16 November at around 1.30 pm.
NMC has also sought details of who instructed the students to stand in a line, maintain the prescribed posture and greet passing seniors, and whether the practice was voluntary or compulsory.
The university has further been asked if similar practices were routinely followed on campus or in hostels, whether the authorities were aware of them, and whether the incident was examined under anti-ragging regulations.
Additionally, NMC has directed KGMU to preserve all relevant CCTV footage, video recordings and other evidence, and conduct an independent, impartial and time-bound inquiry.
(Edited by Mannat Chugh)
