The move is progressive and a step in the right direction. They must continue with the trend in the coming years, and ban such lists altogether.
What purpose do these merit lists serve anyway, besides giving students warped ideas of what achievement means and external validation?
These lists, which rank students on the basis of their exam marks, are an absolutely futile exercise. As we grow up, we realise how redundant these merit lists are, for that matter even exam marks are.
The merit lists in no way define our future lives.
But such lists have over the years only put unnecessary pressure on students and intensified the rat race in our flawed education system.
Stigma attached to low marks
The undue importance given to merit lists is actually a symptom of how India is obsessed with good grades in exams, and the stigma attached to low scores.
While in school, I remember that there were some groups, comprising students who all scored 90 per cent and above, who would not befriend low scorers. That was the norm.
I remember they would often discuss their aim to make it to the merit lists, and how they wanted to outperform each other. They also spoke about the pressure they faced from their parents to make it to the merit lists.
But what about students with low scores, or those who flunked and had to repeat a year? They were frowned upon by teachers and toppers alike, and were often treated as outcasts. I also remember how they felt intimidated by the toppers. The school’s scholarships were given out based on the merit lists, which led to even more disappointment for low scorers.
I never made it to the ‘sacred’ rankings list before Class 10. Till then, my parents had been disappointed in me, fearing that I would have no career if I wasn’t a rank-holder.
The superficial nature of merit lists affects parents too, because they are also under pressure from a society in which prying neighbours and relatives often ask — how much did your child score and what was her rank? We have all heard stories about parents promising children expensive gifts only if they stand first in class.
My parents did it too, and now they laugh about it having realised the futility of it all.
Employers look for talent, not toppers
In no job interview, have I ever been asked how much I scored in Class 10 or 12, and whether I was part of the merit list that year. It’s been a decade since I passed my Class 12 board exams, and my educational achievements are just another column in my resume now.
If students are aiming for high scores in the hope of landing jobs, they must know that employers never look for toppers — they look for someone with talent, determination, ability to work with others, the right set of skills, and a hard-worker.
These skills are unfortunately not what our education system builds in students. Instead of breaking their head over memorising history chapters or chemistry formulae, and obsessing over marks, students must strive to achieve skills and knowledge. After all, even toppers can be rejected if they don’t have the right set of skills required for the job, no matter how their brilliant academic record may have been.
Our school curriculum deprives students of vital cognitive life skills. There should be courses in schools that prepare students for the real world.
Reassuring social media posts
Right after the CBSE results were declared, several people on Twitter shared their old board exam marks to underline the fact that marks are not the be-all and end-all in life.
IAS officer Nitin Sangwan wrote on Twitter that he barely managed to pass his chemistry exam in Class 12, but that didn’t hinder him.
In my 12th exams, I got 24 marks in Chemistry – just 1 mark above passing marks. But that didn't decide what I wanted from my life
Don't bog down kids with burden of marks
Life is much more than board results
Let results be an opportunity for introspection & not for criticism pic.twitter.com/wPNoh9A616
— Nitin Sangwan, IAS (@nitinsangwan) July 13, 2020
Actor Sushant Singh also wrote about how his 74 per cent marks in Class 12 boards “didn’t define him”.
1989- I scored 74.5% in 12th Grade, CBSE. PCM stream. Couldn’t even get BA (Pass) in DU, somehow managed to get English Literature in KMC after clearing the written test. Graduated with 2nd division. These are just Marks, they don’t define who you are!! March on my young friends.
— सुशांत सिंह sushant singh سوشانت سنگھ (@sushant_says) July 13, 2020
I wish we also had such reassurance from successful individuals while growing up. I wish we had also been told that a report card, mark sheet, or merit list can never define who we are and our future. I wish we were told that it doesn’t matter how much we score in exams — what matters is how much we learn and how we capitalise on it.
Views are personal.
Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it
India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.
But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.
ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.