Mumbai: HBO has released the first full scene from its upcoming Harry Potter series. Potterheads are not impressed.
The clip, released on 14 November, shows the start-of-term banquet at Hogwarts. The new series is another adaptation of JK Rowling’s Harry Potter books, which were made into eight films from 2001 to 2011. Fans have been comparing the two versions ever since HBO first announced its plans to remake the series. But now, fans don’t seem particularly impressed with what they’ve seen of the new one so far.
The video begins with students chanting the name of their headmaster, Albus Dumbledore, played by John Lithgow. Harry (Dominic McLaughlin) asks Ron Weasley (Alastair Stout) whether Dumbledore is “a bit mad”, to which the latter replies, “Yep, totally off his rocker”.
Dumbledore then snaps his fingers and food appears on the tables. There’s also a conversation between him and Professor McGonagall, played by Janet McTeer, about Harry.
However, one of the biggest complaints for fans isn’t not seeing familiar faces but the lighting. Fans say the Great Hall looks dull compared to the 2001 film, which starred Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter.
“The colour is so diluted. The first Harry Potter movie’s dinner scene was bright and colourful, and this looks like someone tried to copy it without understanding what made the movies fantastic,” one X user wrote, sharing a video of the scene from the 2001 film.
Another posted an edited version of the clip with brighter colours.
“What happened to colour correction? It’s so flat and grey. This took me 5 minutes, and it’s just a little contrast and saturation,” the post read.
Even the Hogwarts feast hasn’t escaped criticism. One X user compared the food with the much grander spread in the original films, joking that inflation had reached Hogwarts.
Others complained about the chanting.
“The students cheering Dumbledore. I actually cringed,” one viewer wrote on Reddit, complaining that that wasn’t in the book.
Another canonical correction is that in the text, Percy Weasley answers Harry’s question about Dumbledore, not Ron.
However, Lithgow has so far escaped criticism as the new Dumbledore.
“I can’t wait for John Lithgow’s turn as Dumbledore. I am really hoping we get the Book Albus,” one Reddit user wrote.
“Ok, that little aside and exchange between Dumbledore and McGonagall. More of those, please,” another Reddit user wrote.
The new Harry and Ron have also impressed some viewers.
“It’s good, but it’s strange at first after being so used to the films!! Dominic and Alistair are already shining so bright. And Dumbledore seems so fun and quirky already,” one fan wrote.
The series stars Dominic McLaughlin as Harry Potter, Alastair Stout as Ron Weasley and Arabella Stanton as Hermione Granger. Johnny Flynn, Warwick Davis, and Paapa Essiedu also star in the series.
The first season releases on 25 December 2026 and will have eight episodes. A second season is already in production.
(Edited by Insha Jalil Waziri)
