In the ever-evolving world of skincare, few ingredients spark as much debate as retinol and its rising rival, bakuchiol. Both promise to turn back the clock—smoothing fine lines, evening out pigmentation, and restoring that youthful glow. Yet, as a dermatologist who sees hundreds of patients, I’ve learned that the real magic lies not in following trends, but in finding harmony with your skin’s unique biology—especially during sensitive life stages like pregnancy and stress.
Skincare isn’t a one-size-fits-all race; it’s a thoughtful, evidence-guided journey built on patience and personalisation. Let’s explore the science-backed differences between these two celebrated actives so you can choose what truly suits you.
The time-tested powerhouse
Retinol, a derivative of vitamin A, has held its place as the gold standard in anti-ageing dermatology for over four decades. Once applied, skin enzymes convert it into retinoic acid—the active molecule that accelerates cell turnover, boosts collagen production and refines skin texture from the inside out.
Clinical studies consistently show it excels at:
- Reducing fine lines and wrinkles by speeding up skin renewal
- Improving uneven texture and minimising enlarged pores
- Clearing acne and fading post-inflammatory marks
- Lightening hyperpigmentation and reviving dull complexion
A landmark 1990s study in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology demonstrated clear improvements in photoaged skin with consistent use, cementing retinol’s reputation.
That said, potency has a trade-off. Many people experience the so-called “retinisation” phase—temporary dryness, flaking, redness, or stinging—as the skin adjusts. Retinol also makes skin more sun-sensitive, so it’s best applied at night and always paired with broad-spectrum SPF 30+ the next day. Research in the New England Journal of Medicine notes that up to 70 per cent of users notice mild irritation early on, though most adapt with gradual introduction and good moisturisation.
Important pregnancy note: Retinol and other retinoids are not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding. Oral forms like isotretinoin are linked to serious birth defects, and while topical absorption is lower, experts (including guidelines from organisations like the American Academy of Dermatology) advise avoidance to eliminate any potential risk to fetal development. If you’re pregnant or planning to be, pause retinol and consult your doctor, please, not Instagram or ChatGPT.
Also read: Busting 7 Instagram skincare myths that hurt my dermatologist heart
A real-life lesson
Sonia, a 34-year-old professional who came to see me last winter, was troubled by early crow’s feet and pigmentation around her mouth and eyes. She had already experimented with retinol after reading glowing online reviews and noticed some texture improvement. But Delhi’s dry, polluted winter air made things worse: Persistent burning, redness, and a flaky barrier that no amount of moisturiser could fully calm.
We paused the retinol, focused on gentle barrier repair, and transitioned her to bakuchiol. Eight weeks later, Sonia returned with noticeably smoother, brighter skin—and zero irritation. She even felt comfortable using it in the morning. Her story is one I hear often: The most effective ingredient is the one your skin actually tolerates long-term.
Also read: How to treat melasma—strict sun protection, oral therapies and targeted lasers
Bakuchiol: Nature’s kinder alternative
Bakuchiol comes from the seeds of the Babchi plant (Psoralea corylifolia), long used in traditional Ayurvedic medicine. While frequently called a “natural retinol alternative,” it isn’t chemically related to vitamin A. Instead, it works through overlapping biological pathways—supporting collagen, reducing inflammation, and improving pigmentation—without directly activating retinoid receptors.
A well-designed 2019 randomised, double-blind trial published in the British Journal of Dermatology compared 0.5 per cent bakuchiol to 0.5 per cent retinol in women with photoaging. The results were striking: Bakuchiol delivered similar reductions in wrinkles and dark spots—with far less peeling and redness. Other studies highlight its antioxidant and soothing properties, making it especially welcoming for sensitive skin, rosacea-prone complexions, or anyone new to active ingredients.
Standout benefits include:
- Support for elasticity and protection against free radicals
- Excellent daytime compatibility (no photosensitivity concerns)
- High tolerability even for beginners or those with reactive skin
Also read: Gel manicure is weakening your nails. Here’s how to care for them
Which one is right for you?
If your skin handles stronger actives well and you’re seeking the fastest, most dramatic improvements—especially for acne, deeper lines, or significant photoaging—retinol remains unmatched (outside of pregnancy). Start low (0.1–0.3 per cent), go slow, and build tolerance under guidance.
If you have sensitive or dry skin, a history of irritation, or simply prefer a gentler entry into powerful skincare—particularly during pregnancy or breastfeeding—bakuchiol offers impressive, science-supported results with far greater comfort.
Many patients even use both strategically: Bakuchiol to strengthen the skin first, then low-dose retinol for an added boost when ready.
Whichever path you choose, the non-negotiables remain the same: Consistent use, generous hydration, antioxidant support (think vitamin C), and daily broad-spectrum sunscreen, besides a healthy diet and lifestyle, which makes the whole body truly age in reverse.
In the end, glowing skin isn’t about chasing the strongest ingredient—it’s about finding the kindest one that works for your skin and life stage.
Dr Deepali Bhardwaj is a Consultant Dermatologist, Max Hospital, Saket. She is also an anti-allergy specialist, laser surgeon and internationally trained aesthetician. She tweets @dermatdoc. Views are personal.
(Edited by Theres Sudeep)