Thursday, 26 May, 2022
HomeHealthOmicron could replace other Covid variants, survive as common cold: Harvard immunologist...

Omicron could replace other Covid variants, survive as common cold: Harvard immunologist Pillai

Harvard Medical School professor Dr Shiv Pillai says India’s third wave likely to subside by March, and suggests that the country’s response to the pandemic was a mixed bag.

Text Size:

New Delhi: The current Covid-19 surge in India is likely to subside by March. Over the long term, given its high transmissibility, it’s possible that Omicron will edge out all other variants of SARS-CoV-2 and survive as a relatively mild virus for which only the elderly need to be vaccinated. 

That’s Harvard immunologist Dr Shiv Pillai’s “optimistic” take on the future at a time when an Omicron wave is sweeping the world.

In an exclusive conversation with ThePrint, he said it’s possible that Omicron will stay on as a fifth common cold coronavirus. These don’t confer immunity to those infected — it’s possible to catch the same virus multiple times in a year.

Dr Pillai added, however, that there’s also an alternative possibility of another wave caused by a resurgent Delta variant.

He also said that governments around the world didn’t tackle the pandemic as well as they could have — with India’s performance being a mixed bag — and emphasised that the flu vaccine gives no protection whatsoever against Covid.

Dr Pillai is a professor of medicine and health sciences and technology at Harvard Medical School. He is the director of Harvard’s PhD and MMSc Immunology programmes. His research group studies T cell-B cell collaboration and its relevance to autoimmune and inflammatory diseases.

He grew up in India, studied medicine at Christian Medical College, Vellore, and went on to receive a doctorate in biochemistry from the University of Calcutta. He also has a unique poetic take on immunology. 

Also read: Covid spilling over to free-ranging animals? Dead leopard cub had Delta, didn’t die of it

Two future scenarios

Dr Pillai painted two possibilities for the future. He called the first an “overly optimistic scenario”, saying, “If Omicron replaces all other variants and takes over the population — which it’s doing quite well now — then it may be the only SARS-Cov-2 variant left. There would be immunity among the vaccinated against it, less among the unvaccinated. So, after seven-eight months, people who never got the vaccine would get Omicron.”

He added, “We currently have four known common cold coronaviruses that share similarities with Omicron. What might happen is that Omicron might become the fifth common cold coronavirus. It mutates but never gets highly pathogenic. We will then develop vaccines targeted at it, maybe get the elderly vaccinated. Nothing is a slam dunk in this situation. But there is a history of similar things happening in animals.”

Evolutionally, he said, the purpose of a virus is to replicate itself, not to kill its host — so any virus that does the former as well as Omicron has a fair chance of out-surviving other variants.

However, he added that there’s also an alternative possibility, that the Delta variant, surviving somewhere in the “Amazon forests”, will resurface and, taking advantage of the limited immunity Omicron confers against the other variant — “about 40 per cent of what you want” — unleash a virulent new wave.

India’s response varied

India’s response to the pandemic has varied, and sometimes lacked adequate information in policy decisions, said Dr Pillai. But there’s also a strong element of public education that seems to be missing, with people still shunning masks or not wearing them properly.

Large gatherings, including religious ones, were held in the open, and led to surges when the participants returned home, he said. 

“All over the world, governments did not do as good a job as they could have. These things have to be rooted in science,” he said, adding, “I think people (in India) are not as serious as they should be. People don’t wear masks, or wear them in a way that will do nothing for them.”

“I am concerned about people not having information. I understand people are tired and life will go on. The issue of public education is a broader issue for a longer time,” he said.

He added, however, that “India did a great job in vaccinations.”

Also read: Most of Covid virus ‘inactivated’ in minutes, says UK study on aerosol risk at short distance

‘No smoking gun’ on SARS-CoV-2 origins

Dr Pillai was reluctant to venture too much into the origins of SARS-CoV-2, saying that there is no evidence one way or the other. 

“There is no ‘smoking gun’, absolutely none. The virus looks like viruses that can be found in animals. There are bats that have similar viruses. We do not know where the original Wuhan strain came from. To waste time on that is to waste time on something that you cannot prove,” he said. 

Nobel Prize-winning US biologist Dr David Baltimore was once quoted as saying that a particular feature of the structure of SARS-CoV-2 was a ‘smoking gun’ for the theory that the virus had originated in a laboratory, but has since said that he may have overstated the case.

Dr Pillai added that he has immense faith in Chinese scientists and is inclined to believe that the virus came from some animal. “I do not think for the slightest that anyone would intentionally release a virus,” he said.

‘Flu vaccine does nothing against Covid’

Dr Pillai ruled out any possibility that the flu vaccine might give any protection against the SARS-Cov-2 virus. 

“Flu vaccine doesn’t help in Covid at all. Maybe it helps with the flu for some time. It’s directed against particular strains, important for elderly people. In hospitals like mine, everybody has to be vaccinated against the flu. The protection is not amazing but it’s better than nothing,” he said.

He also said that in a person whose nutritional status is good, supplements do not boost immunity. “If you are not malnourished, none of those things means anything. Eating is more important than a tonic,” he said, adding, “People want to do something to protect themselves, and the business world promotes those things. But it is garbage. But it’s not harmful.”

(Edited by Rohan Manoj)

Also read: ‘Deltacron is non-variant of no concern’: Why experts aren’t worried about Delta-Omicron ‘hybrid’


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

Most Popular