Even India’s biggest billionaires can’t escape the crunch in debt market

Ratings of some firms of billionaires Ajay Piramal, Pallonji Mistry & MP Lodha have been cut as the business environment worsened and funding costs rose.

File photo of Ajay Piramal | Photographer: Dhiraj Singh | Bloomberg

Mumbai: Indian tycoons including Ajay Piramal and Pallonji Mistry are grappling with a prolonged realty slump that’s adding to the shadow banking crisis, showing that even the nation’s richest can’t escape widening cracks in the debt market.

Ratings of some companies in the conglomerates run by billionaires Piramal and Mistry have been cut as the business environment worsened and funding costs rose. Rating companies also raised doubts about the debt repayment capabilities of a developer controlled by the nation’s richest property tycoon, and president of Bharatiya Janata Party’s Mumbai unit, Mangal Prabhat Lodha.

“The deteriorating credit profiles of tycoons will have far-reaching implications in terms of ratings and lending,” said Sandeep Upadhyay, managing director of Centrum Infrastructure Advisory Ltd., which focuses on real estate and infrastructure.

The weak performance of property businesses and an acute liquidity crunch were cited as key reasons for rating downgrades. While the Indian economy is forecasted to grow at 6.1% in the June quarter from a year ago, well below the 7-8% growth seen in the past few years. Wariness in credit markets still remains high with little respite in sight.

Mangal Prabhat Lodha, India’s richest property tycoon:

• Moody’s Investors Services and Fitch Ratings cut the credit rating of the closely held Macrotech Developers, founded by Lodha, by one notch this month, citing heightened liquidity risk
• Lack of sufficient progress in refinancing upcoming debt maturities is a concern, Moody’s said; The developer has also been struggling to monetize assets in London, as well as domestically
• Macrotech said that its total debt stands at 190 billion rupees ($2.66 billion) while its receivables from projects are 380 billion rupees. It also has commercial assets worth 20 billion rupees.
• Piramal Capital & Housing Finance Ltd. and Piramal Realty Ltd. had rating cuts last month with assessors citing funding challenges for the country’s shadow lenders and heightened refinancing risk for property developers
• Piramal Capital has identified 18 out of its total 232 deals involving loans to developers for corrective measures, according to recent exchange filings
• Company has also been focusing on reducing developer lending for residential projects, cutting it to 47% of the overall loan book of 566 billion rupees in June, from 79% in March 2015
  
  Pallonji Mistry, chairman of 150-year-old Pallonji Mistry Group: 
• Shapoorji Pallonji and Co. saw downgrades by Care Ratings and ICRA twice in last 12 months
• Lower-than-anticipated progress on asset sales and weaker performance of the property business were cited as key reasons
• The group recently listed its solar company Sterling & Wilson Solar Ltd., raising 29 billion rupees which will be used to pare debt

The rating cuts and liquidity crunch have put to test the belief that the prolonged slump in apartment sales is affecting small and medium-sized developers while larger ones, or those backed by top groups, have remained immune.

Still, these conglomerates may gain from the carnage that’s gripping India’s property market. Stricter laws and customer preferences for apartments that are ready to move into have prolonged developers’ working cycles, meaning that those with deeper pockets and the backing of wealthy founders tend to benefit.

“If the moguls manage to sell assets, raise funds and honor debt obligations this crisis will make them stronger in the long run. In the short run it is anybody’s guess,” said Centrum’s Upadhyay. “Creditors won’t easily come out of the overhang of the rising possibility of defaults by the nation’s richest, and rating downgrades of these groups, which were once considered pristine.”