Saturday, 21 May, 2022
HomeOpinionRWAs threaten animal lovers inside societies. This isn’t resident welfare: Maneka Gandhi

RWAs threaten animal lovers inside societies. This isn’t resident welfare: Maneka Gandhi

RWAs have run vicious campaigns on Facebook, threatening to beat feeders and ordered guards to beat animals inside the compounds, all in the name of lockdown.

Text Size:

When Indians were restricted to their homes on 24 March due to the coronavirus lockdown, I thought that it would be an opportunity for everyone to discover the best in themselves: read books, cultivate plants, play cards, laugh, breathe cleaner air, play with their children and animals, feed the homeless, both animals and people, write jokes on Facebook, catch up on homework, learn cooking, play music,

But this didn’t happen. Just as people in jail become vicious and want to hurt each other, many Indians became as mean as jail birds, like jail wardens, with all the power in their little kingdoms of villages and communities. It is as if we are in a sci-fi movie and the monsters have taken over.

The heads of Resident Welfare Associations (RWA) broke into people’s flats if they had animals. I had to rescue a boy, who fed cats in Mumbai, and send his attackers to jail. And he is just one of the several thousand who were victimised just because they had a compassionate side.

RWAs ran vicious campaigns on Facebook, threatening to beat feeders. They locked gates and ordered guards to beat the animals inside the compounds, even though these animals are protected by Supreme Court orders . They refused to let feeders go out.

They have also threatened to cancel the leases of tenants who fed animals. They kept poison for birds and animals in the open. In Delhi’s Kirti Nagar, which houses mid-level bureaucrats, a deputy secretary chased a 16-year-old girl and her mother calling them “whores”. I will deal with him after the lockdown.

Also read: Media rumours and vicious RWAs have been worst for animals during Covid: Maneka Gandhi

In the name of resident welfare

One of the RWAs in Thane locked the gates at night after a feeder, who wanted to avoid human contact, had left to give the strays their first meal of the day. The feeder had to spend the night on the road. In Mumbai’s Kandivali, a guard beat an already-paralysed dog in Saidham building. In Mandsaur, the municipal employees, in full public view, beat a dog to death with lathis because his owner was suspected of coronavirus infection.

A high court judge in Delhi went on a stroll with his dog without wearing a mask and landed into an argument with a person feeding monkeys, who had a legal pass from the police. The judge was filmed as he threatened to slap the monkey feeder. He then rang up the police commissioner and had the feeder’s pass cancelled. I had it restored.

People who had lived as good neighbours for years made up stories about being bitten by the dogs their neighbours feed. Some groups went and spat in front of animal owners. One temple priest in Ludhiana attacked an old lady with his idol’s bhala for feeding dogs near his temple. Another well-known priest, of a major government-run temple in Guwahati, was caught selling donated cows to a Meghalaya butcher gang who had crossed the border.

A bus driver ran over a pregnant dog repeatedly till she was mashed into the ground. Someone in Kandivli took a cricket bat and killed a mother of six puppies. One person threw his family dog from the ninth storey. People threw stones at street animal feeders. A man and his three sons recently moved into Betim, Goa, took lathis and beat up an old couple who had been feeding the dogs for 30 years.

Also read: Pets shouldn’t die inside shops in COVID-19 lockdown: Animal welfare board to state govts

Police inaction

The police told me that every second call they received during this time was either people complaining about dog feeders, or from people who were being attacked for feeding dogs. I alone must have sorted out about 7,000 cases. World War 3 has been raging for the last one month and, as time goes on, it will get much worse. One of the problems is that the police don’t want to take action on anyone except counseling them as they have been asked by the “higher” authorities to show zero crime figures, which means that this is a good time for all to indulge in crime. You can steal and rape – but India has officially no crime.

And everyone can pick on women. A majority of this viciousness is aimed at women. They are the caretakers, they are the feeders. They are the ones who have embraced all life. And they are the ones who are being attacked by these low-life, selfish people.

On Monday, I got a call from a man who had been sent a legal notice by us to desist from hounding a woman feeder in his building. The man called and said the filthiest things about the woman, accusing her of putting all their lives in danger by going out. When I remarked that since he was not supposed to come out of his flat, how was his life in danger, he went into another paroxysm of rage about women in general.

