Delhi: A video by Indian stand-up comedian Daniel Fernandes on how Jains posed as Muslims to buy goats this Bakrid received massive backlash from the former community. His four shows in Chennai and Hyderabad were cancelled after he received threats over emails and social media.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MLA from Telangana, T Raja, shot a video saying that if Fernandes doesn’t cancel the show in Hyderabad, his workers “will come there and thrash him”. The MLA also recalled that in 2021, comedian Munawar Faruqui’s Bengaluru show was cancelled as he allegedly insulted Hindu deities during one of his shows.
On 29 June 2024, Fernandes posted an apology through an Instagram video and promised the Jain community that he would not mention them in his performances. “It was the factual narration of something that happened in a comedic way and there was no intention to target any group,” said Fernandes over a telephonic conversation with ThePrint.
A day after Bakrid on 18 June, ThePrint broke a story on how Jains in Chandni Chowk dressed up as Muslims and bought 124 goats to “save them from sacrifice”. Fernandes read the article and thought he could put a comical spin to it. In the video that is now pulled down, the comedian said that the audience must have some questions: “Are these the same Jains who owned meat export businesses where they profit off the slaughter of animals?” The comedian went on to joke that when the goats multiply, the Jains will have to make an “awkward phone call” to Salim bhai, asking, “When is Eid, we have 300 goats”. The video received angry comments from the Jain and Hindu communities, which took offence at Fernandes pulling a joke about them being meat exporters. The abusive messages asked him to “prove it”, said the comedian.
“I started [my comedy career] sometime in 2011. I have had people outraged over my jokes before, but this is the first time somebody has tried to cancel the shows. Earlier, you didn’t look over your shoulder. It is a very distressing feeling,” said the comedian.
From Chennai to Hyderabad
On 28 June, Fernandes was on his way to the Chennai venue, Medai – The Stage, when he received a phone call from the police. He was told that a mob had gathered outside the police station and demanded the show’s cancellation.
“They were an aggrieved group of people who said that their sentiments were hurt. They filed a complaint at the police station and did not want the show to happen. But they were peaceful, and there was no violence threat,” he said.
The following day, Fernandes landed in Hyderabad and saw Raja’s video being widely shared on social media. Minutes later, he learned that the managers at the venue, Jubilee Hills, were receiving calls and being harassed.
“I don’t know which community the people belonged to, but I learned that they were impersonating policemen and entering the venue saying that they were looking for me and the producer of the show. Then there were calls saying we will storm the venue and vandalise it,” the comedian said.
After canceling the Hyderabad show, Fernandes said in the online video: “To the members of the Jain community…there was no intention to malign anybody. I can see that you are upset and it genuinely makes me sad.”
Fans responded in solidarity and expressed disappointment at the show’s cancellation. “I was literally at the cafe on time for the first time in my life. Returned home with a heavy heart after reading the cancellation notice,” one said.
The comedian said that after he posted the video, he received messages from the members of the Jain community thanking him for acknowledging their sentiments and wishing him well.
“Jains have shown me kindness, embraced me through forgiveness,” the comedian told ThePrint.
Also read: The India that Vir Das and liberals want – and the one they won’t talk about
Fellow comedians speak up
Support poured in from Fernandes’ fellow comedians. Kunal Kamra commented on the apology video, saying, “Comedians are an oppressed minority”. Punit Pania said that there is “legal redressal for people who are offended”.
“We instead resort to violence. It’s rather sad how religiosity and hooliganism are so closely aligned in our country. And till the time there are threats, abuses, open calls for violence by no less than the elected representatives of the dispensation, there is no civilised discussion possible on this issue,” said Pania, speaking to ThePrint. He also said that everything in India is coloured with religiosity and there is nothing left for the comedian to talk about.
Despite the controversy, Fernandes says that he will never write from a place of fear.
“I am very conscious about how I write my material. My objective is laughter. I am not looking to put anybody down.”
(Edited by Humra Laeeq)
Will he make a joke about the Muslim community in India or abroad? My comment about the goats multiplying and taking over the earth in the Youtube video section of the Print was deleted. It is based on the Biblical and Quranic interpretation that God made man to rule over all other life forms for material benefits. So, man can treat them as material goods to be traded. This materialistic interpretation has devastated the world ecology and environment. Jains on the other hand respect all living things. Left to itself, a tree can live for more than hundred years and possibly for thousands of years which a human being can only dream of. Jains do not proselytize and attempt to convert others to their religion like Christians and Muslims by their actions. I am not a Jain. I am only an admirer of their high regard for all living things. (Please do not delete this comment)
In this incidence, his target wasn’t politicians, billionaires, celebrities or specific individuals. That would’ve been understandable. But he targeted an entire religious community. The most pacifistic, non-violent community at that. He mocked them for their clearly moral act of saving animals.. moral by every yardstick. I don’t think Indian laws permit outraging religious sentiments in this way. Just because he comes from a violent abrahmic cult, he shouldn’t keep offending Indic religions under the garb of comedy. Repeat offender.
Why the don’t make jokes on their own community?
Why they always target our Hindu & jain community
He was actually really funny. He pointed out the absurdity of the whole thing. Sadly we live in country where people are so thin skinned and unable to laugh and whose “feelings” ger hurt rather too easily. The same people meanwhile treat their fellow citizens like dirt and their feelings remain intact. The biggest hypocrites are those that follow some religious faith or the other.
He would have been looking over his shoulder to keep his head, if it were a different religion this joke was about.. Would love to see the reaction from all the “so called Liberal” publications them.
this so called leftist/humanist masquerading as “comedian” was targeting hindus in passive aggresively ( through so called demeaning jokes) manner . And the author is giving cover to the “comedian” so that he can play victimhood card.
Unfortunate that i have to keep calling out the left bias of this author …..
and Iam not a Jain…..