New Delhi: A cumulative 64,68,388 adult Covid-19 infections were estimated in India by early May, the results of the serological survey conducted by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) have revealed.
On 15 May, India’s official Covid count was 85,940. This shows the country had missed nearly 64 lakh cases in the first three months of the pandemic, with March taken as the starting point. As of Friday morning, the country has a caseload of 45,62,414.
The missed cases came at a time when India’s testing regimen was extremely restrictive, heavily relying on whether people were symptomatic or not despite official statements that 69 per cent of Indian patients were asymptomatic.
The study published in the Indian Journal of Medical Research Friday said a total of 30,283 households were visited and 28,000 individuals were enrolled for the sero survey across the country.
“Population-weighted seroprevalence after adjusting for test performance was 0.73 per cent. Males, living in urban slums and occupation with high risk of exposure to potentially infected persons were associated with seropositivity. A cumulative 6,468,388 adult infections were estimated in India by the early May,” said the study.
“The overall ICR (infection to case ratio) was between 81.6 and 130.1 with May 11 and May 3, 2020 as plausible reference points for reported cases. The IFR (infection fatality ratio) in the surveyed districts from high stratum, where death reporting was more robust, was 11.72 to 15.04 per 10,000 adults, using May 24 and June 1 2020 as plausible reference points for reported deaths,” it said.
Of these, 8,56,062 infections were in zero-case districts. At the time of the survey, there were 233 zero case districts in India.
The difference between an infection and a case is that the latter is medically diagnosed. The infection-to-case ratio is a measure of what proportion of infections were diagnosed while the infection fatality ratio looks at deaths as a proportion of infections and not cases.
A sero survey estimates what percentage of the population has been exposed to a virus by looking not for the virus or an antigen but antibodies.
Also read: India has a health ‘time bomb’ ticking – and it isn’t Covid
Much lower fatality
The ICMR had given out the results of the sero survey in June but the actual peer-reviewed publication has been released now.
According to the findings, the infection fatality ratio shows the percentage of fatalities in India because of Covid is way lower even than the 1.7 per cent figure, which is about half the global average. In other words, Covid seems to be killing far less people in India than even the current official estimates.
In the 30,283 households from 700 clusters in 70 districts that were covered by surveyors, 28,000 people agreed to be a part of the survey.
While acknowledging the dynamic nature of the pandemic in which a zero case district does not remain so for long, the researchers wrote on the seroprevalence found in zero case districts that “there could be under-detection of COVID-19 cases in the zero stratum districts on account of low testing as well as poor access to the testing laboratories”.
“In four of the 15 districts in this stratum, COVID-19 testing laboratory was not available at the district headquarters and the samples were transported to the State headquarter hospitals for diagnosis. The present findings of seropositivity in the strata of districts with zero to low incidence of COVID-19 cases underscores the need to strengthen surveillance and augment the testing of suspected cases in these areas,” the report said.
Also read: 1 in 100 hospitalised Covid patients may get a punctured lung, finds new Cambridge study
Need for district-level sentinel surveillance facilities
The findings showed that India was still in the early stages of the pandemic even in May.
“The low prevalence observed in most districts indicates that India is in early phase of the epidemic and the majority of the Indian population is still susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 infection. It is, therefore, necessary to continue to implement the context-specific containment measures including the testing of all symptomatics, isolating positive cases and tracing high risk contacts to slow transmission and to prevent the overburdening of the health system,” wrote the researchers from various ICMR institutes across the country.
They recommended setting up district-level sentinel surveillance facilities, and continuous sero surveys to better understand the spread of the disease.
Seroprevalence estimates conducted later in the epidemic, or in the settings with higher prevalence such as containment zones, provide better quality data on infection-to-case and infection-to-fatality ratios, they said.
“It is further recommended to establish the district-level facility-based sentinel serosurveillance to systematically monitor the trend of infection in the long term to inform local decision-making at the lowest administrative unit of public health response towards the COVID-19 epidemic in the country,” the researchers added.
Also read: Vaccine hesitancy growing in parts of world as people doubt effectiveness, Lancet study says
Anything is possible with statistics. Give these things to 12th class students or maths graduates, they will come up with even fancier projections. What if “India missed 64 lakhs” infections – it should be seen as this flu (or this seasons flu) is the least fatal of all. Without getting into the bogusness of testkits (both RT PCR antigen and antibody) and the bogusness of counting deaths i can bring out this scam. 64 lakhs infections missed, but death is still 64000(currently) – infact the 64 lakhs is the extrapolation by statisticians, then can project it to 64 Cr missed cases also – thats the fun in it. So out of 64lakhs missed (in May) we had 3000 deaths (in May) – which is not even 0.05% CFR in May. So, in Sept it must be 7 Cr missed cases? Or 70 Cr (thanks to extrapolating graphs of statistics and ML tools). Media has helped people outsource their intelligence and wisdom. India for the past 2 decades have had 27,800 deaths per day on an average (yes, again a modest statistics), today when they say its nth wave, we have 1000 deaths per day attributed to the flu – but the total death is still 27000 odd cases per day (this number will come out at the end of the year anyway, so far i havent seen any extra death as per records which are yet hidden from public access). So, where is the new ‘pandemic’ killing extra people? Pandemics dont exist in nature, these are bogus stories made to either cover up chemical toxins ( smallpox, polio, ebola, aids and tetanus, dengue, malaria, encephalitis/meningitis) or just scare like all flus and respiratory diseases which are easier to show as ‘spreading’ like a magician does by diverting attention.
On 10th of May, total confirmed caseload in India was around 67000. Going by this sero-survey, the actual number of cases was around 100 times higher. Since then, testing has increased, but so has the infection spread with the country unlocking in stages. So it should be fare assumption that the ratio between actual and confirmed number of cases have not decreased drastically. If so, with 45 lakh confirmed cases, we should now have around 45 crore actual infections – which belies the test positivity rate. How accurate is this survey? Can this suffer from same kind of statistical errors that opinion polls do?