Tuesday, December 6, 2022
HomeHealthCovaxin approved as it's more likely to act against mutant Covid strain,...

Covaxin approved as it’s more likely to act against mutant Covid strain, says ICMR chief

In an interview, ICMR chief Balram Bhargava addressed questions that have been raised about the approval granted to Covaxin in the absence of efficacy data.

Text Size:

New Delhi: Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin is more likely to act against the mutant Covid-19 strain as it is based on the whole virus rather than targeting some parts of it, Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) Director General Dr Balram Bhargava has said.

In an interview to ThePrint, Bhargava stated that this was one of the considerations for giving it a conditional nod even though there is no clear data available for the efficacy of the vaccine.

“We know that the virus has undergone mutations including in the spike protein. Pfizer has said that they will need six weeks to modify the vaccine. But because Covaxin is basically the whole virus killed, it is more likely to act against the mutant strain too,” he said.

“Simply put, if there are say 1,000 points in a vaccine, of which two have mutated, this is still going to have 998 points to generate a response, unlike others such as mRNA vaccines, which target specific areas and may not work as well when those areas mutate,” he added.

This, he added, was one of the considerations for the government drug regulator’s subject expert committee (SEC) as it recommended conditional approval for the vaccine. The vaccine was Sunday approved by the Drugs Controller General of India (DCGI) for emergency use, along with Oxford-AstraZeneca’s Covid-19 vaccine Covishield.

The ICMR chief expressed hope that the vaccine would start being procured soon for the national immunisation programme. “This is a great day for Indian science, India and low- and middle-income countries in general. Once we start using it, they can too,” he said.

Bhargava, however, added that he was not aware of any decision to allow export of the vaccine just yet or on when it would be available in the open market.

Bhargava’s remarks come as questions have been raised about the approval granted to Covaxin in the absence of efficacy data.

The hope that Covaxin may work against the mutant strain finds a mention in both the official DCGI statement Sunday, as well as Saturday’s statement from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.

Also read: Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin given conditional nod based on incomplete Phase 3 trial results data

No Phase 3 efficacy data available

Covaxin is a collaborative effort between the ICMR and Bharat Biotech, which means that India will have an indigenous vaccine in the Covid-19 vaccination programme right from the start. The virus on which the pharmaceutical company developed the vaccine was isolated early on at the National Institute of Virology in Pune.

Asked if there is any data on how efficacious Covaxin is against the SARS-CoV-2 virus, mutated or otherwise, Bhargava said: “They do not have a figure yet. But they have submitted efficacy data in rats, mice, monkeys. There is also some efficacy data from the phase I and II trials, and you can extrapolate from there.

“Moreover in phase III it has been administered to 22,000 subjects and has been found to be extremely safe. The SEC has met for 6-7 hours each for two days and they have gone into all aspects.”

For both Covaxin and Covishield, Bhargava added, the trials would continue, as would rolling reviews.

“As I have been repeatedly saying for all of last year, we have been consistently ahead of the (Covid) curve. This is a very good proactive and preemptive move by the Government of India and a victory of Indian science. We have now also successfully cultured the mutant virus strain in ICMR,” he added.

Covaxin has been having trouble recruiting volunteers for phase III trials.

In a statement late Saturday night, Suchitra Ella, Joint Managing Director of Bharat Biotech, said, “We thank every volunteer who has taken the time to participate in this trial. Their volunteering spirit is a great morale boost for India and the world. We thank all the principal investigators, doctors, medical staff & the hospitals for their cooperation & support in taking the phase 3 trials forward in 26,000 volunteers in India. We continue our progress towards achieving the goal of 26,000 participants for Phase-3 clinical trials of Covaxin.”

Also read: Strict follow-up, informed consent from recipients — conditions set for cleared Covid vaccines

Questions are already being asked

The approval for Covaxin, however, has already led to expressions of concern.

The All India Drug Action Network (AIDAN), a network of several NGOs working in the field of healthcare, said it was “shocked to learn of the SEC’s recommendation to grant REU (restricted emergency-use) approval”.

“Disturbingly, it appears that no efficacy data for the vaccine candidate were submitted from the phase 3 trials that are ongoing and are being conducted by Bharat Biotech and ICMR. The only data for humans, available through publication pre-prints, are of safety and immunogenicity from Phase 1 and Phase 2 trials across a total of 755 participants,” it added in a statement.

Demanding that the trial data be made public, the AIDAN also questioned the claim that the vaccine would work against the mutant strain as there is no such scientific data in the public domain.

It asked for the approval to be reconsidered.

On Covisheld, too, the AIDAN asked for clarity on the dosing schedule that has been approved and the efficacy estimates for that.

An earlier version of the report erroneously stated that the hope of Covaxin’s potential against the mutant strain doesn’t find a mention in the official DCGI statement. The report has been updated to correct the error.

Also read: Covid vaccination drive based on election process, planned to poll booth level, says govt


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. No doubt Bharat Biotech type of vaccine will be the most effective vaccine. All Indians should appreciate, congratulate the scientists and the company for their hard work and excellence. Request public not to criticize the company instead criticize the agencies like ICMR, DCGI, Health Ministry etc which need to share all data regarding it’s efficacy and safety with the public. If scientifically it is proven an effective and safe vaccine, every Indian will line up to take this type of vaccine compared to other narrow target vaccines… But please don’t short circuit due scientific processes regarding safety and and don’t make the Indian public guinea pigs in a secret experiment.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular