New Delhi: The Narendra Modi-government may have approved the proposal to grant the status of organised cadre services to the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), but paramilitary personnel still fear that IPS officers may circumvent the new rules to scuttle their career growth.
Worried that the ‘IPS lobby’ will not allow CAPF officers to avail benefits they are now entitled to, several retired officers from the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) – the oldest paramilitary force in the country – have sought a meeting with Home Minister Amit Shah.
Former Inspector Generals of Police (CRPF) – V.P.S. Panwar and S.S. Sandhu – have written to Shah requesting him for a meeting.
According to sources in the government, Shah is expected to visit the CRPF headquarters in Delhi on 29 July.
Given that serving officers in the force are bound by their service rules, and still report to IPS officers, the retired officers are in a better situation to express concerns of the forces, a serving CRPF officer told ThePrint.
“IPS officers are suddenly scared that they will lose hold over their fiefdom. They can do everything to scuttle our rights,” the senior officer said, on condition of anonymity.
‘Vested interests not inclined to execute order’
The Union Cabinet on 3 July gave its nod to the proposal to grant Non-Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU) and other pay benefits to officers of the paramilitary forces, which their counterparts in all ‘Group A’ organised services are entitled to.
“Despite the fact that the Ministry of Home Affairs has issued directions for implementation of the above order, the general perception prevailing in the minds of the officers is that the vested interests are still not inclined to execute the orders in a holistic manner,” Sandhu, a 1976 batch officer, has written in his letter addressed to Shah.
While the Cabinet’s nod now allows CAPF officers to head their own forces, it will still require framing of new rules for the cadre. The CAPF personnel worry that IPS officers will use all their clout in the government to “delay” this.
According to the Department of Personnel and Training rules, in ‘Group A’ organised services, appointments up to the position of SDG can take place only through promotions and lateral entry or appointments through deputation is only permissible if the former is not possible.
“Efforts are still being made to deny the rightful benefits and career aspirations of these officers,” Sandhu’s letter says.
Seeking “an exclusive hearing” for the officers of the CRPF, the letter further states: “I am afraid that efforts are being made by hectic and active parlance among DGs (directors general) and senior IPS officers to find ways and means to delay the implementation of government orders according to the guidelines of DoPT.”
“According to the circulated programme of your visit to the CRPF headquarters on 29 July, even the serving cadre officers have not been included for any interaction with you lest the design of the IPS officers brought to your kind knowledge by them,” the letter further reads.
Also read: The inside story of what CRPF jawans go through to keep our marathon elections free & fair
‘Deep roots of discrimination’
Both Panwar and Sandhu have cited the absence of a proper platform for retired CAPF officers to bring forth their grievances before the government. This, CAPF officers believe, is in contrast to to the Indian Army and other armed forces, which have designated platforms to voice their protest.
According to the serving CRPF officer quoted above: “The roots of discrimination against them are so deep that the initial jubilation among CAPF officers has been shadowed by some real concerns.”
Sandhu’s letter also throws light on other specific concerns. According to it, since 2008, “not a single post of policy decision-making has ever been given to (an) experienced officer of the cadre.”
“This is a pertinent point which needs attention of the Hon’ble Home Minister.”
“The post of IG (personnel) which deals with promotions, posting and establishment matters of officers, ministerial cadre, subordinate officers, cadre reviews, disciplinary proceedings also vigilance matters have been held by an IPS officer for the last more than four decades,” the letter further contends.
“These are deliberate efforts to project the cadre officers in poor light not only before the government but also in the eyes of their own subordinates.”
Serving CRPF officers also say that they cannot transfer or post their own subordinates even after 30-35 years of service and this dampens the morale of the entire force, diminishes their authority in front of their subordinates.
Similarly, the post of inspector general (operations) – which deals with operational matters and deployment of forces – and the inspector general (northern sector) – which deals with allocation of resources such as vehicles, infrastructure and accommodation – have all been kept “under IPS control,” Sandhu’s letter states.
“The reason for this is to keep the cadre officers out of decision making and authoritative positions to run their writ and to utilise the force and its resources as per their whims and fancies,” the letter reads.
In a separate letter to Shah, Panwar, who spent 39 years in service, has said it is important that the home minister is aware of the difficulties faced by both the retired and serving officers of the force so that “privations can be adequately addressed for future generation of officers and their families…”
This would “motivate them to perform their duties and serve the country with more zeal, dedication and determination.”
Also read: Pulwama makes it to election speeches, but CRPF & its problems are left out
Sab se Pahle ye samjiye sab log ki IPS central exam UPSC qualifie karke bante hai naki state pcs se exam dekar state police officer.
Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel academy Inka central institution hai yahi par cisf paramilitary k officers ka bhi training hota hai or IB recruitment hota hai hamare NSA sir bhi Pahle IPS the baad me IB me recruited ho gaye,,, or central exam upsc me se hi jo low marks pate hai vo CAPF comandent bante jo high marks pate hai vo IAS, IFS or jo fit hote hai or ache marks bhi pate hai vo IPS bante hai. Or jo Delhi k aas pass hai ya Delhi me hai unhe anubhav k liye Police Memorial Jana chahiye..
Bharat Mata ki Jai
Jai Hind
Pehle Puri jaankaari lelo fir bakwasbaazi Karna. First know the things and only then should you comment. Little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Get some life.
@prasanna….India got freedom from British colonism but became enslaved to IAS/IPS..due to soft sentiments by Sardar Vallabh bhai patel and other leaders…same IPS lobby recruited by britain to rule slaves in india and which brutelly tortured all freedom fighters, got inserted provision in constitution as article 312 AIS…Its high time that Modi ji implements recommendations of Administrative reforms Committe which Recommended abolition of IAS/IPS cadre many times.
Zero ground experiance, total curruption, colonial hangover are only qualities with these babus in unifirm.
What makes them capable of handling a paramilitary force akin to army in organisation and weapons…
Their work, traigning and recruient makes them unsuitable to handle such combatised forces. As far as present state of these PMF., its becouse of These uniformed babus sitting in AC offices these forces are suffering..hiw can u expect IG ops to control operation in jungles when he never saw any…never lead Battalion or a company…
Its high time we get rid of this last piller of British rule and these incapable non experianced babus in uniform..IPS..
if they still want to contribute…they should be send to PMF at Assst comdt level and must serve at least 7 yrs in field before being considered for any further deputation..only selected few who can handle field envuronment should be allowed..
we must understand job of PMF is way tougher than state police and an incompetent unexperianced uniformed babu is a sure recipe for disaster…
I neither belong to PMF nor IPS…
i have read ARC reports which never came into light becouse of lobby of these babus…
As a country we are moving towards a greater society and must remove these hurdles IAS/IPS….
Ironically…even Britain stopped thus kind of police structure long dacades back…
Too many agencies . No clearcut KRAs for each of them , each one having a feeling that they are supreme.
Reality is with little powers vested, the politicians are their road blocks and whatever the IQ level , qualification you have , an uneducayed brute in the disguise of politician will control and literally rules sidelining education, intelligence, perceptions, conviction of beuracrats.
If discrimination amongst the class, they should be central agencies and control states . Even people feel insulted when a third class minister insults an IAS, IPS officer.
Lot of introspection need to be done to make officers work like officers and not as buckets.
Amazed by the mockery of self proclaimed IPS know it all fancy jumbos. The comments here are a clear of example of how an IPS officer looks at non IPS officers. One fellow here quotes”Gadhon ke sarpe Taaj”, forgets the whole idea of IPS heading combat based organisation with desk job experience. The CAPF even insisted that if any one wishes to join them, can come at lower ranks to get enough on ground experience which is fair enough. There is no point appointing a hifi clerk as cheif of Ghatak Platoon. Or a south block Babu heading a para SF team. Same way forces like BSF, ITBP have no requirement for “the elite” IPS officers. 39 years of experience at Borders have worth to make a man lead the organisation. Further, motivation is a huge factor for such forces. Making incompetent IPS officers as policy makers is like asking a BCOM student to head a robotics research team. By the time he figures anything out , his time will be over and a new snowflake will join wthe club in his place.
The one and only one serious mistake of Respondent No.1-Union of India is :-
“ghadhoun ke sar par Taj lagaana” on which “nikkammey-nalaayak ghadhey” don’t have objection to get “Taj”. Nikkammey-nalaayak ghadhey are willingly happy and surprised to get “Taj”. Once “taj” is given to them, then it becomes necessary to give them “raaj” on civil public, lower level employees, with all luxurious/royal treatment with various benefits like speedy promotions along with NFFU(Non Functional Financial Upgradations) and higher salaries about to 2 to 4 lacs per month. Even then “gaddhey” don’t have satisfication.”
Due to which few of them missleaded government and got unfair benifits of “Organized Services” and “NFFU” they desired. Due to which funds of nation are wasting along with they were been empowered with higher positions of highly responsible central Security/Police agencies. Further, such positions to incapable NON-IPS officers may finally lead dissasterous results in Internal security of nation.
Above Said lines are Just for moral message. But, Straightly means that, Due to huge deficiency of capable IPS officers in Union of India. The Respondent No.1 recklessly appointing incapable NON-IPS official on the posts of Higher Authorities in Central Armed *POLICE* Forces also. Almost at every level from the Dy.Commandant-(Dy.SP), Second in Command, Commandant, DIGP, IGP and upto zonal DGP-Directorate General of Police “about 99%” Authorities are Non-IPS in CAPF(Central Armed *Police* Forces), and remaining just “1% IPS officers” can’t handle entire responsibilities of such a huge Central Armed Police Force Department in better way. Looking on Non-IPS officers unfair efforts to occupy all higher cadre DGP ranks in Central Armed Police Forces and situations it seems that further the remaining 1% IPS officers place may also be replaced by Non-IPS officers of CAPF. Therefore “officershahi”, “mannmani” “gundagardi, laparvahi, and gair-jimmedhari” by Incapable Non-IPS officers in Central Armed Police Forces, especially in CRPF(Central Reserve Police Force) is growing up and causing worst 36 types of all other worseness which the petitioner mentioned in 36 points sought through RTI on inhumanity matters i.e. Fratricidal, Suicidal, Accidental, Negligent Operational and Medical casualties, Illegal Activities, Injustice and Violations of human rights type complaints are at the peak level in CENTRAL ARMED POLICE FORCES especially in CRPF comparatively by settled State’s Police Forces departments etc operated by capable IPS officers. Now, at present situation of CRPF is gone to much more worst among other forces. In the same route from where ARMY, BSF and other forces convoys passes safely, but there the convoy of CRPF get hits a attack and losses above then 44 lives of innocent soldiers (Pulwama Attack). In LWE area, Where the Chattiagarh and other police force’s Greyhounds, SOG’s and STF’s are also conducting successful Anti-Naxal operations there the CRPF losses 75 innocent Soldiers within a single attack. There are thousands of such examples in which CRPF is getting failed and loosing huge count of men in negligent operations. Even on looking on such worst ground level performance of lower formations headed by NON-IPS officers, even then Union of Indian government Declared CAPF as “Organized Service” and started replacing higher level posts of CAPF headed by civils-standard IPS officers with incapable Non IPS paramilitary grade officers.
Internal Security strategies are going worst day by day. At present Internal security Policing were divided into two types of “Organized Services” 1) Non IPS standard Paramilitary/CAPF and 2) Civils IPS standard State governing Police Forces. Looking on such foolish security strategies of Government to to provide various types of enjoyments to incapable Non IPS Police authority in Central Government Police Agencies it seems further Defence of Nation may also divided into different organized services and create Problems to Presidency Rules of Nation. Also Non-civils qualified officers of other organizations would also demand the same for them, on which it may trouble system of nation. Till now there was two types of ideal Securities for Nation i.e
1) Defence-Army, Navy, Air Force.
2) Police for internal Security-CAPFs alongside State Polices.
The people of nation availed still now. But recently Policing of nation is looking like two different type of Police organized services :-
1) IPS quality State Police organizations and
2) Non-IPS Standard Central Armed Police Forces.
Therefore, Respondent No.1 may advised to don’t allow incapable Non-IPS officers to occupy higher level posts of Central Policing Agencies made for dealing civilians, and if possible clear deficiency of IPS officers in CAPF and resolute all above faults in better manner as deemed fit for entire sufferers of Military treatment of security in civil society comes under Home ministries. Looking on 36 Information of worst outputs it is not suitable to allow ground level operating officers to replace higher authorities level Police Force General’s posts holding by civils Standard qualified IPS officers. Showing sympathy of soldiers beeing killed/martyred under close command directions of Non-IPS officers the Non-IPS officers gained”organized services” and “NFFU” benifits. Such benifits may boost moral of Non-IPS officers but not useful for people of nation or their soldiers in any mean. Adversely such Decision of Union of India may cause more losses and damages to soldiers and civil people harshly. Lower level formations Commanding by Non-IPS officers in CAPF forces were failures at ground level performance but from now onwards CAPF may cause dissaster entirely. Non-IPS headed CAPF may break all past records of human rights voilations, suicidal-fratricidal-operational-casualities, criminal activities, service relevant injustice and all disaster may form new level of world records. Dicision of Non-IPS officers for central policing agencies may cause huge loss to civil people of nation.
Such Hell directions of Union of India by choosing Non-IPS officers for high command and loosing intelligence civil IPS officers who were been shield of CAPF by replacing with Non-IPS officers is totally unfair for all. Straightly means “maarey jaay Jawan.. or faaydha officers aur nethaon ko”. Hence, Such benifits are not beneficial for “Jawan” in any manner. It would be better if such funds wasting to provide useless benifits to incapable officers may utilized to provide extra benifits to NOK’s of Martyr/killed soldiers to boost moral of Soldiers moral of determination, dedication and sacrifices. The most important matter of shame is that, by providing such useless benefits, the union of India shut the mouths of CAPF officers before announcement of “Martyrdom” status was rejected to their soldiers who were been killed at Pulwama-Kashmir by Pakistan based organization. Actually, when a foreign organization/national attacks on Nation in any mean, on which if any people/soldiers sacrifice themself to protect Nation is straightly means as “Martyrdom”. But union of India is not ready to recognize such sacrifices of our soldiers. But ready to offer benefits to CAPF officers unconstitutionally to be quit and enjoy benefits on basis of sympathy gained from soldiers been killed.
Hence, I just want to request that, In case, the respondent is unable or can’t clear the deficiency of capable IPS officer in Central Police Organizations, then, the respondents may kindly explain about such departmental and constitutional provisions due to which Respondents are unable to provide sufficient capable IPS officers for highly Responsible Central Police Organizations with brief explanation on such major defects of Non-IPS officers who can’t even make or take a perfect Operational, Administrational and Judgments resulting causing huge causalities and inhumanty type of Injustice etc in Central Armed Police Forces.
Hence, the Gazetted Officer wearing decoration of “Ashok Sthamb” the symbol of “Sathyamev Jayathey” on shoulder upon uniform may/shall/must be a loyal and Intelligent IPS officer for better Policing and Internal civil security of Nation please.
Dear ,you are saying gadhe to CAPF officers,very good assessment done by you fool and it was expected from stupids and fools only which you have now proved. I heard about stupidity but now it confirmed me that stupidly exits in the man called as IPS officer. You are real stupid and I on many occasions served with IPS officer,so I know much much better about their conduct,their caliber and their potentiality to deal with situations. The IPS officer are nither fit enough to serve usefully instated nor they are capable to understand any of situation on ground while serving in CAPF. They are dame zero as far as leadership is concerned,and are total liabilities on government of India. The recruitment of IPS officer be completely be stopped as it huge wastage of money, they get timescale promotion and most of are sitting at home without any assignments. You IPS officer comes to central deputation only after completing full circle of failure in own state ,where state level politicians kicked them daily.
This is high time that a separate service cadre for the central paramilitary forces should be created. Keeping in view the nature of their job which very tough than army and always there is risk to life, this will be moral booster for the forces. In addition to this the personnel of these forces should be extended all benefits after retirement which an ex-army man gets.
Fact: IPS Officers come to the CAPF only at the rank of DIG and above. Long story short , their posting to the CAPF is more like a vacation of sorts . Then there are the cadre officers who are appointed at the rank of AC and work their whole career in their respective forces but are denied the opportunity to lead and take part in policy decision making in the very organisation they have served their whole career. One glaring aspect to be considered is that most of these policies directly affect the soldiers,s.o and officers at the operational/ battalion level. Policies which are framed by people who swoop in at the top level without any proper experience at ground level. So what do you expect of the CAPFs? It’s right there for all of us to see the pathetic condition of the forces at present. The attiration level in the forces speakers for itself.
Speaks*
Can the IPS officers ready to work in border areas like indian army??? no they want so comfort and cosy lavish lifestyle ..many officers r not doing duties well in civilian society ,then hw can they tackle the problems created by violent terrorists and maoists. This is not that much easy wandering in cities and district headquarters with armed bodyguards.the convoys of CAPF can be attacked anytime by terrorists in the jungle, everyone must carry assault rifle.the officer inside that convoy vehicle is not an ips officer.he may be assistant commandant or deputy commandant or commandant ranked cadre officer. If they survived they would get promoted as DIG s and get retired. Not given proper timely promotions, every day living on a land mine,carrying their weapons and fighting for nation. Hw they r honoured still?? Nothing. So this is the time to honour their sacrifices,martyrdoms. Many young guns r resigning from AC posts of CAPF. respect their service. Jaihind
I mean not in favour of this system..
Because Deputation is the part of….. Exchange of vision..
Because of IPS officers.. Deputation*** CAPF are getting these advantages..
2. Best coordination among civil police and CAPF,
3. Best legal support from Civil police
4. Best idea of New IPS officers .. Will make a drastic change in the forces..
5. Mutual understanding among all paramilitary forces and civil police, Snd armed forces
6. Lower rank will get more officersahi*** because of this system
Don mix up CRPF problems and few directly recruited Gazetted officer’s ambitious service related desires as one and same. Also don’t misinterpret court’s verdict. SC did not allow IPS to present their version, as IPS not going to be affected. This was stated by SC in its judgment in last para. 40 percent of IPS recruitment is meant for manning posts under Govt. of India. They are being recruited for the last 70 years in the same manner. Where will this 40% already recruited IPS would go? Can govt. recruit some one and after serving for few years can say, now the post is not for you?
What ever kind of assessment you did may be good for your own consumption ,but sorry ,how you arrived at this self cooked story that CAPF officers get benifits and knowledge from IPS officer,with even knowing views from CAPF officers. This is totally a fiction type story may be useful for you but none of CAPF officers is interested in you IPS officer,as they are timid, cowards and nonfunctional as they are in their own states. In state also they works as Babu and all field kind of duties and work is done by state level police officers. They do nothing in state and run away from states for comfortable life in CAPF. Nothing can be gained from IPS officer as they hardly have any knowledge about the functioning and duties of CAPF.
The one and only one serious mistake of Respondent No.1-Union of India is :-
“ghadhoun ke sar par Taj lagaana” on which “nikkammey-nalaayak ghadhey” don’t have objection to get “Taj”. Nikkammey-nalaayak ghadhey are willingly happy and surprised to get “Taj”. Once “taj” is given to them, then it becomes necessary to give them “raaj” on civil public, lower level employees, with all luxurious/royal treatment with various benefits like speedy promotions along with NFFU(Non Functional Financial Upgradations) and higher salaries about to 2 to 4 lacs per month. Even then “gaddhey” don’t have satisfication.”
