New Delhi: Noting the significantly low OBC admissions and “abysmally low” SC and ST enrollments in private universities in India, a parliamentary panel has recommended implementing reservations in private higher education institutions for marginalised students, with full financial support from the government to ensure equal access to quality education.
The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education, Women, Children, Youth and Sports, chaired by Congress Rajya Sabha MP Digvijay Singh, tabled its 370th report Wednesday on the implementation of Article 15(5) of the Constitution regarding special provisions for reservations for SCs, STs, and OBCs in educational institutions, including private ones.
Article 15 (5) empowers the state to make special provisions for the educational advancement of socially and educationally backward classes, including SCs and STs, in private unaided educational institutions (excluding minority institutions).
Under the Central Educational Institutions (Reservation in Admission) Act, 2006, and as enabled by Articles 15(4) and 15(5) of the Constitution, central educational institutions in India provide 15 percent reservation for SCs, 7.5 percent for STs, 27 percent for OBCs, and 10 percent for EWS.
However, private educational institutions are not legally required to implement reservation policies, as no statute mandates them to do so.
According to the report, there is a significant gap between official data and actual enrollment figures.
The committee noted that, as per data from the Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Education, private HEIs reportedly have 40 percent OBC, 14.9 percent SC, and 5 percent ST students.
However, data provided by the private universities themselves reflect much lower OBC admissions and “abysmally low” SC and ST enrollments.
The report highlights lower admissions in OBC, SC and ST categories in esteemed private universities including Birla Institute of Technology and Science (BITS), OP Jindal Global and Shiv Nadar University.
It states that during the 2024-25 academic year at Birla Institute of Technology and Science, out of 5,137 students, approximately 514 (10 percent) are OBC, 29 (0.5 percent) are SC, and 4 (0.08 percent) are ST, with some students not declaring their category. Similarly, at O.P. Jindal Global University, out of 3,181 students, only 28 SC and 29 ST students are enrolled, each constituting less than 1 percent. At Shiv Nadar University, among 3,359 students, SCs number 48 (1.5 percent) and STs 29 (about 0.5 percent).
“The Committee, therefore, recommends that the Department of Higher education implement reservation quotas in educational institutions, including private ones, in proportion to the population of SCs, STs, and OBCs,” the report stated.
It further urged the establishment of a central oversight mechanism—such as the UGC, National Commission for Backward Classes, and SC/ST Commissions—to monitor implementation of Article 15(5) of the Constitution ensuring that institutions submit annual admission data to ensure compliance.
Also Read: Indian universities must not mimic Ivy Leagues. Global rankings won’t build Viksit Bharat
Divide in higher education
According to government data cited by the parliamentary panel, India has 685 government-managed universities (including 240 central and 445 state institutions) and 473 private unaided universities.
Among the country’s 45,473 colleges, only 21.5 percent are government-run, 13.2 percent are privately aided, and a majority—65.3 percent—are private unaided institutions.
The Standing Committee noted a growing divide in Indian higher education between a small number of well-resourced private and select government institutions, and the majority of higher education institutions that struggle to match their quality.
“The Committee strongly emphasizes that education must be a key instrument of attaining social justice in this country, and noted that the current absence of reservations in private HEIs may be an impediment to the same,” the report stated.
To address this imbalance, the committee recommended that Article 15(5) of the Constitution be implemented in full through parliamentary legislation.
The committee specifically proposes reserving 27 percent of seats for OBCs, 15 percent for SCs, and 7.5 percent for STs in private higher educational institutions.
It also noted that the high fees charged by private universities make education inaccessible for marginalized students and urged the State to legislate financial and structural support to ensure effective implementation of these reservations.
The committee also recommended that the department take steps to improve the quality of data collected on student composition in both private and public HEIs.
“It is important for HEIs and the department to understand the social composition of the student body as well as the prospective pool of applicants. The current system of making caste declaration optional may result in a caste-blindness of the admissions process,” the report stated.
Also Read: The history of Indian caste censuses is the history of Indian statecraft
Financial support from govt
The committee stated that any introduction of reservations for SCs, STs, and OBCs in private higher educational institutions must be fully funded by the government. It recommended adopting a model similar to the 25 percent quota under Section 12(1)(c) of the Right to Education Act, where private schools are reimbursed by the government for admitting students from disadvantaged backgrounds, in the higher education institutions as well.
Observing that expanding reservation will require increasing seats and infrastructure like classrooms, hostels, faculty, the committee recommended that central and state governments should allocate dedicated funds for private HEIs to increase seats, build infrastructure, and hire faculty in institutions implementing reservations.
“The Central and state government should also supplement resources through Public Private Partnerships (PPP) in education. The Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Education, through Higher Education Funding Agency (HEFA) should provide low-interest loans to HEIs/ Universities for infrastructure expansion, ensuring no reduction in general category seats to avoid reducing general category opportunities,” the report stated.
The Committee recommends that the department of higher education develop certain model programmes (bridge courses, free coaching for entrance exams, etc.) that private HEIs can adopt to support effective implementation of Article 15(5).
“Similarly, the Department may also provide scholarships which can bear the burden of living costs in hostels to students taking admission through quotas in private HEIs,” the report added.
Reacting to the report, Congress general secretary in charge of communications Jairam Ramesh posted on social media platform X, “The legitimate demand of SC, ST, and OBC communities for reservations in private higher education institutions can no longer be ignored.”
He added that the party’s 2024 Nyay Patra had pledged to legislate the implementation of Article 15(5), and the Committee’s report has given fresh momentum to this commitment.
Also Read: India’s higher education system needs to level up. A third pillar of experts can help