Friday, 2 December, 2022
HomeOpinionGlobal PrintThis is why PM Modi doesn’t really care about internationalisation of Kashmir...

This is why PM Modi doesn’t really care about internationalisation of Kashmir issue

Trump’s Monday call is important because it vindicates India’s position that the abrogation of Article 370 is an ‘internal matter’.

Text Size:

Late Monday evening, US President Donald Trump called Prime Minister Narendra Modi. According to official sources, their 30-minute conversation was “even better than the press release”.

The Indian officials sounded quite relieved. There has been a lot of bitterness in the India-US relationship of late, marked by Trump telling reporters, as he stood beside Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan at the White House, that Modi had asked him to mediate between India and Pakistan on Kashmir – the Indian government promptly denied the US President’s comments.

Even the spat on bilateral trade remains unresolved. It seems that US trade representative Robert Lighthizer has found little time to meet with Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal, even though Delhi is ready to roll back additional tariffs on several US products.

Last week, though, the Americans came out in support of Delhi when China, speaking on behalf of Pakistan, sought to castigate Delhi at the closed-door meetings of the UN Security Council called to discuss Kashmir. Along with France and Russia, the US prevented a formal statement from being issued.

Also read: Trump calls up Modi & Imran separately, calls for restraint in ‘tough’ Kashmir situation

Imran Khan’s insecurity

Trump’s Monday call is important because it vindicates India’s position that the abrogation of Article 370 is an ‘internal matter’. Modi evidently told the US President that “certain leaders in the region,” namely Imran Khan, were indulging in “extreme rhetoric and incitement to anti-India violence…”.

Certainly, Khan has outdone himself on the rhetoric front. A series of tweets on the weekend exposed both his insecurity and anger:

Now that the UN Observers haven’t caught a plane to Srinagar and even Trump doesn’t particularly look like he cares whether the two warring neighbours reach a nuclear flashpoint over Kashmir – he is probably more concerned about China massing armed police and armoured personnel carriers in nearby Shenzhen, within spitting distance of Hongkong –, it might be time for Pakistan to think up a real trick or two.

Also read: Modi speaks to Trump, says anti-India rhetoric not good for peace

Why Trump called Modi

So, what happened? Why did Trump call Modi?

The answer, perhaps, lies in Pakistan ambassador to the US Asad Majeed Khan’s comments to the New York Times a week ago. He said that in the wake of the abrogation of Article 370, the Pakistanis may have to redeploy their troops from the Afghan theatre to Kashmir.

Considering Trump was counting so much on the Pakistanis to deliver the Afghan timetable for peace, so that US troops could get back home as quickly as possible, Asad Majeed’s comments may have hit a raw nerve.

Certainly, Majeed cannot be faulted for thinking about blackmail in these tough times. With the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) noose closing in, the Pakistani ‘miltablishment’ (or ‘military establishment’ as Friday Times editor Najam Sethi puts it) has less and less money to pay for the conflict that has been bleeding India for decades.

Also read: Trump is no fool & this is why he deliberately lied about Modi’s Kashmir request

Imran Khan’s troubles

So, what happens when Pakistan is broke within and friendless without? Remember, only China came to its help at the UNSC last week. Moreover, how long is China going to bail out its client state when it has its own problems, like Hong Kong, to think about?

Poor Imran Khan. He is so completely out of his depth playing prime minister that he has even outsourced the running of the state to his army chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa, by extending him for another three years.

The bigger question remains: Does Gen. Bajwa’s ‘miltablishment’ want to keep quiet in the face of the massacre of innocent Shias in a wedding hall in Kabul in which 63 people died, all civilians? The Islamic State has taken responsibility for the attack – evidently, the IS has been responsible for 60 attacks between 2015-2017 in Afghanistan – which allows Gen. Bajwa to get away with the charade that the Taliban is hardly as dangerous.

As for Kashmir, the world remains watchful for signs of human rights violations in that Union Territory. France, Germany and others will do a U-turn at the sight of greater tension in the Valley. But one thing is clear: The international community is not about to challenge Narendra Modi’s unilateral abrogation of Article 370.

Nor does Modi particularly care about phrases like ‘internationalisation’ or the ‘will of the people’ of Kashmir that the world, for decades, has used to rap India on the knuckles with.

Also read: China says India’s Kashmir move ‘unacceptable’, undermines its territorial sovereignty

Eye to eye with China

As for China, the Trump call serves another purpose, which is that it allows New Delhi to look Beijing in the eye. Remember that Chinese president Xi Jinping is coming to India in October – and despite the fact that China took Kashmir to the UN Security Council, neither has called off the meeting or said anything critical about it.

This compartmentalisation of foreign policy tells us two things: First, that China wants a decent relationship with India, for fear of India taking US help to become the next Asian power. Second, support for ‘iron brother’ Pakistan comes at a huge price.

Modi will now follow up his conversation with Trump by flying off to countries like France and UAE later this week, which came out in support of India’s “Kashmir is an internal matter” statement. Modi will be back in Biarritz, France, for the G7 meeting on 25 August, where India is a partner country and therefore can sit only in some meetings.

Remember that the big boys – and Angela Merkel – will be at Biarritz. Certainly, Modi isn’t letting a photo opportunity like that slip by. As he told Trump on the phone, he is in New York next month for the UN General Assembly meetings. On the other hand, they may just say hello in Biarritz.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. For some people, we should always keep talking to Pakistan and also keep a very cool relationship with China. First coming to China, most untrustworthy for any deals. Nehru’s Indi-Chini Bhai Bhai backfired badly. Nehru showed India’s ordinance factory and China understood our capabilities those days and attached and took Aksai Chin. People feel they need to be trusted and we need to be close with them. When it comes to Pakistan, whom do you talk to in the establishment: Prime Minister, Army, Terrorists/Separatists and common Pakistani. With Army bulldozing everyone, any talk is futile.

  2. There are more dimensions to this. One would like to presume that the current Indian leadership understands the strategic importance of timing more than the governments that preceded it: (1) Trump’s foolish statement on being a mediator on Kashmir; (2) potential Pakistan-US collusion, compromising any opportunity for a DECENT civilian government in Afghanistan, and one that could have been detrimental to Indian interests; (3) Pakistan’s economic problems and FATF deadlines, creating a hot iron that could be stuck; (4) China’s Hong Kong dissent and questioning of Uyghur muslims.

    Currently, the world is tied up in knots. It is like the Congress party prior to Sonia’s re-election – like a headless chicken. No one knows who’s the boss, no one has the answers. One more knot will make no difference; Pakistan is too small a fish in this huge chaos.

  3. What an utter piece of crap this article is. Firstly, the writer gets exposed when she tries to snub Pakistan’s prime minister on the basis of what Modi called “extreme rhetoric.” It’s a fact all over India that Modi is a member of the RSS, a Hindu terror group which has a lot of similarity with the Nazis. Were Modi not an RSS member, one would agree with the claim that Imran Khan’s rhetoric is extreme. Secondly, the writer is trying to argue that Trump’s consultation on the Kashmir crisis has nothing to do with Kashmir crisis because in the thick-headed head of the writer, who is blinded by the Sangh’s hateful politics because she happens to be Hindu who buys their BS, Kashmir is still an internal matter of India, while the whole world knows it is not. It doesn’t matter that Modi has managed to have one corrupt Arab leader on his side after begging in the UAE, the fact remains that Kashmir is a dispute and the UN still considers it as a dispute. So journalists like Joti should do some introspection and try and be honest with her job.

    • Robin man calm down ! Chill !!
      IA Naya Pakistan, the dream project of your selected PM, is coming into existence soon. (Hint: It will be present Pak minus Baloch, pok and kp. )

    • RSS is not a Hindu terror group. Trump’s self invitation to mediate has more to do with indo-us trade than kashmir. Robin’s hindu phobia is quite obvious.

    • Shri Robinji or whatever is your name. Let me give you a completely different scenario. A couple of weeks back The Saudi owner Aramco invested 20 billion dollars in Reliance. Laxmi Mittal is investing close to 6 billion dollars in buying Reliance. Apple and other giants are again investing and establishing manufacturing bases in Bharat. There is ofcourse much more! Now let’s come to your dear country Pakistan, almost bankrupt, with your PM running around on his knees with a Katora in his hands, sucking the toe nails of Emirs to get a few Dollars. Forget comparisons with us, even Bangladesh is ahead of you. Focus in the next few years of putting a couple of rotis on your plate before you take a panga with us.

    • Pakistan & Supporters Don’t Have SHAME!! For Them, Everyone Is A Terrorist Besides Jihadi Terrorist Enterprise Of Pakistan!!

      Meanwhile, Thanks To Pakistan’s & Islamic Nations Support, #Xinjiang, #China’s #Concentration Camps have achieved what they had set out to do!!* #Uyghur #Muslims Now openly RENOUNCING #ISLAM. Go in as a #Muslim. Leave As an Atheist!!

      Lessons For India & The World??!!

Comments are closed.

Most Popular