scorecardresearch
Wednesday, March 27, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionModi-Shah-Bhagwat play good cop-bad cop to win 2019 elections

Modi-Shah-Bhagwat play good cop-bad cop to win 2019 elections

Follow Us :
Text Size:

This BJP strategy also inherently carries the risk of sending out contradictory messages to voters.

The troika of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, BJP president Amit Shah and RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat seem to be pursuing a good cop-bad cop strategy for 2019 Lok Sabha elections.

The coming months are likely to see Modi continuing to play the role of a statesman who believes in ‘sabka saath, sabka vikas’ (with all, development of all), gender justice (regardless of his silence on Sabarimala in contrast with his outspokenness on triple talaq), and diversity of culture and beliefs. He has to be the embodiment of everything that aspirational India looks for. He has to be the leader of ‘future India’.

The role of the RSS sarsanghchalak and the BJP chief is to ensure that Hindus feel a sense of empowerment and attachment with the ruling dispensation at the Centre. This is why the Sangh and the BJP have suddenly woken up from slumber to raise the pitch once again on the construction of the Ram temple in Ayodhya. This is an issue Modi hasn’t uttered a word on since he hit campaign trail in 2014. In the past four weeks, Bhagwat has repeatedly demanded the construction of the Ram temple at the earliest, “whichever the way and whatever the means”.


Also read: Opposition can’t oppose Ram temple openly, says RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat 


The BJP chief has endorsed him, emphasising that “the fact” about the destruction of the temple cannot be sidestepped. Shah is, in fact, emerging as a hard-core Hindutva proponent, repeatedly raising the Ram temple issue, vowing to throw away illegal Bangladeshi migrants, or “termites” as the BJP chief prefers to describe them, and declaring the government’s determination to send “behind bars” “voices that speak of dividing the country”.

Opposition leaders have been left wringing their hands in despair as they see the ruling party’s attempts at “polarisation” ahead of the elections. They have no clue about how to counter it, except through implicit participation by making temple visits an essential part of the poll campaign.

Each in the Modi-Shah-Bhagwat troika seems to be playing his defined role to perfection. Modi is a strong and decisive Prime Minister of whom the world is in awe and, in the case of the immediate neighbours, fear. He would also have people believe that unlike the past governments that worked for “one family”, he is working for all, giving them toilets, houses, health insurance, cooking gas cylinders, electricity, and everything else under the sun. With him in the saddle, everyone should hope to realise his or her dreams in the New India of 2022.

And if some people are sceptic about these claims and promises, they could turn to Bhagwat and Shah, who would help them in rising above temporal considerations and contributing their might to the larger cause of Hindutva.

In 2014, Modi’s appeal transcended castes and communities, helping the BJP shed its Brahmin-Bania-party tag and expand its base among OBCs and Dalits. This expansion has caused unease among its core votebank though. The party’s top leaders are conscious of it and have asked party chief ministers to address it.


Also read: Data shows Modi-led BJP can’t bend too much to please upper caste vote base 


They are also conscious of the growing voices of discontent from several OBC groups and Dalits who had very high expectations from an OBC Prime Minister. The saffron party is so unsure about its hold over new caste constituencies that it has postponed its plan to shake the caste cauldron by sub-categorising the OBCs.

The commission set up to give its recommendation on the sub-categorisation has been given several extensions. These dilemmas confronting the BJP strategists explain the saffron party’s return to the Ayodhya temple as also to the plank of cultural and muscular nationalism.

There are elements of assumption and risks in the BJP’s good cop-bad cop strategy for 2019. The aspirational India, Modi’s core constituency, may not take kindly to Bhagwat’s and Shah’s attempts to derail the development discourse. To assume that they would continue to repose faith in Modi while discounting the words and actions of other members of the troika could be foolhardy. An issue like Ayodhya temple that India of 1980s and ‘90s responded to may not evoke much response in 2019 when GenNext across urban-rural divide has different priorities.

The strategy also inherently carries the risk of sending out contradictory messages to voters. Modi might have been projected as Hindu Hriday Samrat post-2002 Godhra riots but a significant section of people voted for his ‘vikas purush’ avatar in 2014. It was the latter that created a ‘personal votebank’ for Modi, over and above his party’s.


Also read: What Narendra Modi and Amit Shah have learnt from BJP’s India Shining debacle 


Opposition strategists such as Jairam Ramesh of the Congress – who otherwise believe that people vote for the party and not individuals — grudgingly concede that “7-8 per cent” of the voters might have voted for Modi, the individual, in 2014. The BJP runs the risk of losing this chunk of voters with its polarising narrative, which also betrays the saffron party’s lack of confidence in the Modi government’s development pitch.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

5 COMMENTS

  1. I am really enjoying the theme/design of your site. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility problems? A number of my blog readers have complained about my website not working correctly in Explorer but looks great in Safari. Do you have any suggestions to help fix this problem?

  2. Let us give credit to Kumar Ketkar for his efforts . Many may agree that his analysis based on historical analysis and throw light on some issue we normaly, avoid to mention openly.

  3. 2019 elections results rude shock like Delhi /Bihar election results for the saffron /spent forces. Not a cake walk like 2014 elections. Anti establishment votes will overthrow this autocratic style of rulers. Even Lord Ram slogans will boomerang on BJP.

  4. Some kind of “Samudra Manthan” is indeed going on in the Hindutva fraternity. In the older version God made the Devatas win. Let us see what He has on His mind this time around! My gut feeling is that the BJP will split after the 2019 elections.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular