scorecardresearch
Add as a preferred source on Google
Friday, November 28, 2025
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionCan democracy really function if citizens cannot breathe freely?

Can democracy really function if citizens cannot breathe freely?

When the environment becomes toxic, all other rights fall like dominoes.

Follow Us :
Text Size:

Every society speaks of rights — the right to equality, the right to speech, the right to vote, the right to justice. Nations debate the design of their democracies, the strength of their constitutions and the failures of their institutions. But beneath all these conversations lies a reality so fundamental that it is often forgotten: no right has meaning if the human body itself is unsafe.

Before liberty, before property, before identity, before thought — there is only one act that makes all other acts possible: to breathe. Breath is the first signal of life and the universal connection every human shares with the world. Clean water is its companion, sustaining the body in ways no ideology or institution ever can. These are not civil rights or legal entitlements. They are pre-political rights, older than civilisation, older than culture, older even than language.

Today, these first rights — clean breath and clean water — are under unprecedented threat.


Also Read: Air purifiers are the new water filters. Delhi has quietly accepted a crisis


 

When the basic act of living becomes dangerous

Across continents, human existence is becoming quietly but steadily unhealthy. Air pollution now shortens lives by years in major cities. Toxic chemicals infiltrate groundwater. Rivers that once nourished civilisations carry industrial waste. Microscopic pollutants enter our lungs, bloodstreams, and even unborn children.

This crisis does not recognise borders, ideologies, or income. It affects democracies and autocracies alike, developed nations and developing ones, urban centres, and rural expanses. Pollution has become the great equaliser — harming everyone, everywhere, all at once, albeit to different degrees.

We debate the future of democracy, but the more urgent question is: Can democracy function meaningfully if its citizens cannot breathe safely?

Clean breath and clean water: the foundation of every other right

A person struggling to breathe cannot speak freely. A body weakened by toxins cannot fight for justice. A mind clouded by polluted air cannot innovate or dream. A community without clean water cannot build prosperity.

Rights such as speech, equality, religious freedom or due process may shape the quality of society — but clean air and clean water shape the possibility of society.

When the environment becomes toxic, all other rights fall like dominoes. This is why many countries are now debating whether the right to a clean environment should be elevated to the status of a fundamental right — not as a symbolic gesture, but as a survival imperative.

Healthy existence is the first form of justice

Every nation promises justice — social, economic, political. But justice begins even before law; it begins with the moral responsibility to ensure that citizenship does not endanger life.

When a city’s air becomes unbreathable, when drinking water becomes unsafe, when children grow up surrounded by toxins, the very idea of justice collapses. Society becomes structurally unequal: those with resources escape to cleaner pockets; those without remain exposed.

Ensuring clean air and water is therefore not merely an environmental goal — it is the most essential act of equality.


Also Read: Northeast is the new pollution hotspot. South has the cleanest air, says report


 

Reordering our priorities for the future

If humanity is to survive with dignity, we must reorder our priorities:

  1. Treat clean air and clean water as the first rights of citizens. They must be enforceable, measurable, and protected like other fundamental rights.
  2. Build scientific governance into political decision-making. Air and water quality standards must be monitored with transparency and public access.
  3. Demand adaptation, not nostalgia. Institutions must evolve. Laws must be updated. Regulatory bodies must be strengthened.
  4. Create a culture of responsibility. Citizens, industries, governments, and local bodies must share the burden of protection.
  5. Restore the balance between human life and human ambition. Progress that destroys breath and water is not progress — it is deferred collapse.

The final truth: without breath, there are no rights

Every generation believes its struggles are unique. But the present generation faces a crisis that is both simple and profound: the basic act of living has become threatened. We have reached a moment when human beings must fight not only for freedom or equality, but for the air that enters their lungs and the water that enters their bodies.

This is the first right.

The right that makes all other rights possible.

The right that no human should ever have to demand.

If societies protect this right — the right to exist healthily — then democracy will thrive, constitutional values will flourish, and humanity will move forward with confidence. If we fail to protect it, every ideology, every institution and every dream will suffocate with us.

The future of human existence depends on clean breath and clean water. Everything else follows from that.

Rajesh Kumar Raina is a former Indian diplomat and an expert on neighbourhood policy, Buddhist diplomacy, and Himalayan strategic affairs. Views are personal.

(Edited by Asavari Singh)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular