Sunday, June 11, 2023
Support Our Journalism
HomeJudiciaryRemove references to victim's identity in Tarun Tejpal verdict, Bombay HC tells...

Remove references to victim’s identity in Tarun Tejpal verdict, Bombay HC tells Goa court

Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta Thursday told the HC that the observations made in the judgement and most of the findings with regard to the victim were ‘astonishing’.

Text Size:

Panaji: The Goa bench of the Bombay High Court on Thursday directed a sessions court, which recently acquitted journalist Tarun Tejpal in a 2013 rape case, to redact all references in its judgement which disclose the victim’s identity, before uploading it on the court’s website.

A vacation bench of Justice S C Gupte was hearing an appeal filed by the Goa government, challenging the May 21 judgement passed by sessions judge Kshama Joshi acquitting Tejpal in the case.

Tejpal, former editor-in-chief of Tehelka, was accused of sexually assaulting his then colleague in the lift of a five-star hotel in Goa in 2013 while they were attending an event.

The sessions court while acquitting Tejpal questioned the victim’s conduct, holding that she did not exhibit any kind of “normative behaviour” such as trauma and shock which a victim of sexual assault might plausibly show.

Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Goa government, on Thursday told the HC that the observations made in the judgement and most of the findings with regard to the victim were “astonishing”.

“The judgement, which is yet to be uploaded on the court’s website and made public, also in various paragraphs discloses the identity of the victim woman. This is a criminal offence,” he said.

The judgement discloses names of the victim’s mother and husband and also the victim’s email ID which indirectly reveals her (victim) name, Mehta said.

Justice S C Gupte said he would take care of this and passed an order saying, “Considering the law against disclosure of identity of victims in such offences, it is in the interest of justice to have these references redacted.”

“The trial court is accordingly directed to redact the references made in the judgement that disclose the identity of the victim before uploading the judgement on the court’s website,” Justice Gupte said.

Mehta told the court it was sad that the HC has to order this (redaction).

“The trial court ought to have been sensitive towards these issues,” he said.

Criticising the observations and findings in the judgement, Mehta further mentioned that the sessions judge says a victim of sexual offences should display trauma and only then her testimony can be believed.

“The system expects sensitivity apart from judicial jurisprudence while dealing with such matters. We owe it to the girls (victims),” Mehta said.

He also questioned references made in the judgement to the victim’s meeting with senior advocate Indira Jaisingh and other women lawyers to discuss the case before recording of her statement with police.

“This girl, who is a victim of sexual abuse, had approached senior and reputed advocate Indira Jaisingh. The girl rightly took advice from a woman lawyer. What is wrong with that?” Mehta said.

He told the court that the government, considering the seriousness of the matter, filed its appeal even before it received a copy of the judgement.

“We received a copy of the judgement only on May 25.

We would like to bring the judgement on record and also amend the grounds of challenge in the petition,” Mehta said.

The court allowed the same and posted the appeal for further hearing on June 2.

Also read: Victim’s evasive answers, lack of medical evidence — why Goa court acquitted Tarun Tejpal


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

Most Popular