scorecardresearch
Wednesday, March 27, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionIn the next five years, Modi will need to fulfil promises without...

In the next five years, Modi will need to fulfil promises without blaming Congress

The argument that Modi is carrying the burden of 70 years will neither impress the unemployed youth nor the aspirational middle classes.

Follow Us :
Text Size:

Most Indian journalists are more obsessed with the unseen near future than with the immediate present. During election season, this obsession reaches its peak. It starts with poll predictions and the electoral prospects of parties in the Lok Sabha elections. Now that the results are out, bringing Narendra Modi-led NDA to power again with a massive mandate, journalists are busy predicting the induction (and removal) of ministers and their portfolios.

I have been a participant and addict of the media’s ‘game of thrones’ for over 40 years. Like Alcoholics Anonymous, I often feel there should be a ‘Mediaholics Anonymous’.

Many journalists and commentators have now begun to see beyond 2019. There are eyeing the 2024 Lok Sabha elections and wondering what the political scene will be. In the next five years, Modi and his ministers will have a lot to do, and no failure can be blamed on the Congress anymore.


Also read: Modi era begins in politics as caste factor fades. Here’s why he won’t be easy to beat


Who will be the political actors by 2024? Narendra Modi will be 73, and according to his own diktat on age limit, he will have to retire soon after that. Manmohan Singh’s Rajya Sabha term comes to an end next month. Lal Krishna Advani will be 96. Sonia Gandhi will be 77. Sharad Pawar will be 83. Most leaders of most parties will be in the departure zone.

Even today, ironically, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is not sure whether they can replace president Amit Shah. Will the new president perform as efficiently, as ruthlessly, and as strategically as Shah? Or is it better to continue with Amitbhai? The new president will have to be remotely controlled by both Shah and Modi. Will Amit Shah succeed Modi as the Prime Minister? And will he be as popular? Who else in the party can form the top caucus?

Modi and Shah are ruling India today as if they will be eternally in power —omnipresent, omniscient, omnipotent. There is no second line of command in the BJP beyond Modi and Shah. Modi’s governance style has made every BJP leader, minister and NDA associate dispensable. This is bound to create a leadership crisis in the near future.


Also read: This is what changed for voters from 2014 to 2019 Lok Sabha elections: Nothing


The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) stalwarts, including Sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat, have been sidelined. There is fear among their senior ranks that they will be marginalised further. During the last five years, Modi-Shah duo has supposedly built a parallel volunteer force. That must have alarmed the Sangh. Therefore, the relationship between the RSS and Modi-Shah will also affect the internal management of the party and administration by 2024.

Apart from the personalities and the Sangh, there are other urgent issues that could lead to a navigational crisis for the BJP. The economy is already in doldrums, notwithstanding the bravado and clever obfuscations of Arun Jaitley.

All of BJP’s well-wishers are expecting reforms, which have not been carried out in the first term. A large section of the corporate class is also waiting for special concessions. By and large, they are not happy with the semi-Socialist-welfarist-povertarian policies of the NDA government. But they also understood that the BJP needed populist tactics to come back to power.


Also read: Modi’s key test with Trump will be to ensure Make in India doesn’t clash with Make in America


The liberal commentators had condemned the National Advisory Committee chaired by Sonia Gandhi for its ‘pro-poor’ schemes, including MGNREGA (which was ridiculed most by Narendra Modi himself). These very schemes were incorporated by the NDA government and advertised by them in election campaigns. The same critics of the NAC, who are exceptionally considerate to Modi, had not shown similar sympathy for Manmohan Singh.

But declining domestic investment, slow or reluctant foreign direct investments, exports coming down and, of course, the farmer distress coupled with vast unemployment (mainly in the rural areas) are staring the BJP in the face. This time, Modi cannot run away from them by blaming the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty — from Motilal to Rahul, via Jawaharlal, Indira and “Bhrashtachari” Rajiv.

The argument that he is carrying the burden of the last 70 years will neither impress the unemployed youth nor the aspirational middle classes. The BJP and their trolling armies were always slanderous and abusive towards the so-called intellectuals, without realising that the Modi government lacks the talent to tackle real issues. This scarcity of talent in administration and party has often made the BJP leadership (and Modi personally) a laughing stock — especially on WhatsApp groups.

The Modi government has given a “follow on” to the opposition. It is unlikely that the opposition can match the NDA score in this inning. So, Modi cannot make Rahul Gandhi a target for his failures and divert issues. He will have to face them himself. He has built his image as an ‘invincible emperor’, with his massive media management. Now Modi, as well as embedded TV anchors, will have to prove that the emperor’s new clothes fit.

The author is a former editor and Congress member of Rajya Sabha. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

10 COMMENTS

  1. Succession planning is essential in any organisation, including political parties. In parties dominated by dynasty, there can be succession planning, but it will be always half baked, because top seats are already booked. Trouble mounts when the patriarch dies. There could conflict amongst successors, dissension and even split. In cadre based parties like BJP, succession planning does take place. The Congress President Rahul Gandhi was born on 19th Jun 1970. He is considered as a young politician. BJP too has many young politicians. Devendra Fadnavis ( 22 July 1970), Himant Vishwa Sarma ( 1 Feb 1969), Dharmendra Pradhan (26 Jun 1969), Yogi Adityanath (5 Jun 1972), Shahnawaz Husain (12 Dec 1968) , Kiran Rijuju ( 19 Nov 1971), Pema Khandu (21 Aug 1979), Viplab Kumar Deb ( 24 November 1971), Anurag Thakur (24 Oct 1974) and the youngest Tejaswi Surya (16 Nov 1990). These are all prominent third or fourth generation leaders. There could be more.. Any one of these can succeed Modi. Ideally, Modi should emulate George Washington and retire in 2024, thereby setting a convention that no PM/ CM should rule exceeding a period equivalent to two terms. Let us not worry about what happens in 2024. Even if BJP loses, it can always come back. Just see it’s bench strength.

  2. Although full of assumptions and presumption,let all Indians cooperate with Govt.to make a law that no Indian will have more than one child for next 50 years.be assured that all religions will have same percentage of population after 50 years.All the educated persons should educate masses that South Asia is highly populated area.Take the example of China.You can read the paper written by Pervez Hoodbhoy on Pakistan population.

  3. It would be a fair summation to say that the government will have to do in the next five years what would have been expected of it in the first ten. There is an immense backlog. The media, for the most, has not asked the tough questions, pretty much given a free pass. Even if that continues, that will not be enough of a shield.

  4. “This scarcity of talent in administration and party has often made the BJP leadership (and Modi personally) a laughing stock”
    Elitism on display again from self appointed experts on everything. Interestingly, you fail to find a talent outside of Gandhi-Nehru clan for leading the party, who have failed big time repeatedly in connecting with the people. Hmm, that statement is a bit rich, don’t you think?

  5. Shri Ketkar, please understand that the youth and women, including Muslim women, who voted for Shri Narendra Modi are not a part of your WhatsApp group. So it does not matter to them what amuses you. By being a Gandhi dynasty hagiographer for four decades, you have got yourself a Rajya Sabha seat and subsidised accomodation in Delhi. Enjoy it, while it lasts.

    • Well said, but remember you are communicating with a thick skinned vassal. He is paid to write trash, and particularly trash.

  6. Instead of self critical analysis of how and why his prediction for Congress winning elections failed, Kumar is now asking Modi not to blame for Modi’s likely failures in 2024 to Congress! He is counting Modi’s age and hoping he will at least be out by 2024. It would be better if Kumar tells us his age and when he plans to retire. That would be a relief but anyway, we also need some entertainment and of course, we will miss his sycophancy.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular