There is a general myth and misperception among many consumers that distilled spirits are ‘stronger’ (and therefore more intoxicating) than beer or wine regardless of the quantity consumed. But the reality is different. The alcohol in beer, wine, and distilled spirits, is called ethanol (or ethyl alcohol). Therefore, the alcohol in all drinks containing alcohol is the same, and it has the same effects on the body. There is no drink of moderation, but only a practice of moderation. Still, the amount of alcohol varies by the type of drink and the serving size; so it is important to understand what is in a drink and monitor how much and how often you drink.
From a public health perspective, this is a dangerous misperception that could increase harmful drinking if consumers underestimate the effects of drinking beer or wine.
Some state governments reinforce this misperception through policies and regulations that discriminate against distilled spirits and give preferential treatment to beer or wine. For example, the state of Haryana, in its excise policy of 2023-24 allowed corporate offices with a staff of at least 5,000 and a minimum covered area of 100,000 sq. ft to consume low-alcoholic drinks like beer, wine, or spirits within the office premises.
Another example is the state of UP which, while acknowledging in its excise policy of 2024-25 that ‘law and order situations often arise due to consumption of beer here and there, and (hence) for the solution of the same, the facility of consumption for beer shops will be allowed by the District Excise Officer after the approval of the District Magistrate after receiving the online application form, but for this, a minimum of 100 Square feet separate premises (permit room) within a radius of 20 meters of the shop should be available. For the permit room facility, a fee of Rs. 5,000/- will be charged for the financial year or any part of the financial year. The canteen facility will not be allowed in the permit room.’
Such policies and measures send an inaccurate message that some forms of alcohol are more” safe” or “better”.
Another misperception that the standard serving of beer, RTDs (Ready-to-Drink), or wine has less alcohol than distilled spirits comes from the fact that they have a lower ‘alcohol content’ or alcohol by volume (ABV) listed on the containers in which they are sold. ABV is a measure of how much alcohol is contained as a percentage of the whole container. The alcohol in a bottle of beer, wine, or RTD is more diluted than it is in a bottle of spirits. However, standard serve sizes always contain the same amount of alcohol, which takes into account the ABV. The number of standards served in a bottle of beer, wine, and distilled spirits will differ.
What matters is how much alcohol is consumed and not what type of alcohol is consumed. Over 30 countries have moderate or low-risk drinking guidelines. Such guidelines make no distinction between alcohol consumed as beer, wine, or spirits; rather they reference standard serving of alcohol or standard units. Standard serving sizes vary between different countries, but the most typical standard serving is defined as 10g of alcohol. Using the 10g definition of a standard serve, a 99ml glass of wine at 13% ABV, a 30ml measure of spirits at 42.8% ABV, or a 257ml glass of beer at 5% ABV all contain the same amount of alcohol.
India needs guidelines that recognise that alcohol is alcohol, and make no distinction between alcohol consumed as beer, wine, or spirits. Any taxation of alcoholic beverages should be part of a comprehensive fiscal and regulatory framework. Taxation should be proportionate, appropriate for each local context, and consistent with World Trade Organization principles. Taxation should neither create market distortions nor exacerbate issues of harmful consumption.
The International Spirits & Wines Association of India (ISWAI), the apex body of the premium AlcoBev sector, is an active advocate of progressive policies and Responsible Drinking and promotes the principle of ‘drink less, drink better’. The author of the article is Nita Kapoor, CEO, International Spirits & Wines Association of India (ISWAI).
ThePrint ValueAd Initiative content is a paid-for, sponsored article. Journalists of ThePrint are not involved in reporting or writing it.