Also read: Pet shelters and rescue homes fear food shortage, no medical help despite govt assurance

The ‘Hindu’ misbehaviour

None of these incidents has a single Muslim in it. All Hindus being mean to other Hindus. And those Hindus, who say the loudest prayers, hate Muslims in the most obvious ways and celebrate every Hindu festival with great pomp, were the meanest. When Prime Minister Narendra Modi asked us to light a diya on 9 March, these were the people who smuggled in firecrackers and outdid each other in re-polluting the cities.

I have never been able to understand this latent violence in this sort of Hindu. Recently, I read a book called The Impeachment of Man, written in 1945-46 by a woman called Dr Maximiani Portas, a researcher into world religions who settled in India for 30 years and changed her name to Savitri Devi. She was active in the Independence struggle and met the Mahatma several times. This is what she had written in the 40s.

“Most of these Hindus for whom the vegetarian diet means more than a mere social tradition – more than a part and parcel of the caste rules – and who willingly despise the Mohammedans and Christians for not being vegetarians – are no animal lovers at all. They are at the most cow lovers and that also only theoretically. They are generally the last people to keep any animals as pets, and if by chance they do, to keep them for long. They will easily continue discussing high flown philosophical ideas or broad national and international problems, which they have no power to solve, while some distressed stray cat mews at an audible distance. They will boast of their superiority over the meat eating peoples but eat their food unperturbed by the sight of the hungry dog looking up at them with longing eyes. You tell the man so and he answers the usual thing we have heard again and again “there are millions of starving children and you speak of dogs and cats.”

“This is better suited to a man centred creed – a Christian or a Mohammaden – not one who professes to uphold the unity and sacredness of all life and whose vegetarianism is supposed to be a sign of that belief.”

In my next article I am going to quote what she had written about Hinduism and how people, who do not understand its glory, have misinterpreted it to become vicious. It should make us all embarrassed because it is so true.

Maneka Gandhi, Sultanpur MP and former women and child development minister, is an animal rights activist. She is the founder-chairperson of People for Animals organisation. Views are personal.

To join the animal welfare movement contact,

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Savitri Devi was a Nazi and as is usual with such types a complete hypocrite in almost exactly the way she describes people in the quote given in this article. I completely support the idea of animal welfare, but to use that monster as an exemplar of it is just horrific.

  2. The problem is people through out history never understood animals as individuals because of their culture and religion. Hope, people regardless than their fake belief learn about history of human species and planet, then only they would understand the roles of other species and how we are killing our planet. Narcissistic humans and the worst species in the face of planet Earth.

  3. We need to Take Maneka Gandhi out in the streets where these Vicious dogs are let her take them to her house. She and some stupid supporters needs to house these violent Street Dogs. Why she doesn’t do that ? Such a hypocrite woman.

    • Or maybe Dani we need to put you in the position of dogs and ensure that you don’t get any food.
      Animal haters are the most selfish people in the country

  4. So, you mean those who kill animals for food are animal lovers but who don’t feed animals are bad people.


    are you people even human or have you sold your spirits?

    Aap log ko jitni bhi gaali aati hai sab meri taraf se rakh lijiye

  5. I am a senior citizen and I feel lucky if in any one night if I get uninterrupted sleep for 3/4 as there are ten dogs who bark. All neighbours have requested the family who feeds these not to feed near the house but feed at distant place so that the dogs do not stay there all the time. But they do not listen. This is animal lovers’ terrorism. I have a right to sleep as per constitution. What will Ms Maneka Gandhi say on my this right. Are animals more important than human beings? Let the respective corporations take these dogs and feed them in the designated places.

    • What do u mean Animals are more important than human beings? Have God told you humans are more important? Animals are lesser? And yes every time it’s not possible to give food in distant. If animals were given eligibility like us to earn money & cook food for themselves they wouldn’t have needed our help. You guys have lost your humanity. What Hitler had done wrong, you people are not leeser than him. As u have right to sleep, animals have right to bark. Why people like you are not dying in corona. This world needs animals haters free people. You are senior in age but from heart zero.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular