Thank you dear subscribers, we are overwhelmed with your response.
Your Turn is a unique section from ThePrint featuring points of view from its subscribers. If you are a subscriber, have a point of view, please send it to us. If not, do subscribe here: https://theprint.in/subscribe/
Dear Honorable Finance Minister,
Subject: A Humble Plea for Middle-Class Tax Relief
The Indian middle class—often referred to as the nation’s ATM for taxes—continues to bear a disproportionate burden when it comes to funding the country’s revenues. The numbers speak for themselves: in the financial year 2023-24, personal income tax collections saw a staggering 25.4% increase, reaching ₹10.45 trillion. This accounted for over 53% of direct tax revenues, a sharp rise from the previous year’s 50.06%. In comparison, corporate tax collections grew by a modest 10.3%, totaling ₹9.11 trillion. The message is clear: the middle class is pulling more weight than ever.
The Tax Burden: A One-Way Street
In most high-tax countries, citizens benefit from free healthcare, subsidized education, and robust public infrastructure. In India, however, taxpayers find themselves in a unique predicament. Not only do we pay taxes, but we also end up spending out of pocket for essential services like healthcare and education. For a middle-class family, this dual responsibility creates a significant financial strain.
This strain underscores the pressing need to reduce the tax burden on the middle class. Easing tax rates or increasing thresholds for certain income brackets would provide much-needed relief and enhance their financial security. It is time to recognize that such measures are not mere concessions but vital economic strategies to sustain growth and equity.
Corporate Tax Cuts
Corporate tax cuts introduced in recent years were a progressive move aimed at encouraging domestic investment and bolstering economic growth. However, the anticipated benefits have not fully materialized. While these cuts were expected to spur investments, much of the savings appears to have been routed abroad, contributing to capital outflows rather than fostering local development. This calls for a re-evaluation to ensure that corporate tax incentives achieve their intended purpose without inadvertently shifting the burden onto the middle class. Meanwhile, the middle class continues to play its part, with their tax contributions directly fueling domestic demand and economic growth.
Why Middle-Class Relief is an Economic Imperative
- Redefining the Middle Class
The definition of the middle class in India needs an urgent relook. Families earning up to ₹50 lakhs annually in urban centers like Bengaluru and Mumbai are barely managing to meet basic aspirations and are far from being considered affluent. The rising cost of living, coupled with stagnant real income growth, places these families under tremendous financial pressure. Recognizing the unique challenges faced by this segment is essential to crafting meaningful tax policies.
- Boosting Domestic Demand
The middle class forms the backbone of India’s consumption economy. From weekend outings at local cafes to upgrading household gadgets, every rupee spent by this segment drives demand across industries. Tax relief for the middle class would lead to higher disposable income, spurring spending and creating a multiplier effect on GDP growth and employment.
- Expanding the Tax Net
India’s tax net remains narrow, with a significant portion of the population either exempt or evading taxes. For instance, profitable agricultural income—especially for large landowners—is often untaxed. Introducing taxes for landowners with holdings exceeding 100 acres could be a step toward more equitable taxation. Such measures would not only relieve the middle class but also ensure a fairer distribution of the tax burden.
- Rewarding Taxpayers
Paying taxes is a civic duty, but it often feels like a thankless one. Let us make tax compliance aspirational by creating a culture of recognition and reward. Visible benefits, such as exclusive tax recognition programs, expedited access to government services, or perks like dedicated airport lines for taxpayers, faster passport service, can transform the experience of being a responsible citizen. Additionally, tax credits for environmentally sustainable choices or higher deductions for health and education expenses could further motivate compliance. Such initiatives would not only improve morale but also widen the tax base, making tax compliance both desirable and “cool.”
The Case for Moving Beyond Tokenism
Token gestures will no longer suffice for a population that is increasingly aware and vocal about its contributions and expectations. Over the past three to four budgets, the middle class has been offered marginal benefits—minor increases in tax deduction limits or adjustments in tax slabs. While these changes have been welcomed, they do little to address the substantial financial challenges faced by this segment. What is needed now is a comprehensive overhaul that provides significant and tangible relief, rather than incremental adjustments. middle-class taxpayers deserve measures that genuinely ease their financial burdens and reflect their critical role in nation-building.
Addressing Concerns
Critics may argue that reducing taxes for the middle class could widen the fiscal deficit. However, this perspective overlooks the dynamic nature of an economy. Higher disposable income leads to increased spending, which in turn drives production, job creation, and additional tax revenues through indirect taxes like GST.
All recent policy measures have focused heavily on addressing supply-side issues—corporate incentives, production-linked schemes, and infrastructure boosts. While these have had their impact, the current challenge lies in reviving demand. Reducing personal taxes is the most direct and effective way to stimulate demand, putting more money into the hands of consumers who will spend it, thereby fueling economic activity.
The Bottom Line
The Indian middle class is more than just a source of tax revenue; it’s the lifeline of the nation’s economic engine. From driving domestic demand to contributing to societal stability, this segment’s importance cannot be overstated. Prioritizing tax relief for the middle class isn’t an act of charity; it’s an investment in India’s future.
Honorable Minister, a balanced approach to taxation—one that alleviates the burden on the middle class while expanding the tax base—can help create a more equitable and thriving economy. By giving the middle class the break it deserves, we’re not just ensuring their well-being but also paving the way for a brighter, more prosperous India.
So, let’s ask ourselves: isn’t it time the middle class got something back for all its contributions? A fairer tax system would be a good place to start.
Yours sincerely,
A Concerned and Hopeful Taxpayer
These pieces are being published as they have been received – they have not been edited/fact-checked by ThePrint