Saturday, March 25, 2023
HomeJudiciaryNaveen probably forced to file FIR against woman at centre of CJI...

Naveen probably forced to file FIR against woman at centre of CJI case, says his mother

The mother of Naveen Kumar, who has accused the former SC employee of cheating him, says he's incapable of doing this on his own.

Text Size:

Jasaur Kheri: At Jasaur Kheri village in Haryana’s Jhajjar district, neighbours of Naveen Kumar wonder if employees of a finance company have turned up looking for him. “Personnel from a finance company keep coming here frequently,” says one.

Outside Kumar’s home, several knocks go unanswered. It’s only after a while that his mother emerges. She then explains her apprehension to open the door. Her son, she says, has told the family not to speak to the media ever since a media house published a photograph of her.

Kumar has also been staying away from the village after being sucked into a controversy engulfing the country’s apex judicial office — that of the Chief Justice of India (CJI). He is the complainant in a cheating case filed against the former Supreme Court staffer who has accused CJI Ranjan Gogoi of sexual harassment.

Kumar, 31, has alleged that the woman took Rs 50,000 from him after promising him a government job. Although the job didn’t materialise, she allegedly didn’t return the money and, instead, threatened him.

An FIR was filed against the woman in a Delhi police station on 3 March, with the Delhi Police now seeking cancellation of her bail.

Kumar’s mother, however, said that the family only learnt of the FIR two weeks ago.

“We got to know about the FIR and the entire matter only a fortnight ago,” she said. “These people are quite powerful; they can easily frame us even if we withdraw the FIR. But we are unable to convince our son to withdraw the case. Several other people have also threatened my son to withdraw the case.”

It’s a pattern throughout the conversation as the mother never refers to the woman or utters her name, instead continually saying “those people” or “powerful people”.

She does, though, state that the CJI case may have had a bearing on her son’s decision to file the FIR.

“The business of fleecing people in the name of government job is going on at several places here. This matter is also the same,” she says. “That woman alone cannot be blamed. But there is a possibility that some people pressured Naveen to file an FIR against her after she got involved in the controversy related to the CJI. Naveen is not capable of doing this on his own.”

Also read: Justice NV Ramana recuses himself from inquiry panel on allegations against CJI Ranjan Gogoi

‘Simple, straightforward man’

At Jasaur Kheri, Kumar, known as Rinku here, has a reputation of being a “simple, straightforward” young man.

“Naveen is a very simple lad,” says one neighbour. “He is too straightforward to cross paths even with any of the villagers. The entire family (kunba) is like that. They have lost around Rs 50,000. They might have arranged this money as a loan with interest.”

The family’s home is just 500 metres from that of Pradeep Deswal, the Jannayak Janta Party (JJP) candidate for the Rohtak parliamentary constituency.

Kumar’s father is a truck driver in Madhya Pradesh while his wife and mother are involved in the sewing business. The family also owns a buffalo. Only the mother, Kumar’s wife and his child are at home.

The mother says that Kumar works in a company in Bahadurgarh and has recently shifted to Chandigarh.

She says the media attention has been distressing and asks for her identity to be concealed.

And if villagers are to be believed, Naveen’s family was under tremendous pressure to file the FIR, which has now catapulted them into national headlines.

Also read: ‘Conspiracy’, tantrums, apology — how SC hearing unfolded in case about CJI Gogoi


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. There are serious allegations of sexual harassment against the CJI. We cannot absolve him without a proper investigation. It is easy to say he is being framed, but that’s what all accused say. The victim has filed a detailed affidavit and there has to be some substance to it. All senior lady lawyers must stand by the complainant and help her get justice.

  2. With due respect, the entire unveiling of event, calls for a biopic! Hope the chaiwala Chowkidar’s producer will take up this idea and make some quick buck to compensate for his lose in the earlier venture!

  3. But, the general perception is that the media houses and some corporate houses are trying to malign the image of the Hon. CJI. It is being orchestrated by the media houses to put pressure on the Hon. CJI to resign. Hon. Sri Ranjan Gogoi is the cleanest of PERSONS one could come across in any sphere of life. His uncompromising stand always tickles the favour seekers on their wrong sides. He is known for his principled judgements, never swaying from the path of neutrality. But, we the people from Assam, know very well that the Hon. CJI would not bend and bow down to these concerted immoral efforts of the media and corporate houses.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular