Thank you dear subscribers, we are overwhelmed with your response.
Your Turn is a unique section from ThePrint featuring points of view from its subscribers. If you are a subscriber, have a point of view, please send it to us. If not, do subscribe here: https://theprint.in/subscribe/
On June 22, 2026, the Calcutta High Court made an observation that should concern every resident of Kolkata. Hearing a case concerning the illegal filling of water bodies in the East Kolkata Wetlands, the Court noted that, despite repeated reports submitted by government authorities, not an inch of the affected water body had been restored. The measures undertaken appeared, in the Court’s assessment, to be largely cosmetic and time-consuming.
The observation exposed an uncomfortable contradiction in the city’s environmental governance: Kolkata has legislation to protect its wetlands, an authority responsible for their conservation and international recognition of their ecological importance. Yet, the distance between legal protection and actual conservation continues to widen.
The East Kolkata Wetlands are not simply a collection of ponds and marshes on the city’s eastern periphery. Covering approximately 12,500 hectares, the Ramsar-designated landscape is one of the world’s most distinctive examples of an urban ecological and resource-recovery system. Recognised as a Wetland of International Importance in 2002, it sustains a remarkable relationship between the city’s wastewater, fisheries, agriculture and local livelihoods. Wastewater carried through a network of canals enters fish ponds, locally known as bheris, where natural biological processes help reduce pollutants and support aquaculture. The ecosystem also contributes to floodwater retention, groundwater recharge, biodiversity conservation and food production.
According to the East Kolkata Wetlands Management Authority’s Ramsar information, the landscape supports approximately 50,000 direct livelihoods through fisheries, with a comparable number of people indirectly dependent on the sector. Its reported annual production includes approximately 10,500 tonnes of fish and 150 tonnes of fresh vegetables daily. The wetlands therefore perform functions that an expanding metropolis would otherwise have to replace through expensive wastewater-treatment and flood-management infrastructure.
What makes this landscape extraordinary is that its ecological productivity is inseparable from its economic and social functions. The wetlands are, in effect, a form of public infrastructure sustained through ecological processes and the labour of local communities. Yet, unlike flyovers, highways and commercial buildings, their economic value remains largely invisible in conventional measures of urban development.
The scale of ecological change is increasingly difficult to ignore. A 2024 study published in the Journal of Environmental Management, using satellite imagery and land-use analysis between 1991 and 2023, estimated that mapped wetland cover in the study area declined from 91.2 square kilometres to 33.4 square kilometres, a reduction of approximately 63.4 per cent. The study also identified a substantial increase in built-up land, from 0.2 to 10.5 square kilometres, alongside increasing fragmentation of the wetland landscape. These figures refer to the wetland-cover classification within the study’s mapped area, not the entire 12,500-hectare Ramsar site. Nevertheless, they indicate the extent of ecological transformation taking place alongside urban expansion.
The question is not whether Kolkata needs development. It does. The city requires better housing, transport connectivity, commercial infrastructure and employment opportunities. The more fundamental question is why urban growth so frequently treats ecological systems as expendable land. The expansion of settlements, warehouses, commercial establishments and road networks towards the eastern metropolitan periphery has intensified pressure on the wetlands. What was historically understood as a landscape supporting the city is increasingly being viewed through the economics of land conversion.
The January 2026 warehouse fire in Nazirabad, near Anandapur, brought the human consequences of this transformation into tragic focus. The blaze at two warehouses claimed 25 lives. Questions subsequently emerged over how such commercial establishments had come up within the protected wetland area. Reporting by The Indian Express established that environmental concerns had been brought before the National Green Tribunal years before the incident. An inspection committee constituted by the Tribunal in January 2024 had reportedly identified nearly 600 unauthorised constructions in the area. Demolition orders were subsequently issued, but the matter remained pending before the Tribunal. The tragedy raises questions not only about workplace safety but also about the administrative processes through which commercial structures can emerge in ecologically protected landscapes despite prior warnings.
The politics of wetland degradation cannot be reduced to an opposition between environmental activists and developers. It involves land ownership, local government, construction permissions, commercial interests, revenue administration and regulatory enforcement. The issue is not simply whether individual violations have occurred, but how they have remained possible despite an established legal framework.
The East Kolkata Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Act, 2006, provides the statutory foundation for protection. It empowers the East Kolkata Wetlands Management Authority to demarcate boundaries, prevent unauthorised development, regulate land use and direct the restoration of land altered in violation of the Act. The problem, therefore, cannot be explained merely by an absence of environmental legislation. It concerns the institutional capacity and consistency with which existing provisions are implemented.
The subsequent proceedings before the Calcutta High Court illustrate this implementation deficit. On August 14, 2026, the Court directed the Wetlands Management Authority to constitute a specialised team involving officials from the Authority, Kolkata Municipal Corporation, land and land reforms administration, police and other state and local bodies to identify and demarcate wetland boundaries. On September 18, the Court recorded that the Authority had sought nominations from eleven agencies only on September 1, more than two weeks after the direction to constitute the team. The expected report had not been placed before the Court, prompting a further adjournment and a renewed expectation that the authorities would ensure restoration without delay. Such proceedings reveal how administrative delays and fragmented institutional responsibilities can obstruct ecological recovery.
The problem is also one of environmental justice. The degradation of wetlands does not affect all sections of society equally. In September 2026, fish-farm workers and residents in Tardaha Kapasati alleged that an encroachment on a canal embankment had blocked access to several bheris, affecting nearly 500 workers employed across six or seven fisheries. A complaint was submitted to the Wetlands Management Authority. The workers maintained that the blocked passage prevented them from transporting fish, feed and equipment. Although the allegations remain subject to investigation, the episode illustrates how the enclosure of common ecological spaces can undermine livelihoods and restrict the economic mobility of communities dependent on them.
An ecocritical understanding of this transformation requires us to question the assumption that land acquires value only when it is converted into a more visibly profitable urban use. A fish pond transformed into a warehouse may appear to generate a higher immediate commercial return, but the city loses an ecological service whose replacement would demand substantial public expenditure. The value of a wetland is distributed across water purification, food production, flood mitigation, biodiversity and livelihoods. Such benefits rarely appear together in real-estate valuations or conventional municipal revenue calculations. Consequently, ecological wealth becomes politically invisible even as its destruction produces tangible economic costs.
The East Kolkata Wetlands also represent an ecological commons. Although individual plots may have different ownership and tenure arrangements, their hydrological and environmental functions are interconnected. Filling one water body, obstructing a canal or altering a drainage channel can affect a much larger ecological system. Conservation cannot therefore depend exclusively on property-level compliance. It requires collective planning, public accountability and recognition that the benefits of ecological protection extend beyond individual landholders.
Kolkata needs a different model of urban development, one that does not treat wetlands as residual spaces awaiting commercial conversion. The government must make available an updated, publicly accessible, geo-referenced map of the Ramsar site, statutory wetland boundaries, land-use categories and authorised structures. Satellite monitoring and regular physical inspections should identify encroachment before it becomes irreversible. The Wetlands Management Authority, municipal bodies, district administration and panchayats must work through a transparent and time-bound restoration framework, with progress reports accessible to citizens. Equally important is the protection of fishers, agricultural workers and cooperative communities, whose knowledge and labour sustain this ecosystem. Restoration must recover hydrological connectivity and ecological function rather than merely create compensatory water bodies elsewhere.
The East Kolkata Wetlands pose a larger question about the meaning of urban progress in contemporary India. A city cannot claim sustainable development while weakening the ecological systems that protect its residents. Nor can environmental conservation remain a ceremonial commitment invoked during international observances while land-use decisions proceed without adequate ecological scrutiny.
Kolkata’s wetlands are not an obstacle to the city’s future. They are part of the infrastructure that makes that future possible. The disappearance of a bheri may appear insignificant beside the construction of a warehouse or residential complex, but the cumulative loss of such ecosystems carries consequences for flooding, food security, public health and livelihoods.
The real measure of urban development is not how much land can be converted into commercial property, but whether a city can expand without destroying the ecological foundations of its own survival. When the wetlands disappear, Kolkata does not merely lose open space. It loses a part of its capacity to sustain itself.
These pieces are being published as they have been received – they have not been edited/fact-checked by ThePrint.