Due to which few of them missleaded government and got unfair benifits of “Organized Services” and “NFFU” they desired. Due to which funds of nation are wasting along with they were been empowered with higher positions of highly responsible central Security/Police agencies. Further, such positions to incapable NON-IPS officers may finally lead dissasterous results in Internal security of nation.
Above Said lines are Just for moral message. But, Straightly means that, Due to huge deficiency of capable IPS officers in Union of India. The Respondent No.1 recklessly appointing incapable NON-IPS official on the posts of Higher Authorities in Central Armed *POLICE* Forces also. Almost at every level from the Dy.Commandant-(Dy.SP), Second in Command, Commandant, DIGP, IGP and upto zonal DGP-Directorate General of Police “about 99%” Authorities are Non-IPS in CAPF(Central Armed *Police* Forces), and remaining just “1% IPS officers” can’t handle entire responsibilities of such a huge Central Armed Police Force Department in better way. Looking on Non-IPS officers unfair efforts to occupy all higher cadre DGP ranks in Central Armed Police Forces and situations it seems that further the remaining 1% IPS officers place may also be replaced by Non-IPS officers of CAPF. Therefore “officershahi”, “mannmani” “gundagardi, laparvahi, and gair-jimmedhari” by Incapable Non-IPS officers in Central Armed Police Forces, especially in CRPF(Central Reserve Police Force) is growing up and causing worst 36 types of all other worseness which the petitioner mentioned in 36 points sought through RTI on inhumanity matters i.e. Fratricidal, Suicidal, Accidental, Negligent Operational and Medical casualties, Illegal Activities, Injustice and Violations of human rights type complaints are at the peak level in CENTRAL ARMED POLICE FORCES especially in CRPF comparatively by settled State’s Police Forces departments etc operated by capable IPS officers. Now, at present situation of CRPF is gone to much more worst among other forces. In the same route from where ARMY, BSF and other forces convoys passes safely, but there the convoy of CRPF get hits a attack and losses above then 44 lives of innocent soldiers (Pulwama Attack). In LWE area, Where the Chattiagarh and other police force’s Greyhounds, SOG’s and STF’s are also conducting successful Anti-Naxal operations there the CRPF losses 75 innocent Soldiers within a single attack. There are thousands of such examples in which CRPF is getting failed and loosing huge count of men in negligent operations. Even on looking on such worst ground level performance of lower formations headed by NON-IPS officers, even then Union of Indian government Declared CAPF as “Organized Service” and started replacing higher level posts of CAPF headed by civils-standard IPS officers with incapable Non IPS paramilitary grade officers.
Internal Security strategies are going worst day by day. At present Internal security Policing were divided into two types of “Organized Services” 1) Non IPS standard Paramilitary/CAPF and 2) Civils IPS standard State governing Police Forces. Looking on such foolish security strategies of Government to to provide various types of enjoyments to incapable Non IPS Police authority in Central Government Police Agencies it seems further Defence of Nation may also divided into different organized services and create Problems to Presidency Rules of Nation. Also Non-civils qualified officers of other organizations would also demand the same for them, on which it may trouble system of nation. Till now there was two types of ideal Securities for Nation i.e
1) Defence-Army, Navy, Air Force.
2) Police for internal Security-CAPFs alongside State Polices.
The people of nation availed still now. But recently Policing of nation is looking like two different type of Police organized services :-
1) IPS quality State Police organizations and
2) Non-IPS Standard Central Armed Police Forces.
Therefore, Respondent No.1 may advised to don’t allow incapable Non-IPS officers to occupy higher level posts of Central Policing Agencies made for dealing civilians, and if possible clear deficiency of IPS officers in CAPF and resolute all above faults in better manner as deemed fit for entire sufferers of Military treatment of security in civil society comes under Home ministries. Looking on 36 Information of worst outputs it is not suitable to allow ground level operating officers to replace higher authorities level Police Force General’s posts holding by civils Standard qualified IPS officers. Showing sympathy of soldiers beeing killed/martyred under close command directions of Non-IPS officers the Non-IPS officers gained”organized services” and “NFFU” benifits. Such benifits may boost moral of Non-IPS officers but not useful for people of nation or their soldiers in any mean. Adversely such Decision of Union of India may cause more losses and damages to soldiers and civil people harshly. Lower level formations Commanding by Non-IPS officers in CAPF forces were failures at ground level performance but from now onwards CAPF may cause dissaster entirely. Non-IPS headed CAPF may break all past records of human rights voilations, suicidal-fratricidal-operational-casualities, criminal activities, service relevant injustice and all disaster may form new level of world records. Dicision of Non-IPS officers for central policing agencies may cause huge loss to civil people of nation.
Such Hell directions of Union of India by choosing Non-IPS officers for high command and loosing intelligence civil IPS officers who were been shield of CAPF by replacing with Non-IPS officers is totally unfair for all. Straightly means “maarey jaay Jawan.. or faaydha officers aur nethaon ko”. Hence, Such benifits are not beneficial for “Jawan” in any manner. It would be better if such funds wasting to provide useless benifits to incapable officers may utilized to provide extra benifits to NOK’s of Martyr/killed soldiers to boost moral of Soldiers moral of determination, dedication and sacrifices. The most important matter of shame is that, by providing such useless benefits, the union of India shut the mouths of CAPF officers before announcement of “Martyrdom” status was rejected to their soldiers who were been killed at Pulwama-Kashmir by Pakistan based organization. Actually, when a foreign organization/national attacks on Nation in any mean, on which if any people/soldiers sacrifice themself to protect Nation is straightly means as “Martyrdom”. But union of India is not ready to recognize such sacrifices of our soldiers. But ready to offer benefits to CAPF officers unconstitutionally to be quit and enjoy benefits on basis of sympathy gained from soldiers been killed.
Hence, I just want to request that, In case, the respondent is unable or can’t clear the deficiency of capable IPS officer in Central Police Organizations, then, the respondents may kindly explain about such departmental and constitutional provisions due to which Respondents are unable to provide sufficient capable IPS officers for highly Responsible Central Police Organizations with brief explanation on such major defects of Non-IPS officers who can’t even make or take a perfect Operational, Administrational and Judgments resulting causing huge causalities and inhumanty type of Injustice etc in Central Armed Police Forces.
Hence, the Gazetted Officer wearing decoration of “Ashok Sthamb” the symbol of “Sathyamev Jayathey” on shoulder upon uniform may/shall/must be a loyal and Intelligent IPS officer for better Policing and Internal civil security of Nation please.
The IPS are meant to serve civil police not CAPF or paramilitary forces which are “Other Armed Forces” of the nation. The IPS are administrative jobs and cant head combat forces like CRPF, BSF etc. Moreover they lack desired field experience and commanding capabilities. If they wish to serve CAPF then they must join in the ranks of Asst Comdt/Deputy Comdts before becoming DIGs /IGs. They are the most corrupt people and their image is zero in the eyes of common people. They are spoiling the CAPF in the same manner as they have done the civil police. Hats of to the Hon’ble HC Delhi and Hon’ble SC to give the long due to paramilitary officers. Every force must be headed by its own officers. The IAS and IPS must be restricted to their limits. Its NEW INDIA…Modi ji’s India and not of the Britishers.
You can’t fight the nexus of IAS n IPS cadre. What do you think they have not degraded Armed Forces? At least in your case SC have given verdict that CAPF will be given NFU. Today I feel among all Central government services Armed Forces is the weakest and worst services, with toughest of the job and no carrier progression for 70% officers beyond the rank of Lieutenant Colonel.
Don mix up CRPF problems and few directly recruited Gazetted officer’s ambitious service related desires as one and same. Also don’t misinterpret court’s verdict. SC did not allow IPS to present their version, as IPS not going to be affected. This was stated by SC in its judgment in last para. 40 percent of IPS recruitment is meant for manning posts under Govt. of India. They are being recruited for the last 70 years in the same manner. Where will this 40% already recruited IPS would go? Can govt. recruit some one and after serving for few years can say, now the post is not for you?