SubscriberWrites: India – Ethical contradictions

India needs a Senior Protection Obligation Act to shield elders from mis-selling, ensure fair banking, and channel ₹72,000 cr unclaimed deposits into senior welfare.

A man counts money after withdrawing it from an automated teller machine (ATM) in New Delhi, India | Representational image | Reuters

Thank you dear subscribers, we are overwhelmed with your response.

Your Turn is a unique section from ThePrint featuring points of view from its subscribers. If you are a subscriber, have a point of view, please send it to us. If not, do subscribe here: https://theprint.in/subscribe/

Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act – Propos

The Problem

• India produces food surpluses, yet millions go hungry.
• RBI reports ₹72,000 crores unclaimed deposits, much in seniors’ names.
• Banks’ Relationship Managers (RMs) aggressively push products without concern for seniors’ financial security.
• Seniors face longevity risk, cognitive decline, and weak family/legal support.

Why SPO?

• Current laws ensure KYC (Know Your Customer) but not DYC (Duty to Your Customer).
• Seniors are the most financially targeted yet least protected group.

Key Provisions of SPO Act

1. Suitability Test – Mandatory assessment of seniors’ risk profile, liquidity, and dependency.
2. Cooling-off Period – 15–30 days to reverse high-risk/long lock-in products.
3. Risk Disclosures – One-page simple “risk sheet” in plain/local language.
4. RM Accountability – Digital records of advice; personal liability for mis-selling.
5. Senior Ombudsman Division – Fast-track grievance redressal within 30 days.
6. Senior Welfare Fund – Portion of unclaimed deposits used for: 
   • Health insurance top-ups.
   • Helplines and legal-aid services.
   • Awareness campaigns.

Implementation

• Parliament to enact SPO Act.
• RBI, SEBI, IRDAI to regulate jointly.
• Mandatory training & certification for RMs.
• Annual compliance & audits by banks.

Expected Impact

• Prevent financial exploitation of seniors.
• Ethical, transparent banking culture.
• Use idle deposits for social good.
• Protect seniors’ dignity, security, and trust.

👉 The SPO Act is not just policy—it is a national duty to protect those who built India’s economic foundation.

Detailed explanation 

Here are three sharp contradictions that really sum up India’s situation:

1. Food vs Hunger – India produces a food surplus, but leakages, corruption, poor storage, and distribution failures leave millions hungry.
2. Unclaimed Deposits vs Elderly Poverty – RBI data on ₹72,000 crores lying unclaimed is staggering, while many senior citizens struggle with basic needs.
3. Aggressive Marketing vs Elder Protection – Banks’ “Relationship Managers” are incentivized to push products, not to assess the socio-economic safety of their elderly clients.

Why SPO (Senior Protection Obligation) is needed

If we think in terms of corporate responsibility, banks today have a KYC obligation (Know Your Customer). But there is no DYC obligation (Duty to Your Customer). For seniors, this gap becomes more dangerous because:

• Many seniors may not fully grasp complex, high-risk products.
• Longevity risk means they can outlive their savings if wrongly advised.
• Cognitive decline and dependence make them vulnerable to mis-selling.
• Legal heirs often discover losses too late, after the senior has passed away.

Possible Government Action

The Indian Government (through RBI, SEBI, IRDAI, and Parliament) could enact a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) framework. This would require:

1. Mandatory Suitability Test – Before selling any product to a senior citizen (70+), banks must prove suitability: stability of income, liquidity needs, medical expenses, risk appetite.
2. Cooling-off Period – For high-value or long-lock-in products, give seniors 15–30 days to reverse the decision without penalty.
3. Disclosure of Risks in Simple Language – Standardized one-page “risk sheet” (like medicine side effects) for each product.
4. Ethical Responsibility of Relationship Managers – RMs must record advisory conversations (digitally), making them personally accountable if mis-selling is proven.
5. Unclaimed Deposits Redirection – Part of the unclaimed deposit pool can be used to fund senior-welfare schemes (medical insurance, helplines, pension top-ups).
6. Bank Ombudsman with Senior Division – Fast-track grievance redressal exclusively for seniors’ banking/insurance complaints.

Ethical Responsibility of Relationship Managers

Right now, RMs act like sales agents. With SPO, their duty of care must shift:

• Assess client’s life expectancy, dependency, and liquidity.
• Offer capital-protection first solutions (FDs, annuities) before riskier mutual funds/ULIPs.
• Maintain annual “suitability reports” signed by client + family.

👉 In short, sir, what you suggest makes eminent sense: just as India has Consumer Protection Laws, it needs a Senior Protection Obligation Law, because seniors form the most vulnerable yet financially targeted group.

Would you like me to draft a structured proposal (in Word format) that you could share with your UN retiree association or even with MPs/commissions—so that this idea of SPO becomes a model policy suggestion?

Vm300825 ****

Here is a structured proposal draft that you can copy–paste directly into a Word file. I have kept it policy-note style, so that it can be shared with associations, MPs, or commissions.

Proposal for a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act

(Draft Policy Note)

1. Background

India today faces a paradox. While the nation produces food surpluses and generates vast savings, millions of citizens—particularly senior citizens—remain vulnerable:

• Food vs Hunger – Despite food self-sufficiency, millions go to bed hungry due to distribution failures.
• Unclaimed Deposits – RBI data reveals over ₹72,000 crores lying unclaimed, much of it belonging to or in the name of senior citizens.
• Financial Mis-selling – Relationship Managers (RMs) in banks and financial institutions aggressively market products without due regard to seniors’ socio-economic conditions, health, or support systems.

This situation calls for urgent government intervention through a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) framework.

2. Objectives of SPO

1. To protect the financial interests of senior citizens against unethical sales practices.
2. To ensure transparency and accountability in financial advice offered to the elderly.
3. To create a safety net for vulnerable citizens through regulatory safeguards.
4. To channel unclaimed deposits towards senior welfare schemes.

3. Key Features of the SPO Framework

3.1 Suitability & Risk Assessment

• Mandatory “Suitability Test” before selling any financial product to citizens above 70 years.
• Assessment to include: income stability, health status, dependency level, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance.

3.2 Cooling-off Period

• 15–30 days “cooling-off” window for seniors to withdraw from high-risk or long lock-in products without penalty.

3.3 Transparent Disclosures

• Standardized one-page risk sheet in simple language (regional languages included), similar to medicine side-effect disclosures.
• Disclosure of lock-in periods, penalties, and expected returns in bold print.

3.4 Ethical Responsibility of Relationship Managers

• RMs to maintain digital recordings of advisory sessions with senior clients.
• Personal accountability of RMs for proven mis-selling cases.
• Annual “Suitability Report” for senior clients, signed by both client and a family nominee.

3.5 Senior Ombudsman System

• A dedicated Senior Division under the RBI Banking Ombudsman scheme.
• Fast-track grievance redressal within 30 days.

3.6 Utilization of Unclaimed Deposits

• Creation of a Senior Welfare Fund from a portion of unclaimed deposits.
• Support to: 
  • Health insurance top-ups for the elderly.
  • Helplines and legal-aid services for senior financial disputes.
  • Public awareness campaigns on safe financial planning.

4. Implementation Mechanism

1. Legislative Backing – Introduction of a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act by Parliament.
2. Regulatory Oversight – RBI, SEBI, and IRDAI to jointly oversee enforcement.
3. Training & Certification – Mandatory training for RMs on senior-friendly advisory standards.
4. Monitoring & Audits – Annual compliance reports by banks and periodic independent audits.

5. Expected Outcomes

• Reduced incidence of financial mis-selling to seniors.
• Higher trust in banking and financial systems.
• Efficient use of idle/unclaimed deposits for social good.
• Strengthened social security net for vulnerable senior citizens.

6. Conclusion

India must move beyond slogans of “financial inclusion” to genuine financial protection. Senior citizens, who built the nation’s economic backbone, deserve a dignified, secure, and transparent financial environment.

A Senior Protection Obligation Act would be a historic step in aligning India’s financial system with the values of justice, care, and accountability.

Here is a 2-page briefing note version — concise, crisp, and designed for quick reading by policymakers, associations, or media. You can copy–paste this into Word.

Briefing Note

Proposal for a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act

Background

India’s growth story hides a disturbing paradox:

• Food vs Hunger – India produces a food surplus, yet millions go to bed hungry due to failures in distribution and welfare delivery.
• Unclaimed Deposits – The Reserve Bank of India reports ₹72,000 crores of unclaimed bank deposits, much belonging to senior citizens.
• Financial Mis-selling – Relationship Managers (RMs) in banks aggressively market financial products, often ignoring the socio-economic and health needs of senior clients.

This exposes a grave vulnerability: while the elderly are targeted for sales, they lack systematic protection.

Why SPO is Needed

• Seniors face longevity risk, outliving their savings if wrongly advised.
• Cognitive decline makes them vulnerable to pressure tactics.
• Families often discover losses only after the senior’s death.
• Current regulation ensures KYC (Know Your Customer), but not DYC (Duty to Your Customer).

India needs a Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act to correct this imbalance.

Key Provisions Proposed

1. Suitability Test

• Mandatory risk and suitability assessment before selling financial products to seniors (70+).
• Factors: income stability, health, dependency, liquidity needs.

2. Cooling-off Period

• Seniors get a 15–30 day window to reverse high-risk or long lock-in investments without penalty.

3. Simple Risk Disclosures

• One-page “risk sheet” in plain language, covering lock-in, penalties, and real risks.

4. Accountability of RMs

• Digital recording of advisory sessions.
• Personal accountability of RMs in proven mis-selling cases.
• Annual “Suitability Report” signed by client + nominee.

5. Senior Ombudsman Division

• Special fast-track grievance cell under RBI Ombudsman.
• Complaints resolved within 30 days.

6. Unclaimed Deposits for Welfare

• Portion of ₹72,000 crores unclaimed deposits to create a Senior Welfare Fund for: 
  • Medical insurance top-ups.
  • Financial/legal helplines.
  • Awareness drives on safe financial planning.

Implementation

• Legislation: Parliament to enact SPO Act.
• Regulators: RBI, SEBI, IRDAI to jointly enforce.
• Training: Mandatory certification for RMs in senior-sensitive advisory practices.
• Monitoring: Independent audits + annual compliance reporting by banks.

Expected Impact

• Reduced exploitation of senior citizens.
• Transparent, ethical banking practices.
• Productive use of unclaimed deposits for social good.
• Restored trust and dignity in financial dealings for the elderly.

Conclusion

India’s seniors built the nation’s economy; they must not be left vulnerable in their final years. The Senior Protection Obligation (SPO) Act would:

• Protect them from mis-selling.
• Ensure dignity and fairness in financial services.
• Convert idle deposits into a safety net for the elderly.

This is not charity—it is a matter of justice, accountability, and national duty.

These pieces are being published as they have been received – they have not been edited/fact-checked by ThePrint.