SubscriberWrites: Rethinking Merit–Challenging Traditional Hiring Practices in Corporate India

India's IT sector needs to adopt inclusive hiring practices that value diverse experiences and resilience over rigid academic criteria, recognizing the impact of family stability and privilege.

Representative image | FMT

Thank you dear subscribers, we are overwhelmed with your response.

Your Turn is a unique section from ThePrint featuring points of view from its subscribers. If you are a subscriber, have a point of view, please send it to us. If not, do subscribe here: https://theprint.in/subscribe/

The traditional hiring practices in India’s corporate sector, particularly in IT, have long relied on a narrow definition of merit – one that prioritizes consistent academic performance and uninterrupted educational trajectories. While these metrics might appear objective at first glance, they often reflect privilege more than potential, particularly the hidden advantage of family stability that was predominantly enjoyed by children of government employees in pre-1991 India.

The Problem with Current Metrics

The emphasis on steady academic performance and high percentage requirements creates an inherent bias in the hiring system. Companies typically set strict cut-off marks for campus placements and automatically reject candidates with gaps in their education or fluctuating grades. This approach fails to recognize that academic consistency often reflects family stability rather than individual capability or potential.

Consider these scenarios:

• A capable learner might have taken a year’s break due to family financial difficulties
• A talented individual might have had to help in the family business during crucial academic years
• A promising student might have had to relocate due to family circumstances, affecting their academic performance
• A death in the family might adversely affect the academic performance of a student

In each of these cases, the disruption in academic performance reflects external circumstances rather than the individual’s capabilities or potential value to an organization.

The Need for Change

Corporate India needs to recognize that a steady academic career is more often an indicator of familial privilege – particularly the stability that government employment provided – rather than innate ability or potential for professional success. This recognition should lead to more nuanced and inclusive hiring practices that:

1. Look Beyond Academic Consistency: Companies need to develop evaluation methods that consider the context of a candidate’s academic journey. Rather than automatically rejecting applications with gaps or fluctuations, they should:

• Create mechanisms to understand the circumstances behind academic inconsistencies
• Evaluate recovery and resilience shown after facing challenges
• Consider the overall trajectory rather than isolated academic performance metrics

1. Value Diverse Experiences: The struggles faced by candidates from less privileged backgrounds often foster valuable skills:

• Problem-solving abilities developed through facing real-world challenges
• Resilience built through overcoming adversities
• Adaptability learned through managing uncertain circumstances
• Leadership skills developed through handling family responsibilities

1. Implement Context-Sensitive Recruitment: Organizations should develop recruitment processes that:

• Consider socioeconomic background and challenges overcome
• Include alternative assessment methods beyond academic scores
• Value practical skills and potential over perfect academic records
• Create separate evaluation tracks for candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds

Practical Recommendations for Companies

1. Revised Screening Criteria

• Remove automatic filters based on academic gaps
• Develop a holistic evaluation system that considers circumstances behind academic variations
• Create separate pools for candidates from challenging backgrounds
• Implement background-adjusted cut-off marks

1. Alternative Assessment Methods

• Skills-based assessments that measure current capabilities
• Project-based evaluations that demonstrate practical abilities
• Problem-solving tests that showcase analytical thinking
• Behavioral interviews that assess soft skills and adaptability

1. Inclusive Hiring Programs

• Dedicated hiring channels for candidates with non-traditional backgrounds
• Mentorship programs to support transition into corporate roles
• Training programs to bridge skill gaps
• Partnership with NGOs and educational institutions to identify promising candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds

1. Organizational Culture Changes

• Training for HR teams about bias in traditional merit-based systems
• Education for managers about the value of diverse experiences
• Regular review of hiring practices and their impact on diversity
• Success stories highlighting employees from non-traditional backgrounds

The Way Forward

The corporate sector, particularly the IT industry, has an opportunity to lead transformative change in Indian society by adopting more inclusive hiring practices. This isn’t just about social responsibility – it’s about tapping into a vast pool of talent that current practices might be overlooking.

Companies that embrace these changes can benefit from:

• Increased diversity in thought and problem-solving approaches
• Enhanced organizational resilience through diverse experiences
• Improved understanding of different market segments
• Stronger connection with the broader Indian society

The time has come for corporate India to acknowledge that merit cannot be measured solely through academic consistency. By understanding the historical context of privilege, particularly the advantage of government service backgrounds, companies can develop more equitable and effective hiring practices that truly identify and nurture talent from all segments of society.

These pieces are being published as they have been received – they have not been edited/fact-checked by ThePrint.