Saturday, June 3, 2023
Support Our Journalism
HomeIndia5 reasons why Modi govt is finding it difficult to tackle protesting...

5 reasons why Modi govt is finding it difficult to tackle protesting farmers

Five rounds of talks between the govt and the farmers have already taken place, but no resolution is in sight yet.

Text Size:

Chandigarh: Even after five rounds of talks between the agitating farmers and the Modi government, no solution to the continuing siege of Delhi seems to have emerged. What is making it particularly difficult for the government to deal with the farmer leaders is their determination, refusal to compromise coupled with some novel features in their conduct and leadership.

Modified trolleys — Prepared for the long haul 

The farmers are prepared to stay put at Delhi’s borders for several months. Travelling in tractor trolleys that double up as night shelters is not a new concept in Punjab.

During the annual three-day Shaheedi Jor Mela held in the last week of December at Fatehgarh Sahib, visited by lakhs, these specially-modified trolleys are a common sight.

Villagers from across Punjab arrive ahead of the mela in such trolleys carrying ration, utensils, cooking fuel, wood, gas cylinders and even bikes (to do the local running around) to organise langars for the visitors. They park the trolleys on roadsides and make it their home for over a week.

The inside of a trolley is divided using wooden planks into an upper area used to store belongings and the lower sitting and sleeping area is cushioned. Since the mela takes place during extreme winter, these trolleys are completely sealed with plastic sheets.

“It is no wonder that the farmers simply went to Delhi and started cooking their food and living out of these trolleys as if this is something which they have done all their lives. But it’s not as easy as it looks,” said Gurdarshan Singh, a farmer from Chunni Kalan.

Also read: Bharat Bandh-like protest could see repeat of 2017 Mandsaur when 6 farmers died — RSS affiliate

Stage control — Keeping it apolitical

While the trolleys are lined up for several kilometres on the road leading to the Singhu border, the epicentre of the protest is the spot where a makeshift stage has been built. It has a loudspeaker system that addresses the farmers all day long.

All important announcements about the outcome of meetings with the government and future course of action are made. Apart from farmer leaders, activists, singers, actors and sportspersons have spoken on the stage in the past few days. To keep the focus on the agitation, the unions deputed 30 volunteers to keep a strict control on who gets onto the stage to speak.

“No politician is allowed to speak. And no Khalistan ideologue will speak from the stage. Anyone who jeopardises or has the potential to sidetrack the movement is not welcome,” said Gurmeet Singh, vice-president, BKU (Dakaunda).

At least 400 volunteers have also been put in place to guard the periphery of the protest site to spot suspicious persons and trouble-makers.

Also read: How protesting farmers have kept politicians out of their agitation for over 2 months

Rotating pradhans — No single power centre 

Although the farmer bodies in Punjab are highly factionalised they have shown remarkable unity for this protest. The agitation began with 10 farmer unions in June but by September, 31 organisations had joined. Ever since, this conglomerate has followed a democratic way of conducting meetings and taking decisions. Every meeting is presided over by the head of one of these 31 unions in rotation.

“The pradhan of the day chairs the meeting and later addresses the press about the decisions. No union leader should feel that because he is heading a smaller union he does not have the same say as the head of a larger union,” said Gurmeet Singh.

This also ensures that no one leader is imbued with the power to take a decision for the rest of the unions. “Which also makes it difficult for anyone to break the unity because in this kind of leadership everybody matters,” Gurmeet Singh added.

No Daana Pani — Show of moral resolve 

Terming it as a “satyagraha”, farmer leaders have refused to accept any hospitality from the government during the meetings with the ministers. They have, instead, called for their own food cooked as part of the langar from the protest spot and eaten it sitting on the floor of Vigyan Bhawan.

“This shows to both the government and the thousands of supporters who have followed us here that our resolve is unwavering. The first day when we accepted the hospitality, the ministers went to town saying that we had tea and the talks were cordial,” Gurmeet Singh said.

“That is when we decided that we will not allow the government to send out a message that we are non-serious or are here to have their tea and coffee. This is a matter of our livelihood, our survival and our conduct should reflect that.”

Yes or No — Building decisive pressure 

The farmer leaders virtually brought the talks to a halt during the fifth round of meeting Saturday after they all decided to go quiet, undertake a maun vrat and put up placards before the ministers, demanding a yes or a no to repealing the three farm Acts.

“This demand is completely non-negotiable. The government is ready to amend them but that is not acceptable to us,” farmer leader Joginder Singh Ugrahan who heads the BKU (Ugrahan) told the media outside the Vigyan Bhawan Saturday.

“And since the conversation was getting repetitive and nothing new seemed to be coming out of it, we decided to ask them for a one word answer — yes or no?” he added.

Also read: Punjab’s frustration & anger is rooted in its steep decline, now visible in farmers’ protests

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. This is protest limited to rich farmers of Punjab and in a few other districts of some states. The vast majority of farmers in rest of the country, including poor farmers of Punjab have nothing to do with this agitation. The government needs to communicate this fact and the benefits of the new laws clearly to the citizens of this country. Why should everyone else subsidise the entitled few?

    • That is the narrative BJP Hindus want to peddle. But you live outside reality. The agitation is growing just like CAA-NRC, which ended only because of Covid. But this one is growing, Covid or no Covid. With CAA-NRC also, your type of Hindu thought only Muslims are affected, it is alright for you, why are they disturbing. When your existence is at threat, people will agitate. Likewise, farmer’s know the plan is to take their lands and give it to Adani. Their existence is at threat, so they will fight. And as for the conceited Brahmins like you, realise the farmers can burn all their produce and you will not have food.

  2. What if the Centre throws the buck to the Punjab CM, to follow the new laws with amendment or revert to the old system prior to the law. Let the govt make it clear , that if the Punjab govt wants, they can revert to the old system. That the new system is optional so only the states which want to implement it will implement it.. This way , it can achieve two things. If the opposition states don’t want it, they are free to revert to the old system and face the same problems which has plagued the farmers. if the new system is better, surely the states which accept it, will surge ahead and the adamant farmers of non willing states, will realize sooner than later. Also the states which deliberately tried to portray the laws as taking away land from farmers, will have to deal with the consequence of playing negative politics , pay the price for it. Let this process of states accepting the new laws be made very clear so that the market system works flawlessly in those states .

Comments are closed.

Most Popular