During his ten-day tour abroad, the scion of the Congress party was scheduled to speak at the British Parliament, meet Indian diaspora, address a press conference, hold private business meetings and give a talk at Chatham House. All these, according to one of the organisers, were supposed to have ignited a debate “…not limited to a political future, but (must) embrace the cultural, social and business ties that bind both countries, as the people are the living bridge”.
Far from building bridges, Rahul Gandhi has demolished existing ones, including the image of his party.
Going by his inarticulate speeches, incoherent replies to questions and untenable averments, he has not only made a fool of himself but has probably made it extremely difficult even for some of his party colleagues to defend him. More importantly, most of his fulminations abroad reflect his inability to comprehend the real issues that his party is facing and can be summarised as gross waste of an opportunity to project himself as a serious politician.
Also read: Waqf boards are India’s big urban landlords. But whose interest are they serving?
What you don’t say abroad
In one of his speeches, he is reported to have ‘complained’ to his audience abroad that the security of his mobile phone was compromised and that it contained the Israeli spyware Pegasus. On 25 August 2022, then Chief Justice of India N.V. Ramana said that the Supreme Court committee mandated to undertake a thorough investigation into all such allegations against the government did not find any conclusive evidence on the use of the spyware in phones examined by it. Notably, out of hundreds of phones that were allegedly targeted by Pegasus, only 29 were submitted to the committee for examination. The Supreme Court appointed committee headed by CJI N.V. Ramana submitted a report stating that they had found some malware in 5 of the 29 phones examined, but there was no conclusive proof that the malware was Pegasus.
Incidentally, the BJP has revealed that Rahul Gandhi did not submit his phone to the Supreme Court-appointed probe committee for forensic examination despite being asked to do so. The party has also alleged that more than nine thousand phones were tapped during the UPA-II regime. The larger point here is that the venue and the group that Rahul Gandhi chose to make an allegation about his mobile being snooped were inappropriate, to say the least. A matured leader would have taken up such issues with the government or made these charges against the government of the day at home. Not before a foreign government and audience which have no jurisdiction here.
His allegation (while referring to a Sikh gentleman), that “Prime Minister Narendra Modi thinks that Muslims and Christians are second class citizens”, is another baseless statement that merits not only condemnation but must also attract charges of vilification. At a time when small but dangerously well-knit elements in Punjab and elsewhere are trying to revive the demand of Khalistan and pursuing a divisive agenda, such references are best avoided.
Again, as for his seeking foreign governments’ help to restore democracy in India, it was during his grandmother’s tenure in 1975 that the worst attack on judiciary, media and the basic structure of democracy was made through imposition of Emergency.
Also read: With each election win, BJP is bridging the gap between Northeast and rest of India
Where Rahul should focus
After the Bharat Jodo Yatra, the Congress party should have advised Rahul Gandhi to take stock of the situation and plan the next step in the electoral strategy for the elections that were held in the North East and other bye-elections in the country. The Bharat Jodo yatra itself appears to have achieved very little as far as the political dividends for the Congress is concerned. It was probably intended only to project the Congress scion as the supreme and unquestioned (and unquestionable) leader of the party. The yatra has not even fulfilled the electoral purposes as Rahul’s electoral campaign in the elections in the North East have fetched negligible votes for the party.
If the Bharat Jodo yatra and the subsequent faux pas abroad are taken together, Rahul Gandhi has single handedly brought great disrepute to the Congress party. After the “election” of Kharge as party president, the organisation appeared to be moving towards projecting a non ‘Gandhi parivar’ person at the helm. Though not many political commentators believed such a thing could happen in the Congress, it was a good opportunity for the party to get rid of the ‘family-owned family-operated’ tag. It is for the saner elements in the Congress, whatever little of it is left, to retrieve the situation and save the party from the disastrous ‘serial loser’. But it is easier said than done.
As was expected, the BJP has gone hammer and tongs after Rahul Gandhi but one hopes it does not become a case of overkill. The BJP would be well advised to refrain from taking any serious legal action against Rahul Gandhi for his “lies, half-lies and fulminations”. Many a truth is said in jest; such as Rahul Gandhi being the biggest campaigner for the BJP. There seems to be some truth in this as every time the Congress scion makes a foot-in-mouth statement, the Congress moves closer to oblivion.
Seshadri Chari is the former editor of ‘Organiser’. He tweets @seshadrichari. Views are personal.
(Edited by Anurag Chaubey)