Under PM Modi, India got back more stolen antiquities in 3 years than the UPA government in 10 years

PM Narendra Modi returning with artifacts from the US in 2016. Source: Narendra Modi official site.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visits abroad often have a return gift. He has brought back more than a dozen historical artifacts from the United States, Australia, Canada, Germany and Singapore. 

SANYA DHINGRA

Since 2014, the Indian government has retrieved 24 Indian antiquities from around the world that were either stolen or smuggled out. In contrast, from 2009 to 2014, just one such object was brought back to the country, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has said.

“There has been some momentum in the last 2-3 years (in bringing back Indian antiquities),” D.N. Dimri, Director (Antiquities) at the ASI, told ThePrint. He said he could not claim that the change has been spurred by the BJP coming to power but agreed that the country has made “significant gains in the recent past”.

Between 2004-09 no such objects were brought back, an official from the ASI said. In fact, between 1976 and 2013, a total of 13 antiquities had been brought back to India, she said.

Bringing back Indian artifacts and cultural heritage remains a “key element in India’s foreign policy”, a government official told ThePrint. The return of these historical objects is part of the “restoration of India’s pride and an acknowledgement of history” as well as a projection of India’s soft-power, the official said.

Over the last two years, 16 objects have been brought back from the US alone. When Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited the US in 2016, the US agreed to return 200 antiquities to India. However, a year and another visit later, only 16 of the 200 objects have been returned.

The government official said they were not aware of the exact status of the rest of the objects.

According to records updated until March from the Ministry of Culture, between 2000 and 2016 a total 101 antiquities have been stolen from Centrally Protected Monuments. However, experts estimate that the actual number of stolen objects over the years runs into several thousands. What is recovered, or even identified, remains a drop in the ocean.

“There has never been a concerted effort by the Indian government (to bring back stolen objects),” said Sudha Gopalakrishnan, former director at the National Mission of Manuscripts. She said that even the maintenance of existing antiquities, let alone stolen ones, barely meets international standards. “Antiquities are scattered all around. They don’t even have a concerted list of antiquities,” Gopalakrishnan said.

The lack of a concerted governmental effort and political apathy for decades had also prompted a handful of private citizens groups to become active.

In 2013, a group called India Pride Project began lobbying efforts to bring back lost antiquities. Its founder, Anuraag Saxena, describes the group as one of “random, mid-IQ guys working on Skype and WhatsApp on weekends”.

Saxena and his partner Vijay Kumar are both Singapore-based NRIs, and he says they were frequently incensed to see Indian heritage scattered in other parts of the world. “It is bureaucratic failure that creates us activists,” Saxena said.

With a core team of 11 members with independent jobs of their own, and volunteers around the world, Saxena says his group coordinates with the government, international agencies, museums and a small, tightly-knit global curator community to investigate cases of missing antiquities. He speaks of secret investigations, back-channel negotiations and encrypted communication, but hesitates when it comes to divulging the level of engagement with the government.

Gopalakrishnan, who claims to have “heard of the group”, says that it is indeed “perplexing” how the group carries out its activities. “It is laudable if they have found a foolproof way (of identifying and tracing stolen antiquities), but I’m not sure how feasible it is,” she said.

Dimri echoes Gopalakrishnan’s scepticism. “Till date, we have not received any authentic information from this group. We don’t know who they have been giving information to,” he said.

Of the five cases the group claims to have solved, one involved conducting the investigation for bringing back the 11th century Chola statue of a dancing Shiva from Australia, which was handed over to Modi by his Australian counterpart Tony Abbott in 2014. The group’s website also lists its work toward the repatriation Sripuranthan Nataraja, Sandstone Yakshi, Bronze Ganesha and Uma Parameshwari.

The website, in fact, states: “The Mughals plundered us. Then the colonials. It’s time to get our Gods back home.”

A historical art curator, who spoke to ThePrint on the condition of anonymity, said that the group is ideologically driven and only investigates Hindu-antiquities. He also said that outsourcing the task of recovering lost heritage to non-governmental organisations or private individuals is fraught with risks:

“(As a private individual) I will always bring back what suits my version of history,” he said.

5 COMMENTS

  1. The group of individuals under Pride Project, who have worked hard to source or rediscover these stolen statues have put in tremendous work and have been instrumental in most of these jobs. They have been doing this only out of passion.

    It is true that the govt has not extended their support to them, ASI and their officers will never recognize these people, because it is the ASI’s job that they are doing. What have these officers ever brought back when they worked??
    And these guys have specialized in Hindu statues and temples, these officers who claim to be a mast of all have nothing tangible to show!!!
    It’s time we recognize the people behind Pride Project and support them.
    Even if these officers doesn’t support them, could they at least stop helping the smugglers and stop the loot!!!

  2. Dimri and Sudha are good ( should I say, terrible/) examples of govt babus who have failed to move an inch to get their jibs done. People in the know of things are aware of the excellent work done by Vijay and Anuraag who have been not only active but also speaking at various fora across the country, creating awareness on theft and transport of Indian ( note Indian, not Hindu) artifacts. The ‘historical art curator’ who wishes to remain anonymous but likes to be quoted should be added to the list of two above

  3. The job carried out by the group and government are complementary to each other! The interest on the idols and the powers to bring back them back to India can not be expected to be possessed by either government or the group! But there must be a right person there in the government who uses both the group and the govt machinery effectively to bring back the idols. There is nothing wrong in the group being interested in Hindu idols. If there is another religious group finds details about stolen antiques pertaining to other religion this group also may be used by the Government! Actually Hindu idols , that too from south India are stolen a lot. Because they are more in numbers! Who is Gopalakrishnan? Who is Dimri ? Are they part of any group? What is their interest?

  4. UPA government, some of the leaders were involved in smuggling out our Indian antiques. Present government is bringing some of them back.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here