scorecardresearch
Friday, March 29, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeIndiaGovernanceAt the heart of potato farmer’s Rs 490 ‘gift’ to Modi, a...

At the heart of potato farmer’s Rs 490 ‘gift’ to Modi, a crisis in India’s aloo mandi

Follow Us :
Text Size:

Pradeep Sharma, a UP potato farmer, scored a profit of just Rs 490 on 19 tonnes of produce.

New Delhi: The 19 tonnes of potatoes he harvested from his field fetched Uttar Pradesh farmer Pradeep Sharma all of Rs 2 lakh. After he factored in the expenses, it left him with a net profit of just Rs 490.

Frustrated, Sharma dispatched the sum as a “New Year’s gift” to Prime Minister Narendra Modi with a note: “Aap rakh lijiye (You can keep it)”.

Sharma’s “gift” comes as the NDA government at the Centre finds itself facing criticism that it doesn’t care about farmers.

Last year, two massive farmers’ protests shook the national capital, with demonstrations organised in other parts of the country as well, including Mumbai.

The farmers demanded a better minimum support price (MSP) and freedom from debt. Their plight went on to become a massive poll issue in the run-up to the assembly elections in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh in 2018.

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which heads the NDA, lost all three states, the loss primarily attributed to farmers’ disenchantment with the government’s policies.


Also read: Heavy debts alone are not driving farmers to suicide


‘No relief’

For the last 25 years, Sharma and his family have been growing potatoes on his 15-acre farm near Agra.

While crop prices have never been a constant, in the last four years his suffering has been aggravated by near total financial loss, he told ThePrint. The last time he received relief from the government was in 2008-2009.

“Earlier, the losses were not so acute,” Sharma said “I have sold potatoes for Rs 5/kg too, but managed to get through.”

He said he had written to the Prime Minister about his “debilitating financial condition” in 2015 as well, but received no response.

“My loans amount to nearly Rs 32 lakh. While some farmers’ loans were waived in UP, I have never received a single penny from the government till date,” he said while lashing out at Modi and Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

In 2017, the UP government had decided to waive farm loans of up to Rs 1 lakh, but the execution has been marred by controversies.

“I have two sons. One is in Class 8, and the other is doing his BA (Bachelor of Arts),” Sharma told ThePrint. “My brother works for less than Rs 10,000 a month in Agra just so we can pay my elder son’s college fee.”

ThePrint tried to reach UP agriculture minister Surya Pratap Shahi and various other office-holders in the ministry for comment, but did not receive a response. This report will be updated as and when they respond.

The potato conundrum

Uttar Pradesh is India’s largest potato producer, accounting for 35 per cent of the country’s total harvest.

An increase in production over the last few years has led to a sharp decline in the value of potato. The UP government sought to intervene in 2017 by fixing the minimum support price for potato at Rs 4.87/kg, but this was dismissed as inadequate by farmers.

According to Alamgir, the general secretary of the Agra Potato Famers Committee, nearly 3 lakh tonnes of potatoes from last season remain in cold storage in western UP.

When Sharma attempted to sell his produce in the local market in December, he found no takers since the market was already overpopulated with others attempting to sell potatoes.

“I spent nearly Rs 2 lakh shipping my produce to Akola, Maharashtra, since no one in Agra wanted to buy potatoes,” he said. “After all the money I spent, I was left with just Rs 490. What good will that do? My family comprises 14 of us in total.”

“Wholesale price of potatoes is around 4-5 rupees a kg, but due to a surplus of production, no one wants to purchase more potatoes,” he told ThePrint.

The Agra Potato Farmers Committee wants the government to fix a minimum support price for potatoes, like they did with paddy last year.

Farmer leader B.M. Singh told ThePrint, “We flagged the anticipated costs and MSP during the two farmer protests in Delhi last year. Only if the government adopts the Swaminathan Commission report will farmers be able to increase their income.”

The Swaminathan Commission report suggests that MSP for farmers be fixed at 50 per cent more than the cost of production.

Sharma now believes his only option lies in selling off a part of his land since, he says, farming has become practically unfeasible under the present government.

“The only thing I can think of is selling the land. The least they can do is help me with that,” said Sharma.


Also read: Congress misleading farmers on loan waiver, says PM Narendra Modi


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

2 COMMENTS

  1. My view is that all small and medium farmers need freedom to sell their produce in a market place of their choice, not necessarily in markets of Agriculture Produce Marketing Committees, where it is often said deals are not transparent.
    I believe farming can be profitable if farmers stand on their own legs, without too much government help. In fact, farmers have to help themselves by setting-up their own organizations (but not cartels) which could provide them technical advice, farming tips, market information and marketing support whenever needed. I also believe that through these organizations, farmers can augment their income from noncore farm activities like sale of milk, eggs, etc.
    There is an increasing tendency on part of many farmers to demand loan waiver and other financial assistance. In extreme cases of distress this type of assistance should be provided to all small farmers. But it cannot be a routine affair.
    Is it not time that we deal with problems of all small farmers (who own less than two hectares of land) on a priority basis? If these farmers face difficulties on account of natural disasters like drought or untimely rain and need financial support it is our Central & State governments’ responsibility to mitigate them. In this connection I believe citizens living in metros, cities, towns etc will gladly pay a special tax/surcharge on income tax, proceeds of which tax can go to needy farmers’ bank accounts.

  2. There are similar heartbreaking stories from many parts of the country. However, the government cannot be in the business of procuring highly perishable agricultural commodities – barring wheat and rice for the PDS – from farmers at prices above market, storing, transporting and then selling them, obviously at a substantial loss. Knee jerk measures, generally taken on the eve of elections, will not provide durable, sustainable solutions. For a start, the next government might wish to appoint as Krishi Mantri a person who understands deeply what the problems are and can work effectively with state governments to place agriculture on a better path.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular